Court Sides With Insurers in Denying Restaurants Coverage for Pandemic

March 13, 2023 by Tom Ramstack
Court Sides With Insurers in Denying Restaurants Coverage for Pandemic
District of Columbia Court of Appeals. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — A restaurant group lost out last week at a Washington, D.C., court in their attempt to recover lost profits from the COVID-19 pandemic under their insurance policies.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia said the restaurants failed to prove they suffered any physical damage to their property, which is required before their insurers must cover their losses.

The restaurants in Rose’s 1, LLC, et al. v. Erie Ins. Exch. argued their business interruption policies were supposed to protect them against the kind of natural disaster created by the pandemic.

It resulted in a government-ordered shutdown of restaurants and other retail establishments as the pandemic sickened millions of Americans. It also continued to keep customers away after the quarantine orders were lifted.

From the time the shutdown orders were issued in March 2020 until the devastation for the industry eased in June 2021, an estimated 90,000 restaurants and taverns were forced to close, according to the National Restaurant Association.

The original lawsuit was filed in D.C. Superior Court by Washington, D.C., restaurant business Rose’s 1 LLC, doing business as Rose’s Luxury, along with more than a dozen other restaurants. The Restaurant Law Center and the Restaurant Association of Metropolitan Washington filed an amicus curiae brief that agrees with the restaurants.

Business interruption insurance “is designed to protect the business’ commercial viability by allowing it to meet its ongoing obligations and to replace lost revenue when confronted with a sudden, unplanned closure,” the brief says.

The failure of the insurance policies to list exclusions for pandemics is a risk assumed by insurers, the brief says.

“District law requiring insurance contracts to be construed in favor of the insured should apply with particular force here, where insurers were aware of pandemic risk yet failed to exclude it in unambiguous terms,” the brief says.

The D.C. Court of Appeals disagreed based largely on policy terms that allowed coverage only for “direct” and “physical” losses. The court’s ruling said that “loss of covered property must be tangible and material,” which did not include customers staying away because of a disease.

The court concluded that “‘direct physical loss of or damage’ does not include a loss of use, and coverage of ‘all risks’ does not mean that coverage can be extended beyond the policy’s terms.”

You can reach us at [email protected] and follow us on Facebook and Twitter

A+
a-
  • COVID-19
  • federal appeals court
  • insurance
  • pandemic
  • Restaurants
  • US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Insurance

    What to Know About Renters Insurance and What It Does and Doesn't Cover

    NEW YORK (AP) — When the unexpected happens — whether fire, hail, or human error — renters insurance can provide much-needed... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — When the unexpected happens — whether fire, hail, or human error — renters insurance can provide much-needed stability. But many choose not to purchase coverage, including in places most frequently and hardest hit by natural disasters, new research shows. Linda Klamm, who works as... Read More

    August 21, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Hospitality Community Under Threat Due to Soaring Liability Insurance Rates

    CHARLESTON, S.C. — Three years after the coronavirus pandemic temporarily shuttered bars and restaurants across the state of South Carolina,... Read More

    CHARLESTON, S.C. — Three years after the coronavirus pandemic temporarily shuttered bars and restaurants across the state of South Carolina, soaring liquor liability insurance rates threaten to close them permanently, according to the members of a local grassroots business organization. The group, SC Venue Crisis, was... Read More

    July 25, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Biden Administration Proposes New Regulations for Mental Health Insurance Providers

    WASHINGTON — The Biden administration renewed controversy with insurers Tuesday by proposing a regulation that would require health insurance plans... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Biden administration renewed controversy with insurers Tuesday by proposing a regulation that would require health insurance plans to prove they are covering mental health costs at the same level as any other health care. Insurers say it will drive up the cost of... Read More

    Biden Launches New Push to Limit Health Care Costs

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden on Friday rolled out a new set of initiatives to reduce health care costs:... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden on Friday rolled out a new set of initiatives to reduce health care costs: a crackdown on scam insurance plans, new guidance to prevent surprise medical bills and an effort to reduce medical debt tied to credit cards. Biden's remarks... Read More

    April 26, 2023
    by Kate Michael
    Medicaid Work Requirements Making Headway at the State Level

    WASHINGTON — Every so often the idea of imposing work requirements in Medicaid comes through Congress. Well, the concept is... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Every so often the idea of imposing work requirements in Medicaid comes through Congress. Well, the concept is making headway again, and this time at the state level.  Currently, Arkansas is the only state to have implemented work and reporting requirements in Medicaid, requiring... Read More

    Cosmetic to Critical: Blue States Help Trans Health Coverage

    PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — For most of her life in New Mexico, Christina Wood felt like she had to hide... Read More

    PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — For most of her life in New Mexico, Christina Wood felt like she had to hide her identity as a transgender woman. So six years ago she moved to Oregon, where she had readier access to the gender-affirming health care she needed... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top