Expert Discusses Gaps in Federal Policy to Ban Surprise Medical Bills

January 5, 2022 by Alexa Hornbeck
Expert Discusses Gaps in Federal Policy to Ban Surprise Medical Bills
The Los Angeles County+USC Medical Center's patient drop-off and pick-up area is seen in Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes)

WASHINGTON — A federal law banning surprise medical bills U.S. patients may receive following an emergency room visit, air ambulance trip, or receiving care out-of-network went into effect on Jan 1., but health policy expert Jack Hoadley finds that gaps in the legislation may leave some patients unprotected. 

“It covers a pretty high share of all situations where you’re treated by someone you didn’t pick outside of your insurance network. An area that is missed is ground ambulance transportation,” said Hoadley, a research professor emeritus in the Health Policy Institute of Georgetown University’s McCourt School of Public Policy, in a phone call with The Well News. 

The legislation protects patients in most emergency cases, non-elective emergency cases, and air ambulances, but according to Hoadley, ground ambulance trips are not included as they tend to occur out-of-network.

Hoadley said urgent care centers are included under the law but only when the urgent care centers are licensed by the state to treat emergencies.

“Most states don’t license their facilities for this. So, states that do not license an urgent care center to provide emergency services are vulnerable to surprise bills,” said Hoadley.

Jack Hoadley is a research professor emeritus in the Health Policy Institute of Georgetown University’s McCourt School of Public Policy.

An estimated one in five patients in the U.S. will get hit with an unexpected medical bill which can go as high as $100,000.

Congress included the No Surprises Act as part of the omnibus spending bill that was passed and signed into law on Dec. 27, 2020.

However, many states like New Jersey and California had already moved forward in implementing their own policies to limit surprise billing practices. 

“The federal law defers to any existing state laws. So, New Jersey will continue to have their arbitration approach, California has a rate standard. The new federal system would apply to any state that doesn’t have an existing method. It’s too early to know if states will make adjustments,” said Hoadley. 

A total of 11 states have already implemented laws to protect patients from surprise bills when it comes to ground ambulance transportation, Hoadley said. 

“Any state level protection that protects consumers is allowed to protect them. Any state with a specified state law with a method for setting payments, it defers to those laws, and there is no requirement that it is less inflationary,” said Hoadley. 

“Some of those states like New Jersey and Texas may be more inflationary, while others like California may be less,” continued Hoadley. 

Prior to the federal effort to ban surprise medical bills, research showed that a number of physician staffing companies used surprise billing as their business model and sought to change the outcome of the No Surprises Act. 

“That ability to leverage the system is not taken away, but mostly taken away. That is why we expect some potential reduction in those premiums,” said Hoadley. 

The Congressional Budget Office estimates that the No Surprises Act will reduce premiums by between 0.5% and 1%.

“The whole point … in focusing on an in-network rate was done in order to avoid inflationary impact on premiums. The law was written in a way to hold the out-of-network payments to an in-network level,” said Hoadley.

Hoadley said the law should be self-enforcing and place the burden on the system and not the patient, but if a patient does receive a surprise medical bill, they are encouraged to file a complaint through the Department of Health and Human Services hotline.

A greater challenge, he said, will be educating physicians and insurers to understand how the law applies.

“It’s going to be a little bit of learning on the fly, but we are aware anecdotally that hospital associations and insurers are putting out bulletins and posting information to state insurance departments. There’s a lot of educational potential out there,” said Hoadley. 

Alexa can be reached at [email protected]

A+
a-
  • California
  • Congressional Budget Office
  • federal policy
  • Georgetown University
  • Jack Hoadley
  • McCourt School of public Policy
  • New Jersey
  • No Surprise Act
  • surprise medical bills
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Health

    May 16, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    YouTube Personality ‘Doctor Mike’ Finally Gets Taken Seriously

    WASHINGTON — It’s a moment “Doctor Mike” Varshavski still describes as both a blessing and a curse. Here he was,... Read More

    WASHINGTON — It’s a moment “Doctor Mike” Varshavski still describes as both a blessing and a curse. Here he was, a young doctor in the middle of his residency in 2015, when thanks to his presence on Instagram, he found himself in the pages of People... Read More

    Mandating ‘Preventive Services’ Not What the Doctor Ordered

    The Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, has been anything but affordable. Despite all the talk about “bending the cost curve,”... Read More

    The Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, has been anything but affordable. Despite all the talk about “bending the cost curve,” benefit costs have far outpaced inflation since the 2010s and national annual health care spending is now an astounding $5 trillion. The good news is that the Supreme Court... Read More

    Missouri Lawmakers Approve Referendum to Repeal Abortion-Rights Amendment

    JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — Six months after Missouri voters approved an abortion-rights amendment, Republican state lawmakers on Wednesday approved... Read More

    JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — Six months after Missouri voters approved an abortion-rights amendment, Republican state lawmakers on Wednesday approved a new referendum that would seek the amendment's repeal and instead ban most abortions with exceptions for rape an incest. The newly proposed constitutional amendment would... Read More

    May 14, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    EPA Revises Rules on ‘Forever Chemicals’ Found in Drinking Water

    WASHINGTON — The Environmental Protection Agency announced Wednesday that it is rolling back limits on the "forever chemicals" that have... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Environmental Protection Agency announced Wednesday that it is rolling back limits on the "forever chemicals" that have been found in the nation's drinking water. The chemicals, known as PFAS, have been linked to cancer and reproductive health problems. They are commonly used in... Read More

    May 14, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Kennedy Defends ‘Streamlining’ of HHS During Budget Hearings 

    WASHINGTON — Testifying on Capitol Hill for the first time as the nation’s leading health official, Health Secretary Robert Kennedy... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Testifying on Capitol Hill for the first time as the nation’s leading health official, Health Secretary Robert Kennedy Jr. on Wednesday defended his bare bones request for $94 billion to run his department, as well as steps he’s taken since January to dramatically cut... Read More

    Maryland Gov. Moore Signs Bill to Tap Unused ACA Insurance Funds for Abortion Grant Program

    ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — Maryland will become the first state to use money collected from a surcharge on insurance plans... Read More

    ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — Maryland will become the first state to use money collected from a surcharge on insurance plans sold under the Affordable Care Act to fund a program to pay for abortions, regardless of a patient's insurance coverage, under a measure signed into law Tuesday by... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top