Biden Repeal of Trump ICC Sanctions Welcome, But Concerns Remain

April 6, 2021 by Dan McCue
Biden Repeal of Trump ICC Sanctions Welcome, But Concerns Remain
ICC prosecutor Fatou Bensouda on the BBC in 2017.

WASHINGTON – Human rights organizations around the world cheered President Joe Biden’s decision to cancel punitive sanctions against the International Criminal Court, but they also agree serious obstacles remain to achieving justice for some of the world’s worst crimes.

The court was created in 2002 to hold accountable perpetrators of war crimes and crimes against humanity in cases where adequate judicial systems were not available in the countries where the crimes occured.

As of December 2020, the ICC had 123 member states; another 42 states have some interaction with the court, but have not signed or become parties to its central document, the Rome Statutes.

The United States has belonged to the latter group since the founding of the ICC, out of concern the court might be used for politically motivated prosecutions of American troops and officials.

President Bill Clinton set the standard for criticizing the court, though some of his predecessors, notably President Barack Obama, did manage to engage in some small level of cooperation with it.

That all changed with the Trump administration, which was openly hostile to the tribunal from the start, and was particularly critical of Chief Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda, and the court´s Head of Jurisdiction, Phakiso Mochochoko, for pressing ahead with prosecutions of Americans for actions in Afghanistan and Israelis for actions against the Palestinians.

The Trump administration accused the ICC of infringing on U.S. national sovereignty when it authorized an investigation into war crimes committed by Afghan forces, the Taliban or U.S. troops.

In September, it targeted court staff, including Bensouda, with asset freezes and travel bans for investigating American citizens without U.S. consent.

The ICC said the sanctions were an attack on international justice and the rule of law.

Though President Biden’s executive order wipes the slate clean of Trump’s belligerent policy, the U.S. continues to reject the ICC’s claims to jurisdiction over the U.S. and Israel.

Nevertheless, the move is seen as another attempt to re-engage with the foreign policy community after four years of semi-isolationism under Trump.

Since taking office, the Biden administration has rejoined the World Health Organization, re-engaged with the U.N. Human Rights Council, returned to the Paris climate accord and started talks aimed at returning to the Iran nuclear deal. 

Among those who cheered the administration’s decision on the ICC was Richard Dicker, international justice director for Human Rights watch.

“The Trump administration’s perversely punitive sanctions against the ICC showed stark contempt for the victims of grave international crimes and the prosecutors who seek to hold those responsible to account,” Dicker said in a written statement.

“In removing this unprecedented threat to the global rule of law, President Biden has begun the long process of restoring US credibility on international justice through the ICC.”

Human Rights Watch had urged the Biden administration to make rescinding Trump’s executive order a priority.

Among other things, it argued, Trump’s policy created apprehension and uncertainty for nongovernmental organizations, consultants, and lawyers who work with the ICC in investigative and adjudicative capacities. 

“The ICC has its limitations, but its role as a court of last resort for the worst crimes is needed now more than ever,” Dicker said. 

“The Biden administration should back the ICC to ensure that victims get a chance for justice and that cooperation should be the rule, not the exception,” he added.

Another organization that weighed in on the change in policy was the American Civil Liberties Union.

“We are pleased President Biden has finally rescinded President Trump’s unconstitutional sanctions order. This is a victory for our clients and all those who support the ICC’s pursuit of justice,” said Scarlet Kim, staff attorney with  the ACLU’s National Security Project. 

“The unprecedented sanctions on the ICC were yet another terrible legacy of the Trump administration, which made clear its disregard for human rights and the rule of law,” Kim said.

The ACLU has maintained that Trump’s sanctions had devastating consequences for many of its clients. 

“[They] ground my work to a halt,” said Leila Sadat, special adviser on crimes against humanity to the prosecutor of the ICC.

“This decision by the Biden administration opens the door for me and my co-plaintiffs to be able to return to our essential human rights work,” she said.

