LGBTQ Workers Win State-Level Protection in Texas
DALLAS — Texas’ Fifth District Court of Appeals ruled Thursday in favor of a former Tarrant County College District employee who claimed she was fired from her job after disclosing her sexual orientation to a supervisor.
Amanda Sims alleged in her discrimination suit against the district that she was fired after she revealed she is lesbian to her supervisor and coworkers when she served as a member of a TCCD committee addressing diversity issues, according to the text of the ruling.
Sims said she began experiencing hostile treatment from the supervisor, who “expressed religious views that held homosexuals in a negative light,” following the revelation. Sims had received above-average performance evaluations throughout her three-year employment with TCCD, at one point even receiving the “Chancellor’s Excellence Award” for her work.
“The Texas 5th Circuit Court of Appeals made the right decision today — legally and morally,” Jason N. Smith, Sims’ lead attorney, said in a written statement. “It has been an honor to work on this case and fight on behalf of LGBTQ Texans. It’s an honor to represent someone as courageous as Amanda Sims, whose stand against discrimination has resulted in statewide employment protections for LGBTQ Texans.”
The court ruled that Sims’ complaint could be brought under the Texas Commission on Human Rights Act, or TCHRA, although the state’s constitution does not protect individuals from discrimination based on sexual orientation. Further, while Texas labor codes on unlawful employment practices do prohibit discrimination based on sex they make no specific mention of sexual orientation.
In January, the Human Rights Campaign filed an amicus brief to the court on Sims’ behalf. The organization, one of the nation’s largest LGBTQ advocacy groups, was represented in the brief and in oral arguments by Winston & Strawn LLP.
“Today, we celebrate this landmark decision alongside the Texas LGBTQ community — who, for far too long, have had to enter the workplace in fear of facing discrimination for who they are,” Alphonso David, president of The Human Rights Campaign, said in a written statement.
“I applaud the plaintiff, Amanda Sims, for her bravery and our legal partners for their impressive work. Let this ruling stand as a beacon of hope to the other states in the United States that are still fighting for basic state-wide non-discrimination protections.”
In its appeal, TCCD argued Sims’ claim of “being discriminated against on the basis of her sex and gender stereotyping” was indeed “covered under the TCHRA,” but no Texas court had ruled whether the TCHRA protected her “status of sexual orientation.”
Because no Texas court had yet addressed whether the statute could be interpreted as prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation, the court looked for a federal precedent to base its ruling on. In June 2020, the United States Supreme Court issued its opinion affirming LGBTQ workers’ protections in the case Bostock v. Clayton County, Georgia.
In its ruling, the Supreme Court reasoned the Civil Rights Act of 1964 encompasses broad prohibitions on discrimination, concluding “an employer who fires an individual merely for being gay or transgender defies the law.”
The appeals court ruled to reconcile interpretations of the TCHRA with federal anti-discrimination and retaliation law under the Bostock ruling. The court, therefore, ruled that the law prohibiting discrimination based on sex also applies to discrimination based on sexual orientation, marking a significant milestone for LGBTQ advocacy groups.
“We are proud to have worked alongside the dedicated litigation team at The Human Rights Campaign throughout the duration of this appeals process and could not be more satisfied with the court’s opinion,” Natalie Arbaugh, partner at Winston & Strawn, said in a written statement. “The law is clear — the Bostock ruling must be applied in every state without explicit non-discrimination statutes, just as it was today in Texas.”
In The News
In The States
Missouri Gov. Mike Parson announced Tuesday he is ending participation in all federal pandemic-related unemployment insurance programs to address workforce shortages across the state. Parson, a Republican, said they will end at 11:59 p.m. on Saturday, June 12. "From conversations with business owners across the state,... Read More
WASHINGTON - The Biden administration gave its final approval Tuesday to the construction and operation of the Vineyard Wind project -- the first large-scale, offshore wind project in the United States. The decision was announced by Interior Secretary Deb Haaland and Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo. The... Read More
STOWE, Vt. (AP) — Eduardo Rovetto is hoping the state of Vermont's reinstated requirement that people who are collecting unemployment benefits must seek work to qualify will help him hire enough staff for his restaurant in the resort town of Stowe. After more than a year... Read More
Though still awaiting money from the latest federal coronavirus relief act, some governors and state lawmakers already are making plans to add the multibillion-dollar boon to their budgets. Among their priorities: bailing out depleted unemployment accounts, expanding high-speed internet and providing additional aid to schools and... Read More
Republicans will gather at 39 sites around Virginia Saturday to choose a slate of statewide candidates, with no choice, of course, being more important than that of governor. In a year in which the battle for the future of the GOP has mostly been waged in... Read More
In 2020, election officials tried to make voting easier and safer amid a global pandemic. Next time, they might get fined or face criminal charges. Republicans are creating a new slate of punishments for the county officials who run elections, arguing they overstepped their authority when... Read More