Judge Could Soon Order SC Republicans to Hold 2020 Primary
WASHINGTON – A circuit court judge in South Carolina heard more than two hours of oral arguments Friday in a lawsuit challenging the state GOP executive committee’s vote last month to forgo a 2020 Republican presidential primary.
In the end, Circuit Judge Jocelyn Newman indicated her ruling will be handed down in a matter of weeks. If she does ultimately decide the case in favor of the plaintiffs, the state Republican primary will be held Feb. 29, 2020.
Drew McKissick, South Carolina’s GOP chairman has argued that given President Donald Trump’s incumbency and continued popularity among voters in the state, a primary is unnecessary.
He’s said to hold a contest anyway would waste an estimated $1.2 million in taxpayer funds just to confirm a foregone conclusion.
In addition, an attorney for the state party said Friday that the executive committee’s actions last month were not unusual. State Republicans also opted not to hold presidential primaries in 1984 and 2004, when Republican presidents were running for re-election, and the S.C. Democratic Party did the same in 1996 and 2012.
But earlier this month, former Rep. Bob Inglis and another Republican voter, Mount Pleasant businessman Frank Heindel, sued the state party over the decision, arguing it violated party rules and state election law.
In a statement, Inglis said, “I am asking the court to require that the South Carolina Republican Party Executive Committee follow its own rules and the law.
“A small handful of party insiders broke the law to deny me — and every other South Carolina Republican — our voice in picking our nominee for president,” he said.
A central question raised during Friday’s hearing was whether state voters have a right to participate in a presidential primary election?
“If we’re talking about a June primary or a general election, then absolutely, the right to vote is sacrosanct,” argued attorney Butch Bowers, who is representing the state party.
“Here, we have a [presidential preference primary],” Bowers said. “If a party decides they want to nominate by convention, they can do so. And if they do so, that means that voters don’t have the right to vote.”
Bowers and co-counsel, Robert Tyson, Jr., went on to argue voters have other ways to participate in the selection of Republican National Convention delegates, such as participating in county and precinct conventions to choose the delegates who ultimately get to attend the national party convention where a nominee is selected.
But attorney Bess Durant, who represented Inglis and Heindel, said she didn’t see how the selection of delegates could be considered “in the same category or even the realm of the right to vote.”
“This is not fair and this is not proper,” DuRant said of the GOP’s decision not to have a primary.
She also noted that party rules require officials to begin the process of canceling the primary two years before the actual contest.
Because it didn’t do that, Durant contends the GOP is bound by a provision of law that says parties wishing to hold a convention rather than a primary must obtain the support from both three-fourths of the attendees of its convention and from the majority of voters in that primary.
Lawyers for the GOP countered that state law — which focuses on changing from presidential primary to convention nomination — only applied if the party were to decide to participate in the primary.
Newman closed the hearing asking both sides to submit a proposed order to her within ten days.
In The News
ALLENTOWN, Pa. — Northampton County election officials on Tuesday uncovered more than 200 votes that had not been part of the initial tally, affecting the result of the Lower Saucon Township Council race and adding to the problems the county had in tabulating votes on election... Read More
When Chesa Boudin learned he had won a tight race to become San Francisco’s new district attorney, he was flying home from a visit with his father at a prison in upstate New York. Boudin was 14 months old when his left-wing activist parents were incarcerated... Read More
A federal judge in Ohio ruled the state must discontinue its practice of disenfranchising eligible voters who are arrested and held in pre-trial detention in the final days leading up to an election. The case has its roots in the 2018 midterm election. Just days before... Read More
North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper vetoed a bill earlier this week that would have removed foreign citizens from voting rolls. At the same time, he signed into law a bill that restores early voting on the last Saturday before elections. “Only citizens should be allowed to... Read More
LEXINGTON, Ky. — A growing number of Republican lawmakers are urging Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin, a fellow Republican, to either provide evidence of the voting “irregularities” he has alleged or concede Tuesday’s election to Gov.-elect Andy Beshear, who defeated him by 5,189 votes. “The best thing... Read More
KANSAS CITY, Mo.—Kansas City took a step Wednesday toward becoming the second city in Missouri to ban conversion therapy for minors following more than an hour of emotional testimony from a packed room of LGBTQ residents and advocates. Conversion therapy, often associated with religious groups, is... Read More