Colleges Seek Legal Protection as They Mull Return to In-Person Classes

June 25, 2020 by Gaspard Le Dem
(Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON — With fall around the corner and coronavirus cases surging in some states, U.S. colleges are scrambling to figure out their gameplans for the upcoming school year. 

Public health experts have repeatedly warned of a potentially massive second wave of the pandemic if cases aren’t reined in before cooler weather arrives this fall.

Some colleges are taking a more cautious approach to reopening by investing heavily in digital infrastructure and committing to a new virtual learning model. California’s community colleges, the country’s largest higher education system, has announced that it will teach almost exclusively online this fall.

Meanwhile, other institutions are forging ahead with plans to return to in-person teaching, reopen student dorms, and resume major athletic events on campus like football games.

Fearing potential lawsuits from students who could get sick by returning to campus, many colleges have called on Congress to grant them emergency liability protections, citing financial difficulties caused by extended campus closures. 

But some advocates say that increasing liability protections for colleges would take away one of the few legal mechanisms students have to ensure that schools actually protect them during the pandemic.

In May, the American Council On Education (ACE), an organization that lobbies on behalf of more than 1,000 U.S. colleges and universities, sent a letter to Congress urging lawmakers to “enact temporary and targeted liability protections related to the COVID-19 pandemic.”

“The impact on the operations and revenues of many institutions has been catastrophic, for some even existential, which has had a terrible ripple effect in communities large and small,” the letter said.

Terry Hartle, a senior vice-president at ACE, says that the purpose of increasing liability protections isn’t to give colleges a free pass, but rather to provide them with temporary legal protection during an unprecedented health and financial crisis.

“Most of the proposals that Congress has considered related to liability protection would not provide absolute immunity, they would change the standards from negligence to gross negligence,” he says.

Hartle acknowledges that students who return to campus in the fall could face health risks, but he says that colleges shouldn’t be held responsible if they have reasonably tried to protect students.

“It is just saying that if you come to campus, it’s quite possible you will get sick,” he says. “And if the institution has taken appropriate precautions, institutions, like all employers, shouldn’t be subject to legal action.”

The proposal to expand legal protections for colleges has angered many advocates who say that current laws do enough to shield the institutions from lawsuits.

“Immunity from legal liability could empower the worst actors in the higher education sector to gamble with students’ lives,” advocates said in a recent letter to the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions.

“This seems like exactly the wrong moment in time to revisit centuries of law that has protected people against negligent acts or actions by businesses — whether that’s a school or a shopping mall,” says Mike Pierce, director of the Student Borrower Protection Center.

Raising the standard for student lawsuits to gross negligence — even temporarily — would send a signal to colleges that they can operate with impunity during the pandemic. “Gross negligence is an extraordinarily high bar,” says Pierce. “There are a lot of really awful things that can happen in the space between a school acting negligently and a school acting with gross negligence.”

In April, students filed a class-action lawsuit against Virginia’s Liberty University, alleging that the school had endangered the health of students and staff by reopening amid the pandemic when most American universities were shutting down. 

The complaint said that Liberty had “placed students at severe physical risk and refused to refund thousands of dollars in fees owed to them for the Spring 2020 semester.” Several students at Liberty developed coronavirus symptoms after the university reopened its campus in March, though it was unclear whether they had contracted the virus on campus.

Pierce says that the lawsuit against Liberty shows the importance of students having legal recourse when universities decide to defy the guidance of health experts during the pandemic.

“The law is really one of the only counterweights that prevents schools from behaving irresponsibly, and unreasonably and putting the lives of their students and workers at risk,” he says. “This isn’t speculative — we’ve already seen this play out and we’ve already seen people get hurt,” he adds.

Despite that criticism, the idea of increasing liability protections for higher education institutions has gained some traction from Republican lawmakers in Congress.

Sen. Lamar Alexander, R-Tenn., chair of the Senate’s education committee, has expressed support for including the measure in future coronavirus relief legislation.

“Schools, colleges and businesses would be less likely to reopen if they think they are going to be sued if someone gets sick when they come back to school,” Lamar told reporters in a video conference in May.

Other lawmakers, however, have expressed concern that increasing liability protections for colleges could send the wrong message to students who are concerned for their health during the pandemic.

At a hearing of the Senate’s education committee in early June, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., chided university leaders, including Christina Paxson, the president of Brown University, for supporting the call for liability protections amid the pandemic.

“When colleges lobby to change that standard and to walk away from it […] what message does it send to our families and our students?” said Warren. “Would it make you more comfortable or less comfortable as the parent of an incoming student?”

In The News

GOP Candidate Clings to 8-vote Lead in US House Race in Iowa
State News
GOP Candidate Clings to 8-vote Lead in US House Race in Iowa

IOWA CITY, Iowa (AP) — A Republican candidate saw her vote lead dwindle to single digits Wednesday in Iowa’s 2nd Congressional District as a dramatic recount moved toward a conclusion in a race that will help determine the size of Democrats’ majority in the House of... Read More

They're Baaack: Trump and Allies Still Refuse Election Loss
2020 Elections
They're Baaack: Trump and Allies Still Refuse Election Loss

WASHINGTON (AP) — Monday seemed like the end of President Donald Trump's relentless challenges to the election, after the federal government acknowledged President-elect Joe Biden was the “apparent winner” and Trump cleared the way for cooperation on a transition of power. But his baseless claims have... Read More

Sorry, Grinch. Virus Won't Stop NORAD from Tracking Santa
In The News
Sorry, Grinch. Virus Won't Stop NORAD from Tracking Santa

WASHINGTON (AP) — Children of the world can rest easy. The global pandemic won't stop them from tracking Santa Claus' progress as he delivers gifts around the globe on Christmas Eve. The North American Aerospace Defense Command has announced that NORAD will track Santa on Dec.... Read More

High Court Blocks NY Coronavirus Limits on Houses of Worship
Supreme Court
High Court Blocks NY Coronavirus Limits on Houses of Worship

WASHINGTON (AP) — As coronavirus cases surge again nationwide the Supreme Court late Wednesday barred New York from enforcing certain limits on attendance at churches and synagogues in areas designated as hard hit by the virus. The justices split 5-4 with new Justice Amy Coney Barrett in the... Read More

Biden Seeks Unity as Trump Stokes Fading Embers of Campaign
Political News
Biden Seeks Unity as Trump Stokes Fading Embers of Campaign

WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) — On a day of grace and grievance, President-elect Joe Biden summoned Americans to join in common purpose against the coronavirus pandemic and their political divisions while the man he will replace stoked the fading embers of his campaign to “turn the election... Read More

Black Friday Offers Beacon of Hope to Struggling Stores
Black Friday Offers Beacon of Hope to Struggling Stores

NEW YORK (AP) — After months of slumping sales and businesses toppling into bankruptcy, Black Friday is offering a small beacon of hope. In normal times, Black Friday is the busiest shopping day of the year, drawing millions of shoppers eager to get started on their... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top