Trump Can’t Block Probe of Jan. 6 Attack on Capitol

November 10, 2021 by Dan McCue
Trump Can’t Block Probe of Jan. 6 Attack on Capitol
Protesters approach the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021.

WASHINGTON — Former President Donald Trump cannot block access to White House records from a House panel investigating the Jan. 6, 2021, siege on the U.S. Capitol, a federal judge ruled.

“While broad, these requests, and each of the other requests made by the committee, do not exceed the committee’s legislative powers,” U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan wrote in her decision.

Trump’s attorneys had argued the materials requested — telephone records, visitor logs and other documents — were covered by the legal doctrine of executive privilege which protects the confidentiality of some White House communications.

Specifically, Trump had requested an injunction blocking the National Archives, the federal agency that now holds his administration’s records, from complying with the committee’s requests for hundreds of pages of documents.

“Plaintiff argues that the public interest favors enjoining production of the records because

the executive branch’s interests are best served by confidentiality and defendants are not harmed by delaying or enjoining the production,” Chutkan wrote, summing up Trump’s argument.

“Neither argument holds water,” she said. “First, the incumbent president has already spoken to the compelling public interest in ensuring that the Select Committee has access to the information necessary to complete its investigation. 

“And second, the court will not give such short shrift to the consequences of ‘halt[ing] the functions of a coordinate branch,’” Chutkan continued. “Binding precedent counsels that judicially imposed delays on the conduct of legislative business are often contrary to the public interest.

“Accordingly, the court holds that the public interest lies in permitting—not enjoining—

the combined will of the legislative and executive branches to study the events that led to and

occurred on Jan. 6, and to consider legislation to prevent such events from ever occurring

again,” she said.

Chutkan also weighed in on the committee’s argument that discovering and coming to terms with the causes underlying the Jan. 6 attack “is a matter of unsurpassed public importance because such information relates to our core democratic institutions and the public’s confidence in them.”

The judge said she agreed with that statement.

“As the Supreme Court has explained, ‘The American people’s ability to reconstruct and come to terms’ with their history must not be truncated by an analysis of presidential privilege that focuses only on the needs of the present.’

“The desire to restore public confidence in our political process, through information, education, and remedial legislation, is of substantial public interest,” Chutkin concluded.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., called the ruling “an important victory for the Constitution, the rule of law and the American people.”

“No one can be allowed to stand in the way of the truth — particularly not the previous president, who instigated and encouraged the insurrection. As the ruling states,”‘Presidents are not Kings, and plaintiff is not president,’” Pelosi wrote in a statement released while she was attending the COP26 climate summit in Glasgow, Scotland.

“The violent domestic attack on Congress on Jan. 6 was an attempt to overthrow the government and to subvert American democracy itself. This ruling clearly reaffirms the power and importance of the Select Committee to pursue its prerogative to conduct oversight and find the truth, to protect the Capitol and defend democracy,” Pelosi said.

Trump has already filed a court notice indicating he would appeal the decision.

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and at https://twitter.com/DanMcCue.

A+
a-
  • Donald Trump
  • executive priviledge
  • National Archives
  • Tanya Chutkan
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Law

    March 25, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    DC Attorney General Warns Sports Teams About Relocating to Virginia

    WASHINGTON — The District of Columbia’s attorney general is invoking a contract provision with local professional sports teams in the... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The District of Columbia’s attorney general is invoking a contract provision with local professional sports teams in the city’s latest bid to keep them from relocating to Northern Virginia. D.C. Attorney General Brian Schwalb told Monumental Sports and Entertainment in a letter last week... Read More

    March 22, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Judge Upholds DC Law Giving Noncitizens Voting Rights

    WASHINGTON — A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit Thursday against the District of Columbia Board of Elections that sought to... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit Thursday against the District of Columbia Board of Elections that sought to invalidate a law giving noncitizens a right to vote in local elections. The Local Resident Voting Rights Amendment Act would allow anyone who is a resident... Read More

    March 20, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Trump Wins Right of Appeal to Try to Disqualify Georgia Prosecutor

    ATLANTA — Former President Donald Trump is getting another chance to exclude a prosecutor he accused of political reprisal in... Read More

    ATLANTA — Former President Donald Trump is getting another chance to exclude a prosecutor he accused of political reprisal in his upcoming criminal trial in Atlanta on charges of illegally trying to overturn the 2020 presidential election vote count in Georgia. Trump asked the judge overseeing... Read More

    Pro-Trump Michigan Attorney Arrested After Hearing in DC Over Leaking Dominion Documents

    An attorney facing criminal charges for illegally accessing Michigan voting machines after the 2020 election was arrested Monday after a... Read More

    An attorney facing criminal charges for illegally accessing Michigan voting machines after the 2020 election was arrested Monday after a hearing in a separate case in federal court in Washington, D.C. Stefanie Lambert was arrested by U.S. Marshals after a hearing over possible sanctions against her... Read More

    March 15, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    Fani Willis Can Continue Case Against Trump With Single Condition, Judge Rules

    ATLANTA — Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis can continue to pursue an election interference case against former President Donald... Read More

    ATLANTA — Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis can continue to pursue an election interference case against former President Donald Trump and several others — as long as the prosecutor with whom she had a romantic relationship steps aside, a judge in Georgia ruled on Friday.... Read More

    March 13, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Georgia Judge Dismisses Some Charges Against Trump

    ATLANTA — Former President Donald Trump and his co-defendants facing criminal prosecution in Georgia for trying to overturn the 2020... Read More

    ATLANTA — Former President Donald Trump and his co-defendants facing criminal prosecution in Georgia for trying to overturn the 2020 presidential election won a partial court victory Wednesday. A Georgia judge dismissed six of the 41 charges against the former president and his accused fellow conspirators.... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top