Supreme Court Adopts Trump Policy In Case of Illegal Immigrant Detentions

March 19, 2019 by Tom Ramstack
Supreme Court Adopts Trump Policy In Case of Illegal Immigrant Detentions
The Supreme Court of the United States in Washington, D.C., on September 25, 2018. (Olivier Douliery/Abaca Press/TNS)

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that certain immigrants with previous criminal records can be detained without a right to bail.

The 5-4 ruling is a significant victory for the Trump administration’s hard-line immigration policies but one that is outraging civil rights advocates.

The decision in a lawsuit turned on an interpretation of the detention provision in the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act. The provision says noncitizens must be arrested “when [they are] released” from police custody on criminal charges and detained without rights to bail until their deportation proceedings conclude.

A lower court ruled the mandatory detention provision applies only when noncitizens are arrested immediately after being released from custody.

“Because Congress’s use of the word ‘when’ conveys immediacy, we conclude that the immigration detention must occur promptly upon the aliens’ release from criminal custody,” says the opinion from the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco.

The Supreme Court reversed the decision, saying immigrants could be arrested and held without a bond if they committed crimes, including minor ones, no matter how long ago they were released from criminal custody.

“The ‘when … released’ clause could not possibly describe aliens in that sense,” said Justice Samuel A. Alito, Jr., writing for the majority. “It plays no role in identifying for [Customs officials] which aliens [they] must immediately arrest. If it did, the directive in [the provision] would be nonsense.”

The ruling said a possible long delay in arresting the illegal immigrants was irrelevant.

“An official’s crucial duties are better carried out late than never,” the ruling said.

Alito acknowledged that some individual immigrants might have rights to challenge their detentions on constitutional due process grounds.

In a dissent Justice Stephen Breyer said the majority opinion violated basic American values.

Breyer wrote the opinion “runs the gravest risk of depriving those whom the government has detained of one of the oldest and most important of our constitutionally guaranteed freedoms.”

Tuesday’s ruling was far from the first time that a majority on the Supreme Court endorsed the Trump administration’s policies on immigration. Last year, the Supreme Court supported the president’s travel ban on visitors from several Muslim-majority nations.

The plaintiffs in the Nielsen v. Preap ruling announced Tuesday included two legal U.S. residents, a Cambodian immigrant convicted of marijuana possession and a Palestinian immigrant convicted of attempting to manufacture a controlled substance.

One of their attorneys was Cecillia Wang, deputy legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union.

“For two terms in a row now, the Supreme Court has endorsed the most extreme interpretation of immigration detention statutes, allowing mass incarceration of people without any hearing, simply because they are defending themselves against a deportation charge,” Wang said in a statement. “We will continue to fight the gross overuse of detention in the immigration system.”

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Immigration

July 11, 2025
by Dan McCue
HHS Bans Undocumented Immigrants From Head Start, Other Taxpayer-Funded Programs

WASHINGTON — The Department of Health and Human Services on Thursday slammed the door on undocumented immigrants accessing taxpayer-funded programs,... Read More

WASHINGTON — The Department of Health and Human Services on Thursday slammed the door on undocumented immigrants accessing taxpayer-funded programs, saying those benefits were never intended to subsidize those in the U.S. illegally. Specifically, the department rescinded a 1998 interpretation of the Personal Responsibility and Work... Read More

The Solution to Trump’s Immigration Debacle? Immigration Reform

Since June 6, immigration enforcement operations have surged across Los Angeles. In just the first 10 days of June, 722 individuals... Read More

Since June 6, immigration enforcement operations have surged across Los Angeles. In just the first 10 days of June, 722 individuals were arrested, according to the Deportation Data Project. But the data tells a deeper story: 417 individuals had no criminal record; 84 others had pending charges;... Read More

New Hampshire Judge to Pause Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order

CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — A federal judge in New Hampshire said Thursday he will certify a class action lawsuit including... Read More

CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — A federal judge in New Hampshire said Thursday he will certify a class action lawsuit including all children who will be affected by President Donald Trump’s executive order ending birthright citizenship and issue a preliminary injunction blocking it. Judge Joseph LaPlante announced his decision after an... Read More

July 3, 2025
by Sydney Devory
Judge Blocks Trump Removal of Temporary Legal Protections for Haitians

WASHINGTON — A federal judge in New York on Tuesday blocked the Trump administration from ending temporary legal status for... Read More

WASHINGTON — A federal judge in New York on Tuesday blocked the Trump administration from ending temporary legal status for more than 500,000 Haitians currently living in the United States. U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan ruled that abruptly moving up the expiration date of the temporary... Read More

Trump Directs ICE to Expand Deportations in Democratic-Run Cities, Undeterred by Protests

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump on Sunday directed federal immigration officials to prioritize deportations from Democratic-run cities, a move that comes... Read More

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump on Sunday directed federal immigration officials to prioritize deportations from Democratic-run cities, a move that comes after large protests erupted in Los Angeles and other major cities against the Trump administration’s immigration policies. Trump in a social media posting called on U.S. Immigration and Customs... Read More

Appeals Court Temporarily Blocks Judge's Ruling to Return Control of National Guard to California

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday temporarily blocked a federal judge’s order that... Read More

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday temporarily blocked a federal judge’s order that directed President Donald Trump to return control of National Guard troops to California after he deployed them there following protests in Los Angeles over immigration raids. The court... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top