Supreme Court to Decide Liability of Transit Agencies After Accidents

July 3, 2025 by Tom Ramstack
Supreme Court to Decide Liability of Transit Agencies After Accidents
A Chicago commuter train after it collided with rail equipment in November 2023, injuring more than 20 people, some of them critically. (Associated Press)

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court agreed Thursday to determine whether New Jersey Transit is immune from liability as a state agency.

The public transit agency was sued by two men who were hit and injured by commuter buses in separate accidents.

In one case of a collision between a bus and a car in Philadelphia, a Pennsylvania court ruled the agency benefits from the same immunity as any other state agency.

In a separate case of a man hit by a bus in Manhattan, a New York court disagreed. It said New Jersey Transit could be sued like any other common carrier.

The Supreme Court is being asked to resolve the differences of opinion.

A Supreme Court ruling against the transit agency would significantly increase liability risks and insurance costs for public transit nationwide. The most likely result could be higher fares for passengers.

Transit agencies often generate some of the highest lawsuit payouts among states that operate them.

In 2021, New Jersey set a record for itself by compelling the state to pay $196 million for lawsuit settlements. The 22 most expensive cases, each with settlements of at least $1 million, resulted from public transit accidents.

A key issue before the Supreme Court is whether New Jersey Transit should be considered the “alter ego” of the state.

New Jersey Transit is a regional public transportation system based in Newark. Although it operates primarily in New Jersey, it also has rail and bus operations that extend to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and New York’s Penn Station as well as the surrounding areas.

Each of the three states shares regulatory oversight of the transit agency.

The alter ego doctrine is a legal concept that determines which of two affiliated organizations should be liable in lawsuits.

In general, when one entity exercises significant control over the other’s operations, policies and decision-making, they are considered alter egos of each other and share legal liabilities. The control can be determined by the degree they share money and management.

If they are not alter egos, each entity is separately liable in lawsuits.

In the Pennsylvania case, the state Supreme Court said New Jersey Transit operated like the alter ego of the state, thereby giving the transit agency the same sovereign immunity as the state. The court dismissed the lawsuit of Cedric Galette, who was injured while he was a passenger in a car that collided with a New Jersey Transit bus in August 2018.

In the New York case, the courts said the transit agency was independent from the state based on its separate budget and the high degree of autonomy of its management.

As a result, the lawsuit by Jeffrey Colt against New Jersey Transit was allowed to continue. He was injured by a bus in 2017.

New Jersey Attorney General Matt Platkin encouraged the Supreme Court to resolve the confusion over what he described as “different readings” of relevant laws in a brief he filed in April. 

“The split is entrenched, reflecting different views of this court’s decisions and the principles underlying state immunity alike,” Platkin wrote. The differing opinions create an “untenable split in which New Jersey finds itself.”

He said that rather than have potential lawsuit liability spread out among three states, they should be concentrated “in the forum where New Jersey has consented: its own state courts.”

The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear the case during its next term, which begins in October. 

The case is Cedric Galette v. New Jersey Transit Corporation.

You can reach us at [email protected] and follow us on Facebook and X

A+
a-
  • liability
  • Supreme Court
  • transit accidents
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Law

    July 10, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Justice Dept. Whistleblower Program Offers Big Rewards for Antitrust Information 

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department on Wednesday announced a whistleblower program that would give potentially large rewards to anyone who... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department on Wednesday announced a whistleblower program that would give potentially large rewards to anyone who reports antitrust crimes. The crimes typically involve organized deception that hurts consumers, taxpayers and free market competition. Whistleblowers who provide the Justice Department with original information... Read More

    July 10, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Federal Judge Certifies Class Action in Birthright Citizenship Case

    CONCORD, N.H. — A federal judge on Thursday barred the Trump administration from ending birthright citizenship, reviving a legal standoff... Read More

    CONCORD, N.H. — A federal judge on Thursday barred the Trump administration from ending birthright citizenship, reviving a legal standoff with the White House just days after the Supreme Court blocked federal judges from using nationwide injunctions to thwart the president's policies. Ruling from the bench... Read More

    July 9, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Pediatricians Sue Kennedy Over ‘Unscientific Changes’ to Vaccine Policy

    WASHINGTON — The American Academy of Pediatrics and a half dozen other major medical groups sued Health Secretary Robert F.... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The American Academy of Pediatrics and a half dozen other major medical groups sued Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Monday for making “unilateral, unscientific changes to federal vaccine policy” that they contend are an “assault” on science and public health. In a... Read More

    July 8, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Gun Rights Groups Sue to Block National Firearms Act Enforcement

    WASHINGTON — A coalition of Second Amendment advocates is suing to invalidate gun ownership restrictions that were revised by the... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A coalition of Second Amendment advocates is suing to invalidate gun ownership restrictions that were revised by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act President Donald Trump signed July 4. The bill removes many of the National Firearms Act taxes associated with gun ownership. The... Read More

    July 8, 2025
    by Alexa Citrin
    Trump Crackdown on Pro-Palestinian Campus Activists Goes to Trial 

    BOSTON — A trial over the Trump administration’s attempts to deport international students and scholars involved in pro-Palestinian activism on... Read More

    BOSTON — A trial over the Trump administration’s attempts to deport international students and scholars involved in pro-Palestinian activism on college campuses began on Monday with the plaintiffs arguing the efforts threaten to upend free speech rights enshrined in the U.S. Constitution. “Not since the McCarthy... Read More

    July 7, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    FBI Report on Sex Trafficker Prompts Elon Musk to Accuse Trump of Cover-Up

    WASHINGTON — A new FBI report on the 2019 jailhouse death of financier and convicted sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein has... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A new FBI report on the 2019 jailhouse death of financier and convicted sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein has reignited a feud between President Donald Trump and his former billionaire ally Elon Musk. The FBI concluded that Epstein committed suicide in jail, despite conspiracy theorists... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top