Bullock Attacks Money in Politics as Super PAC Goes After Daines
WASHINGTON — When Montana Gov. Steve Bullock launched his bid last year for the Democratic presidential nomination, he said he aimed to “defeat the corrupt system that lets campaign money drown out the people’s voice.”
Although his White House effort flopped, Bullock’s money-in-politics messaging had deep roots, including his unsuccessful challenge, as Montana’s attorney general, to a landmark Supreme Court decision that led to unlimited-spending super PACs. Now, Bullock is taking on incumbent Republican Sen. Steve Daines in a pivotal race that could determine which party controls the chamber next year.
As outside groups, including super PACs, line up to spend money on the race, sources of political cash, as well as policies to limit or regulate it, will be a point of contention in the dueling campaigns.
The coronavirus pandemic and resulting economic calamity promise to take the spotlight in the race, but already political ads and campaign rhetoric aim to link campaign finance matters and the crisis.
“Voters need even more assurance that politicians are working for them, not corporate interests,” said Tiffany Muller, president and executive director of End Citizens United, a group that takes its name from the 2010 Supreme Court decision that Bullock challenged, Citizens United v. the Federal Election Commission.
End Citizens United has endorsed Bullock and tracks which candidates and lawmakers have vowed to reject donations from the political action committees of corporations. Bullock has. Daines has not taken the pledge.
Daines has collected more than $3.6 million from business PACs during his congressional career, which includes his Senate term and a seat in the House before that, according to a tabulation by the Center for Responsive Politics. Bullock, who launched his Senate campaign in March, has disclosed donations from congressional leadership PACs as well as from PACs of industry groups, including $10,000 from the PAC of the trial lawyers lobby, American Association for Justice, FEC filings show.
In recent months, as Congress worked on legislation to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic, Daines pushed for a provision in a relief measure that would help speed up production of potential coronavirus vaccines and treatments by dual tracking manufacturing with testing, said his top aide Jason Thielman, who is an adviser to the campaign.
In late March, after Congress passed that measure, PACs for such pharmaceutical companies as Merck, Pfizer and Sanofi contributed about $16,000 to Daines campaign, FEC records show.
Daines serves on the Senate Finance Committee, which has jurisdiction over tax and healthcare matters — making it a magnet for industry and lobbyist donations for lawmakers on both sides of the aisle.
Company PACs, not to be confused with super PACs, compile donations from corporate executives and can give candidates up to $5,000 per election, or $10,000 for a primary and general election. Super PACs, by contrast, can raise and spend unlimited amounts but are banned from coordinating directly with candidates.
One Democratic super PAC, known as Senate Majority PAC, has already spent about $700,000 in an ad attacking Daines for worrying more “about corporate profits” than individuals’ retirement funds or job losses amid the pandemic.
Although that super PAC, like all super PACs, may not coordinate with Bullock’s campaign directly, the Montana governor still benefits from such attacks on Daines, opening him to charges of hypocrisy when it comes to big political money matters.
“The last thing Bullock should want to talk about in this campaign is money and politics,” said Daines aide Thielman, who noted Bullock’s ties to organizations that engage in political spending including super PACs that have backed the governor. “It’s something (Bullock) uses as a distraction topic to whip up his own base.”
And though Daines largely sticks to his party’s line when it comes to campaign finance issues, he was instrumental in 2018 in mandating something that advocates for campaign finance reform had sought for years: electronic filing by Senate campaigns of all contributions and expenditures. Before that, Senate disclosures could be filed on paper, which had to be copied by Senate staff and shipped to the FEC, which paid contractors to type each line item into its online disclosure database. As chairman of the legislative branch appropriations subcommittee then, he included the provision in the panel’s bill, working with Montana Democratic Sen. Jon Tester.
Daines is getting outside help, too.
Americans for Prosperity, part of the Koch political network, has endorsed the Republican and disclosed spending more than $140,000 on digital ads recently, FEC records show.
Thielman said he didn’t expect campaign finance to be a prominent issue in the Senate campaign, adding that jobs would be the focal point.
“Montana has been more impacted by job losses than any of its neighboring states,” he said.
Bullock, as governor, closed schools and businesses in response to the coronavirus, which killed 16 people in the state. That’s one of the lowest tolls in the country, and Bullock began relaxing the shutdown in late April.
Even with the economic woes stemming from the pandemic top of mind, Montana has a long history when it comes to political money matters.
It was the setting of the 2018 documentary “Dark Money,” which examined the influence of oftentimes undisclosed money spent on elections, including efforts to uncover the role of Koch-backed nonprofit organizations in the state.
Filmmaker Kimberly Reed, who is originally from the Big Sky state, said during a 2018 CQ Roll Call podcast that Bullock’s challenge served as an inspiration for the documentary. His role in that challenge, Reed said, helped him win his gubernatorial race, “in large part because he tackled this issue that was, I think, important to a lot of people in Montana.”
A March poll by Public Policy Polling found Daines and Bullock tied, 47-47. It also found that 54% of Montana voters say politicians support policies because they help corporations or groups that donate to them.
Bullock’s campaign, in an email statement to CQ Roll Call, said the governor planned to continue to raise the issue.
“As governor, he worked across the aisle to pass one of the strongest campaign finance disclosure laws in the country,” the Bullock campaign said. “In the Senate, Governor Bullock will continue what he started here in Montana and put an end to the corrupting influence of money in our politics.”
©2020 CQ-Roll Call, Inc., All Rights Reserved
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
In The News
About Gianforte: Greg Gianforte fell in love with Montana over 40 years ago when he first visited there on a school trip. He built a life, started a small business and raised a family in the state. Married for 32 years, Greg and Susan raised their... Read More
About Rosendale: Matt Rosendale, 59, is the son and brother of U.S. Marines. Matt and his wife, Jean, have been living at their ranch in Glendive for nearly 20 years. They’ve been married for 34 years and have three sons, Matthew Jr., Brien and Adam who... Read More
About Williams: Kathleen Williams has spent nearly four-decades in natural resources and public service. Williams is the daughter of a World War II veteran, Harrison, and a woman who left Oklahoma to move west and work in the Navy shipyards, Marie. She is the youngest of... Read More
As Americans head to the polls more divided than ever on social and economic issues, there's one thing they're actually coming together on: cannabis. Much has been made of whether a victory for Democratic nominee Joe Biden, or a potential liberal sweep in the Senate, could bolster marijuana... Read More
About Bullock: Steve Bullock is the governor of Montana. He assumed office on January 7, 2013. His current term ends on January 4, 2021. Bullock is running for election to the U.S. Senate to represent Montana. Bullock was born in 1966 in Missoula, Mont., and grew... Read More
About Daines: Steve Daines is a member of the U.S. Senate from Montana. He assumed office on January 6, 2015. Daines is running for re-election to the Senate to continue representing Montana. He is running against Democrat Steve Bullock. Daines is a fifth generation Montanan, residing... Read More