The Center for Constitutional Rights said in a statement that Trump’s sanctions “set a dangerous precedent for attacks on victims, lawyers, human rights advocates, and courts, and Biden’s repeal is a welcome – if overdue – step toward curtailing U.S. obstruction of accountability at the International Criminal Court for the most serious crimes.

“With the odious Executive Order rescinded, the United States has an opportunity to reset its relationship with the ICC – and justice issues more broadly. It can demonstrate that its pledge to ‘stand against human rights abuses wherever they occur, regardless of whether the perpetrators are adversaries or partners’ is more than just rhetoric.

“To do so, it must cease efforts to undercut the independence of the ICC, whether through direct threats or punishments on those seeking justice, or through proxies seeking to exercise influence over the court’s docket through decisions about its budget,” the organization said. “It must affirmatively support victims and their advocates and denounce smear campaigns against them. And it must cease speaking of ‘peace’ and ‘justice’ as binary choices rather than mutually reinforcing principles.

“The last four years were marked by utter disregard for human rights and the rule of law,” the group concluded. “To turn that page, the United States must finally make good on the mantra that ‘no one is above the law.’”

A+
a-
  • ACLU
  • ICC
  • International Criminal Court
  • Joe Biden
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Foreign Affairs

    At Paris Gathering, Western Leaders to Show Unity for Ukraine and Signal 'Russia Cannot Win'

    PARIS (AP) — More than 20 European heads of state and government and other Western officials are gathering in a... Read More

    PARIS (AP) — More than 20 European heads of state and government and other Western officials are gathering in a show of unity for Ukraine, signaling to Russia that their support for Kyiv isn't wavering as the full-scale invasion grinds into a third year. French President Emmanuel Macron,... Read More

    Unlikely Challenger to Putin Brings Rare Show of Defiance, Creating Dilemma for Kremlin

    They have lined up by the thousands across Russia in recent days, standing in the bitter cold for a chance... Read More

    They have lined up by the thousands across Russia in recent days, standing in the bitter cold for a chance to sign petitions to support an unlikely challenger to President Vladimir Putin. Boris Nadezhdin has become a dilemma for the Kremlin as he seeks to run... Read More

    The UK and France Reiterate Russia's Invasion of Ukraine Must End in Failure as US Aid Falters

    PARIS (AP) — Britain and France reiterated their determination Tuesday that Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine ends in failure, with the U.K.... Read More

    PARIS (AP) — Britain and France reiterated their determination Tuesday that Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine ends in failure, with the U.K. foreign minister saying that Ukraine's allies must better leverage their economic might to vastly outmatch Moscow's war machine. The renewed insistence from U.K. Foreign Secretary David... Read More

    China's State Media Take a New Tone Toward US Ahead of Meeting Between Leaders

    Ahead of the highly anticipated meeting on Wednesday between U.S. President Joe Biden and Chinese leader Xi Jinping, Chinese state media have... Read More

    Ahead of the highly anticipated meeting on Wednesday between U.S. President Joe Biden and Chinese leader Xi Jinping, Chinese state media have taken a new tone toward the U.S. with less negative coverage, calls for a return to warmer ties and stories of Americans with positive connections to... Read More

    Albanese Arrives at White House to Start Day of Meetings and Celebrations

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden pressed forward with this week's state visit from Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, carving out time... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden pressed forward with this week's state visit from Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, carving out time to nurture the relationship with a critical U.S. ally in the Pacific against the backdrop of escalating fighting between Israel and Hamas. The state visit, only the... Read More

    Live Updates | Cease-Fire Pleas and Israel-Hamas Recriminations Rise in Wake of Gaza Hospital Blast

    President Joe Biden is in Israel on an urgent mission to keep the Israel-Hamas war from spiraling into a broader... Read More

    President Joe Biden is in Israel on an urgent mission to keep the Israel-Hamas war from spiraling into a broader regional conflict and to encourage the delivery of humanitarian aid to the Palestinians. The president's visit on Wednesday came after hundreds of people were reported killed... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top