GOP Members Storm Impeachment Hearing, Alleging Lack of Access

October 24, 2019by Katherine Tully-McManus
WASHINGTON, DC OCTOBER 23, 2019 House Minority Whip Steve Scalise (R-LA) pauses while speaking during a press conference alongside House Republicans on Capitol Hill on October 23, 2019 in Washington, DC. The conference called for transparency regarding the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump. (Photo by Alex Wroblewski/Getty Images/TNS)

WASHINGTON — Defying established security protocols, a cadre of House Republicans led by Minority Whip Steve Scalise and Rep. Matt Gaetz stormed the Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility (SCIF) in the Capitol Visitor Center on Wednesday, where the top Pentagon official overseeing U.S. policy in Ukraine was giving her deposition for the House’s impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump.

Hours into a standoff between frustrated Republicans and Democrats leading the impeachment inquiry, a handful of GOP members remained sitting in the SCIF, refusing to leave.

Rep. Michael Waltz told reporters that when he and other Republican members entered the room to hear testimony from Laura Cooper, the deputy assistant secretary of Defense for Russia, Ukraine, and Eurasia, Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff stood up and walked out, accompanied by the witness.

“What is Adam Schiff trying to hide?” Scalise said as Republicans tried to enter the secure area. “They don’t even let the president’s legal counsel question people who are making baseless allegations. Maybe in the Soviet Union this kind of thing is commonplace. This shouldn’t be happening in the United States of America, where they’re trying to impeach a president in secret behind closed doors.”

Intelligence member Val Demings said Republicans “are under a lot of stress” because of what she said is clear wrongdoing by the president.

“I guess when you’re desperate you go back to complaining about the process and that’s what they’re doing,” the Florida Democrat said.

This is not the first time Republican members have “stormed the SCIF” to make a statement about what they view as a lack of transparency from Schiff and how the investigation is operating.

Rep. Jim Jordan, the top Republican on the Oversight panel, has been among the loudest voices calling for greater access to information about the impeachment inquiry in recent weeks.

“It’s gotten so petty from the Democrats, yesterday they even took the chairs out, took the benches out, where our staff sits, outside of the area. Removed those so staff can’t even be there and have a place to sit,” Jordan said.

He said that the frustration among Republicans has “finally reached a boiling point,” and said that the situation has reached a “standstill.”

Republicans have attacked the closed-door impeachment depositions for weeks, calling for transcripts to be released to all members of Congress and the American public. Republican members who requested to read the transcripts of testimony in the impeachment inquiry have been denied access because they were not on the committees of jurisdiction.

On Tuesday House Intelligence member Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., told reporters that there are limitations to impeachment inquiry transcripts for committee members that she calls “unprecedented.”

She said that Intelligence members were notified this week that the panels would only print one copy of a transcript, for every member of Congress to view.

“And you would have to read it with a member of Democratic staff, that is unprecedented and unfair,” she said.

“Americans should know that their member of Congress has had no access to any of the transcripts,” Stefanik said.

Schiff, his staff and House Intelligence Committee Democrats have not confirmed this policy or responded to request for comment.

As the Republicans stormed the secure area, several brought their cellphones with them into the secure area, according to Democratic Reps. Ted Lieu and Harley Rouda of California.

Cellphones, which the Director of National Intelligence considers “high-vulnerability” devices, must undergo a rigorous risk-mitigation protocol to be allowed into a SCIF. They are specifically designed to thwart attempts at electronic eavesdropping, if protocols are followed.

Jordan acknowledged that the cellphone mishap by his colleagues crossed a boundary that should remain in place.

“They shouldn’t do that. They’re not used to this. They walked in, as soon as they were told that, they set their phones out,” Jordan said when asked about his GOP colleagues bringing their phones into the SCIF.

“It was a mistake, No big deal. They shouldn’t do that. They understand now and it won’t happen again,” he continued.

Republicans said Schiff was threatening GOP lawmakers with ethics violations related to the stunt. Schiff was also consulting with the House’s sergeant at arms and multiple members confirmed that House Sergeant-at-Arms Paul D. Irving was present.

