Johnson Troubled by UK Vote on Assisted Dying

December 4, 2024 by Dan McCue
Johnson Troubled by UK Vote on Assisted Dying
House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., addresses reporters during a news briefing Wednesday morning. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., on Wednesday took the rare step of criticizing lawmakers in the United Kingdom just days after the British House of Commons voted to legalize assisted dying.

Stressing his opinions were his own, “a point of personal privilege,” Johnson described Friday, the day of the 330-275-vote on the euthanasia legislation, as “a sad and shameful day for the English speaking world wide.”

“It’s an ancient truth that medicine should always heal and never harm, but the United Kingdom just joined Canada in twisting that definition of medicine and codifying the Orwellian language of assisted death into law,” the speaker said.

Assisted dying has long been a contentious issue in Great Britain and the vote in the House of Commons came after hours of rancorous debate in the chamber.

The bill must still clear the House of Lords and a number of parliamentary committees, but Friday’s vote was seen by its advocates as clearing the most important hurdle.

The bill would allow people with a terminal condition and less than six months to live to take a drug or drug cocktail to end their lives.

It also includes guardrails — a requirement that the terminal ill person be capable of making the decision for themselves, and another provision that says two doctors and a High Court judge must sign off on the decision before the patient’s wishes are carried out.

The patient must then administer the lethal drugs themselves.

If the bill advances and becomes law, the United Kingdom will join Canada, New Zealand, Spain and most of Australia in allowing some form of assisted dying.

It is also legal here in 10 states and the District of Columbia.

“America has always stood out as a beacon, as a shining city on a hill,” said Johnson, who before addressing the British vote had been in a generally light-hearted, holiday season mood.

“We’ve stood out in this regard,” he said. “Our Declaration [of Independence] makes the bold proclamation, the acknowledgement … that life is a gift from our creator.

“Our founders called it a ‘self-evident’ truth that all of us are made equally by our creator, and that he’s the one that gives us our rights,” he continued, adding, “Any society that rejects that truth about life as a gift from our creator and adopts a culture of death is a society that is in the process of crumbling.

“So-called ‘assisted death’ endangers the weak and marginalized in society and it corrupts medicine and it erodes our obligations to family,” he said.

Johnson went on to say that he hopes the people of the United Kingdom “will work, through democratic means, to reverse this legislation.”

“As speaker of the House, I want to say that House Republicans are committed to rejecting socialized medicine and the nanny state and that we will promote and respect every life, no matter how old or sick or weak those persons may be,” he said.

Johnson was asked whether “assisted death” should remain a state decision in the United States or whether he believed the federal government should take action to prevent such legislation from being adopted in other states.

“Well, I can tell you that the action in the U.K. brings [the issue] to the forefront and it’s something that we’ve been watching for years,” he said. “I suspect it will be part of the dialogue going forward, but we don’t have any legislation planned at the moment that I know of. …

“I do think we need to stand up for the respect for life … that’s an important thing to me, and I think it’s an important thing to a lot of my colleagues, so we’ll see what happens,” Johnson said.

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and @DanMcCue

A+
a-
  • assisted dying
  • health
  • House of Commons
  • Mike Johnson
  • United Kingdom
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    In The News

    January 24, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Trump Visits Disaster Areas in North Carolina, California

    WASHINGTON — In the first domestic trip since the start of his second term, President Donald Trump on Friday is... Read More

    WASHINGTON — In the first domestic trip since the start of his second term, President Donald Trump on Friday is visiting parts of North Carolina and Los Angeles, California, which have been ravaged by very different natural disasters in recent months. For residents, business owners and... Read More

    AP Decision Notes: What to Expect in Florida's Special Congressional Primaries

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Control of the U.S. House isn’t on the line in Tuesday’s special congressional primaries in Florida, but Republicans are... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Control of the U.S. House isn’t on the line in Tuesday’s special congressional primaries in Florida, but Republicans are still eager to find replacements for former GOP Reps. Matt Gaetz and Michael Waltz to add some breathing room to their slender majority in the chamber. President Donald Trump looms... Read More

    'We've Got to Move Forward' - Michigan Electric Vehicle Industry Responds to Trump Policy Changes

    DETROIT (AP) — While President Donald Trump took aim at the electric vehicle industry this week, there is still optimism... Read More

    DETROIT (AP) — While President Donald Trump took aim at the electric vehicle industry this week, there is still optimism about the industry’s future in Michigan, a state retooling from America’s most recognizable auto hub to its number one destination for electric vehicle investment. More than... Read More

    March for Life Returns to Washington: What to Look for When Anti-Abortion Activists Gather

    Thousands of anti-abortion activists are coming to Washington Friday for the annual March for Life, seeking to build momentum after... Read More

    Thousands of anti-abortion activists are coming to Washington Friday for the annual March for Life, seeking to build momentum after a string of victories and maintain pressure on legislators. After decades of fighting to overturn Roe v. Wade, organizers are seeking to focus on the multiple... Read More

    January 23, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Trump Gives Davos Elite a Choice: Invest in US or Else

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump promised attendees at the World Economic Forum on Thursday that if they invest in America... Read More

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump promised attendees at the World Economic Forum on Thursday that if they invest in America “we will give you among the lowest taxes on earth.” But with his next breath he warned that if they don’t make their products in the... Read More

    January 23, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Trump Administration Tries to Halt Agreements Over Alleged Police Civil Rights Violations

    WASHINGTON — The Trump administration is trying to halt consent agreements the Justice Department reached in recent years with police... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Trump administration is trying to halt consent agreements the Justice Department reached in recent years with police departments accused of civil rights violations. The consent agreements under the Biden administration were intended to institute reforms to avoid abuses by police. A Justice Department... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top