Minnesota Suit Against E-Cigarette Maker Juul Goes to Trial

Minnesota Suit Against E-Cigarette Maker Juul Goes to Trial
A Juul electronic cigarette starter kit is seen at a smoke shop on Dec. 20, 2018, in New York. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File)

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison is slated to lead off opening statements expected for Tuesday in his state’s lawsuit against Juul Labs – marking the first time any of the thousands of cases against the e-cigarette maker over its alleged marketing to young people is going to play out in a courtroom.

Minnesota sued Juul in 2019, accusing the San Francisco-based company of unlawfully targeting young people with its products to get a new generation addicted to nicotine. Ellison has declined to put a dollar figure on how much money the state is seeking in damages and civil penalties. But he said when he announced the lawsuit that it could be in the ballpark with Minnesota’s landmark $7.1 billion settlement with the tobacco industry in 1998.

Juul has faced thousands of lawsuits nationwide but most have settled, including 39 with other states and U.S. territories. Minnesota added tobacco industry giant Altria, which formerly owned a minority stake in Juul, as a co-defendant in 2020. Altria completed its divestiture this month and says it effectively lost its $12.8 billion investment. A few days later, Altria announced a $2.75 billion investment in rival electronic cigarette startup NJOY.

“We will prove how Juul and Altria deceived and hooked a generation of Minnesota youth on their products, causing both great harm to the public and great expense to the State to remediate that harm,” Ellison said in a statement.

The jury trial, before Hennepin County District Judge Laurie Miller, is expected to last about three weeks. That contrasts with nearly four months for the landmark 1998 lawsuit by the state and Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota against the big tobacco companies.

That case forced the release of millions of pages of previously secret industry documents and ended in a $7.1 billion settlement just before the state was due to deliver its closing arguments. Part of the money went to fund anti-smoking programs, but both Juul and Altria have pointed out in court filings that lawmakers opted to spend much of the money simply to fund state government.

Ellison plans to deliver part of the state’s opening statement himself before handing it off to attorneys from two outside law firms that are handling the case for Minnesota. The lawsuit alleges consumer fraud, creating a public nuisance, unjust enrichment and conspiracy. A brief filed last week gave a preview of the state’s arguments.

“Defendant JUUL, in a conspiracy joined by Altria, preyed upon and enticed Minnesota’s children, through deceptive and illegal tactics, to buy a product that may sentence them to a lifetime of nicotine addiction and other destructive behaviors,” attorneys for the state wrote. “JUUL embarked on a design and marketing campaign that would ensnare children, focusing on attracting ‘cool kids,’ creating a nicotine ‘buzz,’ and using social media and celebrities to act as ‘pushers’ of its addictive products. Defendants claim their conduct was in the name of helping ‘aging smokers’ to stop smoking. That claim is false; it is a smoke screen.”

Juul said in a statement that Minnesota had rejected settlement offers similar to those it reached with other states, which provided “hundreds of millions of dollars to further combat underage use and develop cessation programs in those states.”

“Effective interventions to address underage use of all tobacco products in Minnesota, including vapor, depends not on headline-driven trials, but on evidence-based policies, programs, and enforcement,” the statement continued. “This is the approach that Juul Labs supports and has been part of implementing.”

Altria Group — the maker of Marlboro cigarettes and other tobacco products formerly known as Phillip Morris Cos. — is minimizing its role. It said in a court filing last week that it bought a 35% stake in Juul Labs in 2018 after its own vaping products failed to gain traction, and only after Juul assured Altria “and announced to the world,” that it had made “meaningful changes” to its marketing practices.

Richmond, Virginia-based Altria said the services it provided to Juul — supplying strategic counter space in stores and distributing a Juul ad and coupons to adult smokers — lasted just over a year and ended in March 2020 And it maintains that its support did not appreciably increase sales of Juul products in Minnesota nor the use of e-cigarettes by minors in the state.

Juul, which launched in 2015, became the U.S. vaping market leader on the popularity of flavors like mango, mint and creme brulee. Its rise was fueled by its use among teenagers, some of whom became hooked on Juul’s high-nicotine pods. Amid the backlash, Juul dropped all U.S. advertising and discontinued most of its flavors in 2019. Juul has since lost popularity with teens, and its share of the multibillion-dollar market has fallen to about 33% from a high of 75%.

In June, the Food and Drug Administration rejected Juul’s application to keep its products on the market as a smoking alternative for adults, though that decision is on appeal. In September, Juul agreed to pay nearly $440 million to settle a two-year investigation by 33 states into its marketing of high-nicotine products.

States with litigation still pending against Juul include New York, California, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Alaska, Illinois and West Virginia, plus the District of Columbia.

A+
a-
  • FDA
  • smoking
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Health

    June 24, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Health Insurers Pledge to Fix ‘Broken’ Prior Authorization System

    WASHINGTON — After meeting with the nation’s top health officials, a consortium of health insurers has promised to take steps... Read More

    WASHINGTON — After meeting with the nation’s top health officials, a consortium of health insurers has promised to take steps to streamline and improve the prior authorization process for plans covering nearly eight out of 10 Americans. The announcement on Monday by Dr. Mehmet Oz, administrator... Read More

    June 23, 2025
    by Alexa Citrin
    Texas Mandates Warning Labels on Foods With Harmful Additives

    AUSTIN, Texas — A bill signed into law by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott on Sunday could have sweeping implications for... Read More

    AUSTIN, Texas — A bill signed into law by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott on Sunday could have sweeping implications for the nation’s food industry. The first-of-its-kind legislation requires manufacturers of processed foods and drinks to put warning labels on products containing any one of 44 different... Read More

    June 23, 2025
    by Jesse Zucker
    Hang In There: Your Guide to Dead Hangs and Pull-Ups

    WASHINGTON — Dead hangs and pull-ups might sound simple: just hang down or pull yourself up, but both are surprisingly... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Dead hangs and pull-ups might sound simple: just hang down or pull yourself up, but both are surprisingly tough. They’ve been popping up all over social media lately thanks to a viral dead hang challenge where people try to hang from a pull-up bar... Read More

    June 23, 2025
    by Jesse Zucker
    Stay Cool as a Cucumber This Summer!

    WASHINGTON — There’s something about a cucumber that just feels like summer. Maybe it’s the cool, watery snap when you... Read More

    WASHINGTON — There’s something about a cucumber that just feels like summer. Maybe it’s the cool, watery snap when you bite into one. Or maybe it’s that they show up in everything from salads to spa treatments. However you slice them, cucumbers are one of the... Read More

    Health Insurers Promise to Improve Coverage Reviews That Prompt Delays and Complaints

    The nation’s major health insurers are promising to scale back and improve a widely despised practice that leads to care... Read More

    The nation’s major health insurers are promising to scale back and improve a widely despised practice that leads to care delays and complications. UnitedHealthcare, CVS Health's Aetna and dozens of other insurers say they plan to reduce the scope of health care claims subject to prior... Read More

    NFL Widows Struggled to Care for Former Players With CTE. They Say a New Study Minimizes Their Pain

    BOSTON (AP) — Dozens of widows and other caregivers for former NFL players diagnosed with CTE say a published study... Read More

    BOSTON (AP) — Dozens of widows and other caregivers for former NFL players diagnosed with CTE say a published study is insulting and dismissive of their experience living with the degenerative brain disease that has been linked to concussions and other repeated head trauma common in contact sports... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top