After 60 Years of Revolution in Cuba, Cracks in Leadership Emerge
December 31, 2018
Six months after taking office as president of Cuba, Miguel Diaz-Canel will preside over ceremonies marking the 60th anniversary of a revolution while facing a stagnant economy and growing citizen protests. Six decades into its socialist experiment, his government is still trying to figure out how to satisfy the basic necessities of its population.
With minimal economic growth in 2018 and continuing shortages of basic staples like flour at year-end, experts say the government is failing under his leadership.
And unlike his predecessors, who ruled with almost absolute power, Diaz-Canel exposed internal conflicts this year when his government reversed unpopular regulations to increase control over the private sector, was prone to soften a decree that legalizes censorship of independent art, and decided to withdraw from the draft constitution a controversial article that would open a path to same-sex marriage. The move was viewed by Cuba watchers as a response to fear of losing support from members of the religious sector for a referendum in 2019.
“By revising the regulations governing the private sector and making concessions to the artists on the decree law regulating the arts, the government has shown a responsiveness to organized public pressure that is unprecedented,” said William LeoGrande, a Cuba expert at American University who recently participated in an event organized by the Cuban foreign ministry in Havana.
“In the past, the government modified some draft laws after public discussions indicated opposition to particular features, but its response to organized opposition in the past has been unyielding,” LeoGrande said. “This pragmatic response indicates both the government’s flexibility and also its recognition that the Cuba of 2018 is not one in which people will simply accept whatever the authorities dictate.”
Six decades after the Jan. 1, 1959, triumph of the revolution led by Fidel Castro, Diaz-Canel stands as the figurehead of a country that only recently gave mobile phone users access to the internet, letting them post videos of people standing in long lines to buy bread and to document private taxi drivers who went on strike in protest against new control measures implemented by the state.
Limits on the number of permits for private-sector work that any one person can have and the number of chairs allowed at private restaurants known as paladares, which were included in a decree published in July, also sparked discontent among the so-called self-employed and dismay from foreign governments and experts who had expected an economic opening from what was supposed to be a more modern government with a younger face.
After months of criticisms, Labor Minister Magarita Gonzalez announced in early December that those two measures had been erased.
On Twitter, Diaz-Canel defended the decision and dismissed speculation that it was the result of a fragile government: “There’s no reason to believe that corrections are steps backward, or to confuse them with weaknesses when the people are heard. Revolution is to change everything that should be changed. None of us is as powerful as all of us together,” he wrote.
But the tribulations of Cuba’s new leader — he succeeded Raul Castro in April — did not stop there.
Cuban artists put up a united front to criticize Decree 349, which legalized works of art and requires artists to obtain government work permits. The protests also drew support from dissident artists like Tania Bruguera and even icons of the revolution like singer Silvio Rodríguez.
“Decree 349 is something that they put in front of our president to sign, without any discussion among the artists,” Rodríguez wrote in his blog. “Maybe there should be a moratorium on the decree, until it is discussed and an acceptable modification is found.”
Although the decrees were made public in July, after Diaz-Canel was named president of the Council of State, many were signed by Raul Castro, who remains head of the ruling Communist Party of Cuba. Diaz-Canel signed the decree.
Diaz-Canel “does not hold the same historical legitimacy of Raúl or Fidel or the same ultra-concentration of power, and the people know it,” said Ted Henken, a Baruch College professor who follows Cuban affairs. The new leader “feels popular pressure more than the previous presidents because he’s trying to establish his own legitimacy, in part by trying to listen to and respond to the people’s complaints.”
Experts agree that to win popular support, Diaz-Canel will have to offer tangible improvements in the daily lives of Cubans, which seems unlikely in the short run because of the island’s complex economic and political situation and an administration in the United States that has promised to step up pressure on the Cuban government.
Cuba’s gross domestic product rose slightly in 2018, but the growth “still does not help the people like what we need,” Diaz-Canel told the National Assembly. The government predicted a 1.5 percent GDP growth in 2019, but its figures are not comparable to the rest of the world because Cuba includes spending on health, education and social services.
“Cuba’s productive machinery does not totally collapse, but it also doesn’t create economic progress in the last 30 years,” economist Pavel Vidal wrote in an article published on the digital site, Cuba Posible.
Cuba has still not recovered from the economic crisis in the 1990s known as the Special Period, “but it must be acknowledged that it is a system that has proven to be effective at managing the crisis and avoiding economic collapse, just as it has been ‘effective’ at limiting private initiative, innovation and increases in productivity, Vidal said. “It is a system that holds the record for the lowest levels of investment in Latin America.”
