In NC’s Disputed 9th District Election, Republican Incumbent Wants to Subpoena His Democratic Challenger

February 9, 2019

By Ely Portillo

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — A hearing on North Carolina’s disputed 9th District election could finally shed more light on the only undecided congressional race in the U.S., and Republican Mark Harris wants his Democratic opponent, Dan McCready, to testify.

The newly appointed, five-member N.C. Board of Elections is scheduled to start the hearing Feb. 18 in Raleigh. The board is expected to vote at the conclusion of the meeting on whether to certify the election results — which showed Harris with a 905-vote lead over McCready — or order a new election.

In a letter to the board this week, Harris’ attorneys named 20 people they’re requesting subpoenas be issued for to compel their attendance and testimony at the hearing, including McCready. In a previous letter to the board, McCready asked the board to subpoena Harris, but only to compel his attendance, not testimony.

The bitterly fought race was thrown into disarray in November, when the previous board (which was dissolved in an unrelated legal dispute) refused to certify the results in the 9th District. Allegations of illegal absentee ballot-harvesting by McCrae Dowless, a Bladen County political operative working for the Harris campaign, soon surfaced, with some voters saying they had turned over their ballots to people they didn’t know.

The Harris campaign is also asking the Board of Elections to release its investigative report to the public before the hearing, between Feb. 13 and 15. Briefs from both sides are due in the case by Feb. 12.

David Freedman, an attorney for the Harris campaign, said that so far they have not received any details about what the investigation has uncovered, and that they should have the chance to review those before the hearing.

“From a due process perspective and a fundamental fairness perspective, we should know what the investigation turned up,” said Freedman. “At this point there’s no specific notice as to what specific allegations there are we need to defend.”

A Board of Elections representative could not immediately be reached to answer if they are considering releasing the results of their investigative report before the hearing. The board was briefed on the investigation in a four-hour closed-session meeting Thursday.

McCready campaign spokesman Aaron Simpson said that regardless of the subpoena request, actions associated with the Harris campaign touched off the investigation.

“Unlike Mr. Harris, we’re happy to assist in this investigation in any way we can. There’s one campaign under investigation here, that’s the campaign belonging to Mark Harris,” Simpson said.

In their letter to the board, the Harris campaign said they want to subpoena McCready to testify about any personal knowledge he has of allegations that ballots were discarded, any payments his campaign made to election workers in Bladen and Robeson counties and any correspondence his campaign or the Democratic Party had with Board of Elections members.

The Harris campaign also wants to subpoena Jens Lutz, a former Bladen County elections board member, to testify about communications he reportedly had with the state board, as well as his former business relationship with Dowless. And Harris is seeking to subpoena Andy Yates, owner of the Cornelius-based Red Dome consulting firm that ran much of Harris’ campaign and employed Dowless as a subcontractor.

The Harris campaign is seeking Yates’ testimony about “campaign directions given to him by Mark Harris,” as well as other details on the election and get-out-the-vote strategies.

Most of the other people the Harris campaign is seeking to subpoena are Bladen County voters and residents who have previously talked about or provided affidavits about the alleged ballot-harvesting scheme by Dowless.

In correspondence with the previous board, the McCready campaign named 48 people they’re seeking to subpoena. They were not going to be subpoenaed to provide testimony, only to compel attendance, however. The McCready campaign said it wanted to preserve grounds for possible future prosecution of people involved in election fraud, which could be compromised if they were compelled to testify before the board and received a deal of some sort in exchange for their testimony.

McCready also sought to subpoena Yates, as well as N.C. GOP chairman Robin Hayes and executive director Dallas Woodhouse.

It’s possible that not all people who the campaigns seek subpoenas for will ultimately be subpoenaed, and not everyone who receives a subpoena may testify. Board of Elections chairman Bob Cordle will have discretion to limit the length of testimony, and the board has said, “Duplicative questioning will be severely restricted.”


Staff writer Jim Morrill contributed to this report.


©2019 The Charlotte Observer (Charlotte, N.C.)

Visit The Charlotte Observer (Charlotte, N.C.) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Political News

Social Security Costs to Exceed Income in 2020, Trustees Say Entitlements
Social Security Costs to Exceed Income in 2020, Trustees Say
April 22, 2019
by Dan McCue

Both Social Security and Medicare are on unstable financial footing, and lawmakers need to act sooner rather than later to shore up America’s bedrock retirement programs and phase in needed changes, the trustees of both programs said in reports released Monday. Social Security is the government's... Read More

Cain Withdraws from Consideration for Seat on Federal Reserve Federal Reserve
Cain Withdraws from Consideration for Seat on Federal Reserve
April 22, 2019
by Dan McCue

Former Godfather’s Pizza CEO Herman Cain has withdrawn from consideration for a seaton the Federal Reserve board amid focus on past allegations of sexual harassment and infidelity. Cain ran for president as an insurgent populist eyeing the 2012 Republican presidential nomination, but dropped out of that... Read More

Supreme Court to Take Up LGBT Job Discrimination Cases Supreme Court
Supreme Court to Take Up LGBT Job Discrimination Cases
April 22, 2019
by Dan McCue

The U.S. Supreme Court agreed Monday to take up the question of whether provisions of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibiting employment discrimination applies to LGBT individuals. The justices said they would hear Bostock v. Clayton County, Georgia, which has been consolidated with Altitude... Read More

Trump Sues Cummings to Block Subpoena of Financial Records Litigation
Trump Sues Cummings to Block Subpoena of Financial Records
April 22, 2019
by Dan McCue

President Donald Trump and the Trump Organization on Monday sued the Democratic chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Reform to block a subpoena that seeks years of the president's financial records. The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia,... Read More

State of Play Changes Dramatically In Wake of Mueller Report Release Political News
State of Play Changes Dramatically In Wake of Mueller Report Release
April 19, 2019
by Dan McCue

House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., on Friday subpoenaed the Justice Department for the full, unredacted version of special counsel Robert Mueller's report as well as the underlying evidence, including grand jury evidence. "I am open to working with the department to reach a reasonable... Read More

Bolton Declares Monroe Doctrine ‘Alive and Well’ As White House Eyes Venezuela Foreign Affairs
Bolton Declares Monroe Doctrine ‘Alive and Well’ As White House Eyes Venezuela
April 19, 2019
by HJ Mai

The Trump administration’s ongoing pressure campaign to force Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro out of office is based on an almost 200-year-old doctrine – one that was never meant to be a doctrine after all. National Security Advisor John Bolton on Wednesday said that the Monroe Doctrine... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top