Gun Control Movement Has More Momentum Than Ever; Will That Matter This Time?
In a nation where mourning the most recent mass shooting has become routine, the weekend’s two massacres in El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio, brought another opportunity for reckoning.
This time, the shootings come after a year of increased momentum for the gun control movement and internal fracturing for the National Rifle Association. This time, there is a comprehensive package of bills proposed in Congress aimed at preventing gun violence, including a background check bill and other legislation already passed by the House and waiting for votes in the Senate.
But this time, there is also a recognition that not one mass shooting, from Sandy Hook in 2012 to Dayton on Sunday, has created a true political tipping point. President Donald Trump did not endorse sweeping gun control legislation or mention the background check bill in a televised statement from the White House condemning the killings Monday morning, and there is little, if anything, to indicate that the dynamics in Washington that have prevented any legislative response to mass shootings will change.
Some people saw no reason for optimism in the wake of the most recent killings.
“If you couldn’t act on legislation when 20 first-graders were killed, if you couldn’t act when high school students … were killed, if you couldn’t act when church members praising their God were killed — if you couldn’t act then … I don’t know how we’re going to act now,” said Camille Parkinson, 18, a recent graduate of Henderson High School in West Chester, Pa., and gun control activist.
Trump endorsed a single piece of legislation, the red flag law, which seeks to improve reporting of people whose families believe they may be a danger, and suggested that the death penalty be made mandatory for perpetrators of mass shootings. He had also suggested in a morning tweet that Congress consider background check legislation along with an immigration package.
With Congress out of session until after Labor Day, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., called for the Senate to come back into session “immediately” to pass the universal background-check bill already approved by the House. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., “refuses to act on this bipartisan legislation,” they said in a joint statement.
McConnell tweeted Sunday expressing prayers for the victims. “Two horrifying acts of violence in less than 24 hours. We stand with law enforcement as they continue working to keep Americans safe and bring justice,” he said.
Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., said he had spoken to both Trump and McConnell on Monday morning. He said he didn’t think the Senate would accomplish anything if it were brought back to session this week, saying senators should take time to build support for legislation. He said Congress should pass the background check bill he proposed with Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W. Va., after the 2012 Sandy Hook massacre, but that never won widespread support. He also endorsed calls for a national red flag law.
“This isn’t going to happen tomorrow and if we force a vote tomorrow, then I think the vote probably fails and we may actually set back this whole effort,” Toomey told reporters Monday afternoon.
The House has passed four pieces of gun control legislation awaiting Senate action.
One would establish universal background checks, making checks required for all firearm purchases, including those done through private parties. Another would prohibit any firearms from being transferred to a buyer before the required background check has been completed, even if the background check takes extra time.
A third provides funding for the Centers for Disease Control to study gun violence. The last reauthorizes the Violence Against Women Act, which would restrict people with a misdemeanor conviction of domestic abuse or stalking from buying guns and provide for programs and funding to prevent domestic and dating violence.
“The House has acted. Why doesn’t the majority in the Senate feel the same urgency?” tweeted Rep. Madeleine Dean, D-Pa., on Saturday.
In the last year and a half, the political momentum of the gun control movement has accelerated, largely propelled by outrage after the 2018 shooting that killed 17 at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla.
In November’s elections, more candidates embraced gun control; Democrats, gaining a majority in the House, prioritized gun legislation; and several states, such as New Jersey, have passed their own stricter gun laws.
“Parkland actually was able to put gun violence squarely in the face of everybody,” said Serita Lewis, a Philadelphia anti-gun violence activist who has worked with local youth on the issue. “Has anything really happened in the past year and a half that really is making change? No. We’re seeing even more shootings happening now.”
Parkinson, the Pennsylvania teen who said she was at her high school graduation party when the news of the El Paso shooting broke, said she is “very ready” to vote in her first presidential election 2020, listing background checks and an assault weapons ban as her top gun control priorities.
“I’m still just as fearful as when Parkland happened — as when Sandy Hook happened and I was in middle school — and now I’m graduating high school and I feel like the fear just keeps growing and growing and growing,” said Parkinson, who is leaving for college in a few weeks.
“My grandma always goes to Walmart, and now she’s fearful to go to Walmart herself because you never know when and where it could happen.”
©2019 The Philadelphia Inquirer
Visit The Philadelphia Inquirer at www.inquirer.com
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
In The News
WASHINGTON — Congressional negotiators agreed to spend $25 million to study gun violence in America next year, the first time in more than two decades that federal funds will be dedicated to researching the contentious issue. The National Institutes of Health and the Centers for Disease... Read More
SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Zachary Berg usually buys guns and ammunition with relative ease. After all, he’s a Sutter County sheriff’s deputy and needs them for his job. California’s stringent gun laws usually don’t apply to him. But Berg couldn’t buy shotgun shells at his local hardware... Read More
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court justices sounded uncertain Monday over whether to rule on a major gun-rights case, since New York City has repealed the disputed law at issue that restricted carrying a licensed weapon outside the city. The gun owners who sued “got everything they... Read More
SANTA CLARITA, Calif. — Authorities said the shooting at Saugus High School that left two students dead and three wounded Thursday occurred over a 16-second period in which a classmate pulled out a gun in the quad area and opened fire. The gunfire broke out at... Read More
WASHINGTON — Senate Democrats on Wednesday introduced the same Violence Against Women Act reauthorization bill passed by the House, days after they say talks with Republicans about a compromise broke down over controversial gun provisions. The entire Democratic caucus has backed the bill, which has provisions... Read More
WASHINGTON - A bipartisan bill introduced by Reps. Kathleen Rice, D-N.Y., and Mike Turner, R-Ohio, will create incentives for states to provide complete domestic violence records to federal background check databases. Rep. Rice announced the filing of the bill at Bethany House in Baldwin, N.Y., where... Read More