Diaz-Canel’s recent visits to Russia, China, Vietnam and other Asian countries — with stops in the United Kingdom and France — also did not bring the expected benefits. For 2019, the confirmed foreign investments will account for barely 6.2 percent of all planned investment in the country.
After his return, Diaz-Canel ordered his Cabinet ministers to review about 80 investment proposals, some of them already on the books for several years.
The government also has stopped making payments on some foreign debts that had been renegotiated with several countries, according to state media reports.
Economy Minister Alejandro Gil Fernandez spoke about the “elevated level of debt faced by the economy due to the non-payment of renegotiated debts, an issue that will also impact the government in 2019 because that financial problem cannot be resolved in the short run,” the official Granma newspaper reported.
Drops in exports and tourism — which fell short of 5 million visitors — plus the impacts of Hurricane Irma and the U.S. embargo were cited by Gil Fernández to explain the low growth. Additionally, there is the cut in subsidies from the Nicolás Maduro government in Venezuela, an ally suffering through its own economic crisis.
Sugar production dropped so much that a clearly exasperated Jose Ramón Machado Ventura, the octogenarian No. 2 in the Communist Party, complained, “Why do we want sugar mills if we don’t have any sugar cane?” Granma used the quote in a headline, but changed it after independent and foreign news media reported on it.
The shortages have been more sharply felt at year-end as Cubans have problems finding basic items like bread, eggs and chicken. And 2019 looks no better because the government has announced further cuts in food and fuel imports.
Recently, the government announced an agreement with Major League Baseball that could replace some of the millions of dollars lost by the Cuban government when it recalled medical personnel working in Brazil. Cuba allegedly kept as much as 80 percent of the salaries paid to the physicians fulfilling required assignments overseas.
Under the new agreement with MLB, the Cuban Baseball Federation would receive 15 to 20 percent of the total value of each contract for each player who joins a team in the United States. Havana also will impose a new tax on the personal income of baseball players and other athletes contracted to play abroad, according to Lina Rodríguez, minister of finance and prices.
But those quantities are minimal when compared to the foreign investments the island needs, estimated at $2.5 billion per year.
The proposed new constitution pushed by Raul Castro while he was president had generated some hopes for change. But the final version that will be submitted to a referendum maintains Communist Party rule and a centrally planned economy. It legally recognizes private property, but makes no mention of popular demands such as allowing for the election of the president by direct vote and giving Cuban Americans the right to invest in the island.
©2018 Miami Herald
Visit the Miami Herald at www.miamiherald.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
In The News
In The News
WASHINGTON -- The Defense Department is consulting with health officials and the Joint Chiefs of Staff about the possibility of... Read More
WASHINGTON -- The Defense Department is consulting with health officials and the Joint Chiefs of Staff about the possibility of making COVID-19 vaccinations a requirement of military service. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said in a statement Thursday he is trying to "determine how and when to... Read More
WASHINGTON -- The Treasury Department must provide the House Ways and Means Committee with former President Donald Trump’s tax returns,... Read More
WASHINGTON -- The Treasury Department must provide the House Ways and Means Committee with former President Donald Trump’s tax returns, the Justice Department said in a legal opinion released Friday. In the opinion, the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel said the committee chairman “has invoked... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Members of the House and Senate gathered outside the Capitol Friday to celebrate this week’s progress on the... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Members of the House and Senate gathered outside the Capitol Friday to celebrate this week’s progress on the largest infrastructure bill in U.S. history, and to remind everyone that the legislation still has a ways to go before the $1.2 trillion proposal becomes a... Read More
WASHINGTON -- The House passed a package of seven appropriations bills for 2022, funding the executive office of the president... Read More
WASHINGTON -- The House passed a package of seven appropriations bills for 2022, funding the executive office of the president and general government functions of the executive branch, the judiciary, and several departments and agencies. The vote was 219-208. The seven-bill package, H.R. 4502, provides 2022... Read More
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday tossed a legal challenge that claimed Connecticut violated citizens’ 2nd Amendment... Read More
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday tossed a legal challenge that claimed Connecticut violated citizens’ 2nd Amendment right when it curtailed fingerprinting services during the pandemic. The Connecticut Citizens’ Defense League and six state residents sued Gov. Ned Lamont and the commissioner of... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump urged senior Justice Department officials to declare the 2020 election results "corrupt" in a... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump urged senior Justice Department officials to declare the 2020 election results "corrupt" in a December phone call, according to handwritten notes from one of the participants in the conversation. The notes of the Dec. 27 call, released Friday by the... Read More