Trump Says Mexico Is Cracking Down on Migrants. There, It’s a Different Picture

April 19, 2019by Patrick J. McDonnell
Central American migrants heading to the U.S. walk in a caravan along the road between Metapa and Tapachula in Mexico on April 12, 2019. (Pep Companys/AFP/Getty Images/TNS) **FOR USE WITH THIS STORY ONLY**

MAPASTEPEC, Mexico — If the Mexican government is cracking down on Central American migrants — as President Donald Trump recently asserted — there was no evidence of it here in this remote town in southern Mexico.

Roughly 3,000 migrants, mostly arrivals on recent caravans, had found temporary quarters in a sun-baked sports complex, where residents scramble for shade beneath tents and rough lean-tos crafted from branches and palm fronds.

But they weren’t being detained or readied for deportation. Instead, they were being processed for permits that will facilitate travel north to the U.S. border.

“We want our children to have a future without fear of gangs,” said Oscar Amilcar, a Salvadoran hunkered down with his wife, two children and migrants from Guatemala and Honduras.

They all planned to resume their journeys soon and present themselves to U.S. border authorities to claim asylum.

It was a far different picture than the one Trump painted earlier this month when he announced he was holding off on his threat to shut the U.S.-Mexico border because Mexican authorities were “apprehending people now by the thousands and bringing them back to their countries.”

“Nobody’s ever seen anything like it,” he said during a visit to the California border city of Calexico.

Closing the border would have severe — and possibly disastrous — economic repercussions for the United States as well as Mexico, and Trump was facing pressure from across the political spectrum to rescind his threat. The purported spike in Mexican enforcement offered some political cover.

Except that it doesn’t seem to have occurred.

Mexico has no intention of engaging in mass deportations or moving to stop so-called migrant caravans, said Rocío González Higuera, head of migration policy for the human rights branch of the country’s interior ministry.

“Mexico is implementing a process of orderly, regulated, secure migration, with respect for human rights,” Gonzalez said in an interview in Tapachula, a migrant hub just north of the Guatemalan border, when asked about Trump’s comments. “What another country decides or says is the responsibility of that country, not ours.”

According to statistics published by the Mexican government, enforcement actions against migrants have actually slowed somewhat since President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador took office in December.

Deportations were down 16 percent and arrests 7 percent for December, January and February compared with the same three-month period a year earlier. Figures for March were not yet available.

The reductions came amid decade-high numbers of Central American migrants making their way through Mexico to the United States.

“You have the number of Central Americans arriving increasing almost exponentially, but deportations remaining relatively stable,” said Stephanie Leutert, who heads the Mexico Security Initiative at the University of Texas at Austin.

Lopez Obrador made a campaign promise to respect the human rights of migrants, and his government has stressed assisting them rather than criminalizing them — a posture that has even perturbed some people in Mexico fed up with the illicit migration.

To that end, it has issued skyrocketing numbers of “humanitarian” visas to northbound migrants.

In January and February, the government provided more than 19,000 such visas — almost a third of the total for all of 2018.

The visas allow migrants to cross Mexico to the U.S. border without fear of arrest, and without relying on expensive smugglers.

Soon, Mexican authorities say, Central Americans will be able to apply for the visas in their homelands.

Mexico is especially concerned about protecting the families with children who are increasingly dominating the movement north, said Gonzalez, the migration policy official.

Mexico has long been conflicted on the issue of immigration, and it has not been immune to U.S. pressure over the years.

Since 2015, according to official statistics, Mexico has deported more than 500,000 Central Americans, largely from the so-called northern triangle nations — Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador — which are the biggest source of U.S.-bound migrants today.

Still, Mexico lacks the will, and manpower, to seal off its more than 700-mile border with Guatemala, according to experts and officials.

Mexico’s official lexicon is that those detained and repatriated are “rescued” — terminology that reflects the sensitivity of the issue in a country where large numbers of its own citizens have been sent home from the United States against their will.

With Trump in power, the pressure on Mexico perhaps has never been greater.

Mexican policymakers seem caught between Lopez Obrador’s humanitarian inclinations and Trump’s demands for a crackdown.

“Mexico will have to give guarantees to the White House that it is going to reinforce and harden its migratory policy and retake the control it has lost of the southern border,” columnist Salvador García Soto wrote this month in Mexico’s El Universal newspaper on the eve of Trump’s visit to Calexico.

The main forces propelling the exodus from Central America — sluggish economies and rampant violence — are unlikely change anytime soon.