“They violated House rules by trying to crash committees of which they don’t sit on,” said Lieu.

He said that the House Parliamentarian had been consulted, once again, on the issue of barring members not on the committees of jurisdiction from the proceedings.

“The House Parliamentarian has ruled that you just can’t crash committees,” Lieu said.

Democrats who were present for the Republicans’ efforts to enter and participate in the deposition said that it is up to Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Schiff whether or not to pursue a complaint in the House Ethics Committee for any potential violations of House rules.

“Foreign adversaries really, really want to know what’s happening in this type of room,” Mieke Eoyang, a former Democratic Intelligence Committee aide who worked on cyber issues told CQ Roll Call.

“That they rushed past the security protocols shows a disregard for both the threat that they’re under (as targets of foreign intelligence operatives) and the risk to the facility,” Eoyang said.

In most facilities where lawmakers discuss classified information, there is usually a series of small cubbies outside the room for participants to store their devices. In some cases, it’s a communal basket.

“That can lead to some confusion on the back end, when everyone’s phone looks the same,” Eoyang said.

Eoyang questioned House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy’s and Jordan’s comments defending the GOP lawmakers on grounds that they don’t regularly attend classified briefings and thus don’t aren’t familiar with security particulars.

“Members who have been around awhile have been to classified briefings before,” Eoyang said. “They know the protocol.”


Lindsey McPherson, Niels Lesniewski and Griffin Connolly contributed to this report.


©2019 CQ-Roll Call, Inc., All Rights Reserved

Visit CQ Roll Call at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


Trump Gets More Time to Appeal Lawsuit Over Sealed Mueller Notes
Trump Gets More Time to Appeal Lawsuit Over Sealed Mueller Notes

WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court gave the Trump administration 10 more days to seek U.S. Supreme Court intervention to block House Democrats from gaining access to confidential materials from Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation. If the high court doesn’t agree to hear the administration’s challenge... Read More

Top Ally Defends Trump’s Firing of Two Key Impeachment Witnesses
In The News
Top Ally Defends Trump’s Firing of Two Key Impeachment Witnesses

WASHINGTON — Sen. Lindsey Graham defended President Donald Trump’s ouster of two witnesses from his administration whom he blames for his impeachment, and suggested he would like to see one of the men questioned further. Graham, a South Carolina Republican and top Trump ally, said Sunday... Read More

Trump Airs Grievances After Impeachment Acquittal
Political News
Trump Airs Grievances After Impeachment Acquittal

WASHINGTON — A day after his acquittal in the Senate, President Donald Trump celebrated with Republican allies and ripped Democrats — and the lone Republican — who backed his conviction, expressing a litany of lingering grievances in a somewhat subdued stream-of-consciousness monologue. “It worked out,” Trump... Read More

View From the Gallery: Senators Pack Up Desks as Impeachment Trial Nears Its End
In The News
View From the Gallery: Senators Pack Up Desks as Impeachment Trial Nears Its End

WASHINGTON — Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer tightly hugged Rep. Adam B. Schiff just after the closing argument in President Donald Trump’s impeachment trial, then spoke directly into the House lead manager’s ear for about 10 seconds. Before the New York senator let go, he... Read More

Senate Votes Against Calling Witnesses in Trump Impeachment Trial
Senate Votes Against Calling Witnesses in Trump Impeachment Trial

WASHINGTON — The Senate voted narrowly Friday to bring the impeachment trial of President Donald Trump to a close without issuing subpoenas for witnesses or evidence, rejecting Democrats’ principal demand and clearing the way for an all-but-certain acquittal to take place likely next week. The vote,... Read More

What Happens If Senators Are Tied 50-50 on Whether to Call Impeachment Witnesses?
In The News
What Happens If Senators Are Tied 50-50 on Whether to Call Impeachment Witnesses?

WASHINGTON — With increasing prospects of a 50-50 tie on the Friday vote to subpoena witnesses in President Trump’s impeachment trial, Democrats are considering how they might be able to nudge Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. to weigh in on the issue and break the... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top