Justices Hold Title 42 to Remain in Place Pending Expedited Review

December 28, 2022 by Dan McCue
Justices Hold Title 42 to Remain in Place Pending Expedited Review
Migrants from Venezuela prepare for relocation to a refugee shelter in Matamoros, Mexico, Dec. 23, 2022. (AP Photo/Fernando Llano, File)

WASHINGTON —  A divided Supreme Court on Tuesday held that Title 42, the pandemic-era rule that restricted migration at the southwestern border on public health grounds, will remain in place pending an expedited ruling and future ruling by the justices.

In a brief, unsigned order, a majority of the justices stayed a trial court’s ruling that the Biden administration must lift the measure, and said the court would hear arguments in the case in its February sitting.

The majority went on to explain that the court’s review at that hearing will be limited to the question of intervention — in other words, on whether the 19 mainly Republican-led states that had sought the stay could pursue their challenge to the measure.

“While the underlying merits of the District Court’s summary judgment order are pertinent to that analysis, the court does not grant review of those merits, which have not yet been addressed by the Court of Appeals,” the order said.


Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Neil M. Gorsuch and Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented, arguing that this particular “case-specific decision is not of special importance in its own right and would not normally warrant expedited review.” 

“The D.C. Circuit’s intervention ruling takes on whatever salience it has only because of its presence in a larger underlying dispute about the Title 42 orders,” Gorsuch wrote. “And on that score, it is unclear what we might accomplish. 

“Even if at the end of it all we find that the states are permitted to intervene, and even if the states manage on remand to demonstrate that the Title 42 orders were lawfully adopted, the emergency on which those orders were premised has long since lapsed,” he continued. 


“In April 2022, the federal government terminated the Title 42 orders after determining that emergency immigration restrictions were no longer necessary or appropriate to address COVID-19,” the dissent said. 

“The states may question whether the government followed the right administrative steps before issuing this decision (an issue on which I express no view). But they do not seriously dispute that the public-health justification undergirding the Title 42 orders has lapsed,” Gorsuch added. “And it is hardly obvious why we should rush in to review a ruling on a motion to intervene in a case concerning emergency decrees that have outlived their shelf life.”

The real eye opener in the dissent comes at the end, when Gorsuch conceded he understands the concerns border states have about the end of Title 42 and the “disruptive consenquences” that may come of it.

That said, he wrote, “the current border crisis is not a COVID crisis. And courts should not be in the business of perpetuating administrative edicts designed for one emergency only because elected officials have failed to address a different emergency. We are a court of law, not policymakers of last resort.”

In a statement from the White House, Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said, “The Supreme Court’s order today keeps the current Title 42 policy in place while the court reviews the matter in 2023. We will, of course, comply with the order and prepare for the court’s review.

“At the same time, we are advancing our preparations to manage the border in a secure, orderly and humane way when Title 42 eventually lifts and will continue expanding legal pathways for immigration,” Jean-Pierre continued. “Title 42 is a public health measure, not an immigration enforcement measure, and it should not be extended indefinitely.  


“To truly fix our broken immigration system, we need Congress to pass comprehensive immigration reform measures like the ones President Biden proposed on his first day in office,” she added. “Today’s order gives Republicans in Congress plenty of time to move past political finger-pointing and join their Democratic colleagues in solving the challenge at our border by passing the comprehensive reform measures and delivering the additional funds for border security that President Biden has requested.”

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and @DanMcCue

A+
a-
  • Supreme Court
  • Title 42
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Immigration

    California Investigating if DeSantis Involved in Flying Asylum-Seekers From Texas to Sacramento

    SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — Officials were investigating Tuesday whether Florida's Gov. Ron DeSantis was behind a flight that picked up asylum-seekers on... Read More

    SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — Officials were investigating Tuesday whether Florida's Gov. Ron DeSantis was behind a flight that picked up asylum-seekers on the Texas border and flew them — apparently without their knowledge — to California's capital, even as faith-based groups scrambled to find housing and food for... Read More

    May 11, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    House Republicans Pass Border Bill

    WASHINGTON — House Republicans passed their border protection bill in a 219-213 vote on Thursday, just hours before President Biden... Read More

    WASHINGTON — House Republicans passed their border protection bill in a 219-213 vote on Thursday, just hours before President Biden is about to end the use of the COVID-19 health emergency as a means to bar illegal immigrants from entering the country. That policy, Title 42,... Read More

    May 11, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Trans Asylum Seeker Can Fight Removal in Appeals Court

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Thursday that a transexual woman who fled her native country of Guatemala due... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Thursday that a transexual woman who fled her native country of Guatemala due to alleged gender violence and death threats can appeal her removal from the U.S. in a federal appeals court. Leon Santos-Zacaria, who now goes by the... Read More

    May 8, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    White House Says President Will Veto GOP Border Plan

    WASHINGTON — If the House GOP’s Secure the Border Act — a bill that, among other things, would restart construction... Read More

    WASHINGTON — If the House GOP’s Secure the Border Act — a bill that, among other things, would restart construction of former President Donald Trump’s border wall between the U.S. and Mexico — somehow makes it through the Senate, President Joe Biden will veto it, the... Read More

    May 3, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    House GOP Seek to Restart Work on ‘Trump’ Border Wall

    WASHINGTON — In a new bill, House Republicans are pushing for construction to resume on former President Donald Trump’s wall... Read More

    WASHINGTON — In a new bill, House Republicans are pushing for construction to resume on former President Donald Trump’s wall along the border between the United States and Mexico. Introduced on Tuesday,  H.R. 2, the Secure the Border Act of 2023, runs 213-pages and includes scores... Read More

    January 6, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    White House Toughens Border Policy

    WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden announced Thursday that the United States would immediately begin turning away Cubans, Haitians and Nicaraguans... Read More

    WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden announced Thursday that the United States would immediately begin turning away Cubans, Haitians and Nicaraguans who cross the border from Mexico illegally. The new rules expand on an existing effort to stop Venezuelans attempting to enter the U.S., which began in... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top