“Mexico’s in a hard place because it can’t change U.S. immigration policy and it can’t change conditions in Central America,” Leutert said.

Then there are domestic pressures in Mexico.

Many Mexicans are showing increasing weariness with illegal immigration, grumbling that the government is helping Central Americans more than poor Mexicans.

More than half of respondents to a poll this month in El Universal agreed that the Mexican government should act to stop the flow of migrants. Almost 60 percent said migrants were bad for their communities, compared with 34.2 percent who responded similarly to the same question last October, when the caravans were in the headlines here.

Some reports suggest that deep divisions have emerged within the government about whether to step up enforcement or allow more Central Americans to enter the country.

At the sports complex here in Mapastepec, in the Mexican state of Chiapas, 90 miles north of Guatemala, it was clear which side is winning out for the moment.

The migrants arrived at the facility after residents of the Mexican town of Huixtla — which welcomed caravan travelers last year — rejected their presence.

Now all were waiting to be processed for humanitarian visas allowing them to proceed.

Many were traveling with minor children. Word has spread to Central America nations that it is more likely for asylum applicants to be released in the United States if traveling in families.

“We have nothing to look forward to in Honduras,” said Deysi Marbeli Ibarra, 21, who held her 14-month-old daughter, Evangelina, on the edge of a soccer field.

She headed north in a caravan last month from Honduras with five other family members, including a sister and a niece.

Ibarra said her family ran a small business in her hometown of Danli, and that gangs were demanding weekly extortion payments and threatened her and her family if they did not pay.

Those threats would be the basis for her claim for political asylum in the United States, she said.

A few yards away, in one of the shaded lean-tos, Oscar Amilcar, 40, said he pulled up stakes last month in Ahuachapan, El Salvador, leaving with his wife and two children. The eldest, 16-year-old Marlon, said he felt threatened because he refused to join a local gang.

“If you don’t join, they kill you and your family,” he said. “I don’t want that kind of life. I want to study and make myself better.”


Los Angeles Times special correspondent Cecilia Sanchez contributed to this report from Mexico City.


©2019 Los Angeles Times

Visit the Los Angeles Times at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

In The News




US Ends Strict Trump-era Asylum Rules for Violence Victims
US Ends Strict Trump-era Asylum Rules for Violence Victims

The U.S. government on Wednesday ended two Trump administration policies that made it harder for immigrants fleeing violence to qualify for asylum, especially Central Americans. Attorney General Merrick Garland issued new instructions to immigration judges to stop following the Trump-era rules that made it tough for... Read More

Blunt Message, Search for Answers Mark VP's 1st Foreign Trip
Blunt Message, Search for Answers Mark VP's 1st Foreign Trip

MEXICO CITY (AP) — Vice President Kamala Harris came to Latin America to deliver a message rather than clinch some kind of concrete deal. She bluntly told migrants not to travel to the United States. She spoke of the evils of government corruption that lead to... Read More

US Taps Groups to Pick Asylum-Seekers to Allow Into Country
US Taps Groups to Pick Asylum-Seekers to Allow Into Country

SAN DIEGO (AP) — The Biden administration has quietly tasked six humanitarian groups with recommending which migrants should be allowed to stay in the U.S. instead of being rapidly expelled from the country under federal pandemic-related powers that block people from seeking asylum. The groups will... Read More

Gorsuch Holds 9th Circuit Went Too Far in Accepting Immigrant Testimony
Supreme Court
Gorsuch Holds 9th Circuit Went Too Far in Accepting Immigrant Testimony
June 1, 2021
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - In a unanimous ruling, the Supreme Court tossed a pair of decisions from the 9th U.S. Circuit, holding the appellate court went too far in assuming that an immigrant's testimony was credible unless an immigrant judge said otherwise. Tuesday’s ruling involved a pair of... Read More

Many Wait Uneasily as Biden Unwinds Key Trump Asylum Policy
Many Wait Uneasily as Biden Unwinds Key Trump Asylum Policy

SAN DIEGO (AP) — In March of 2020, Estela Lazo appeared before Immigration Judge Lee O'Connor with her two children, her muscles tensed and a lump in her throat. Would they receive asylum? O'Connor's answer: No – he wasn't even ready to consider the question.  But... Read More

Number of Children Traveling Alone at Border Eases in April
Number of Children Traveling Alone at Border Eases in April

SAN DIEGO (AP) — The number of unaccompanied children encountered on the U.S. border with Mexico in April eased from an all-time high a month earlier, while more adults were found coming without families, authorities said Tuesday. Authorities encountered 17,171 children traveling alone, down 9% from... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top