Federal Judge Hears Arguments to Halt Georgia’s New Anti-Abortion Law

September 24, 2019by Maya T. Prabhu
Andrea Young, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Georgia, speaks at a press conference following the American Civil Liberties Union, the ACLU of Georgia, the Center for Reproductive Rights, and Planned Parenthood filing of a lawsuit challenging Georgia's HB 41, the "heartbeat bill," on the steps of the Richard B. Russell Federal Building, on Ted Turner Drive SW in Atlanta, Ga. on Friday, June 28, 2019. (Christina Matacotta/Atlanta Journal-Constitution/TNS)

ATLANTA — A federal judge said Monday that he hoped to determine soon whether the court should block Georgia’s new anti-abortion law from going into effect, but he hinted at the potential long road ahead for the case.

It’s unclear when U.S. District Judge Steve C. Jones will rule on the request from the American Civil Liberties Union of Georgia to halt the new law, which bans most abortions once a doctor can detect fetal cardiac activity.

Any ruling in the case would almost certainly be appealed.

“I recognize I’m not going to be the last word on this case,” Jones said.

The law is scheduled to go into effect Jan. 1. The ACLU has asked Jones to rule before then.

Attorneys for the ACLU said the new law is essentially a ban on abortions, but lawyers for the state said the procedure still could be performed before cardiac activity is detected.

The new law could outlaw abortions as early as six weeks into a pregnancy, which is before many women know they are pregnant.

The legal arguments were similar to those made in other states that passed similar legislation this year, but they also focused on “personhood” language in the Georgia law, which extends legal rights to fertilized eggs.

Arguing for the ACLU, attorney Susan Talcott Camp said the law violates a woman’s constitutional right of access to abortion until about 24 weeks of pregnancy, as established by the 1973 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Roe v. Wade.

“No state interest is strong enough to justify banning abortion before the point of viability,” Camp said. “A ban at any point before viability must fall.”

The ACLU is suing the state on behalf of the SisterSong Women of Color Reproductive Justice Collective, the Feminist Women’s Health Center, Planned Parenthood Southeast and other abortion rights advocates and providers.

At least 15 states have considered versions of fetal cardiac legislation this year.

Governors in Kentucky, Mississippi and Ohio all have signed similar bills. Federal judges have already issued a preliminary injunction against laws in those states, and similar laws enacted in recent years in Iowa and North Dakota have also been struck down in the courts.

Jones questioned whether a district judge had the authority to overturn U.S. Supreme Court precedent.

Patrick Strawbridge, a private attorney representing the state, said he didn’t believe allowing the new law to go into effect would undermine previous court rulings.

“I don’t think the U.S. Supreme Court has answered this specific question,” Strawbridge said.

Jones asked attorneys on both sides of the argument whether they thought it was possible to keep the “personhood” pieces of the law intact while stopping the abortion ban from going into effect.

That language would allow parents, once a heartbeat is detected, to claim an embryo on their taxes as a dependent, and it would be counted toward the state’s population. A court can also order a father to pay child support after a heartbeat is detected.

Camp said the purpose of the law, House Bill 481, was to ban abortions and the “personhood” language was inserted only to “create a framework to justify banning abortion and therefore all of the provisions should be struck down.”

Strawbridge pushed back, saying establishing tax credits and allowing a mother to collect child support while still pregnant will benefit the parents of many of the more than 100,000 children born each year. He said each provision should be considered on its own.

“This is not window dressing,” he said. “The Legislature is putting its money where its mouth is.”

In Georgia, later abortions still are allowed in cases of rape, incest, if the life of the woman is in danger or in instances of “medical futility,” when a fetus would not be able to survive after birth. To obtain an abortion after six weeks of pregnancy because of rape or incest, a woman would have to file a police report.

Current Georgia law, passed by the Legislature in 2012, allows abortions through 20 weeks of pregnancy.

Georgia’s law is one of several that have moved through Republican-run state governments across the country with the express purpose of challenging Roe v. Wade.

Anti-abortion activists have seized upon the opportunity created after last year’s appointment of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, tilting the bench in the favor of conservatives.

There are already about 20 lawsuits involving abortion that the U.S. Supreme Court could consider that would challenge Roe v. Wade, but supporters of Georgia’s new law said they believe it is the one that will overturn the landmark ruling.

In a news conference after the hearing, Feminist Women’s Health Center Executive Director Kwajelyn Jackson stressed that the doors of her clinic and others in Georgia remain open.

“As medical service providers, we will continue to provide the abortion care that we have always provided,” she said. “We will continue to center our patients’ needs and will continue to work to make sure that they have not only the medical services that they deserve, but also all of the rights and recognitions that they need to thrive in Georgia.”


©2019 The Atlanta Journal-Constitution (Atlanta, Ga.)

Visit The Atlanta Journal-Constitution (Atlanta, Ga.) at www.ajc.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

State News

Feds Fault University, Florida Agency and Contractors for Deadly Bridge Collapse State News
Feds Fault University, Florida Agency and Contractors for Deadly Bridge Collapse

WASHINGTON — During a hearing Tuesday on last year’s deadly collapse of the Florida International University pedestrian footbridge, the National Transportation Safety Board heard evidence from its staff engineers and investigators showing that the bridge’s “catastrophic failure” stemmed from a flawed design with “significant errors.” In... Read More

Embattled Texas House Speaker Dennis Bonnen Won’t Seek Re-Election State News
Embattled Texas House Speaker Dennis Bonnen Won’t Seek Re-Election

AUSTIN, Texas — Texas House Speaker Dennis Bonnen said Tuesday that he will not seek re-election. His decision to not seek another term comes after a secret recording, released by conservative activist Michael Quinn Sullivan, captured Bonnen offering media credentials in exchange for Sullivan targeting “moderate”... Read More

GAO Report Says US Public Land Workers Face Assaults, Threats Public Lands
GAO Report Says US Public Land Workers Face Assaults, Threats
October 22, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - Federal employees overseeing public lands in the U.S. were assaulted or threatened at least 360 times over a five-year period ending in 2017, a sign of increased tensions between the employees and anti-government groups, the Government Accountability Office said Monday. The findings were the... Read More

Florida Senate Opens Session to Decide Fate of Broward Sheriff State News
Florida Senate Opens Session to Decide Fate of Broward Sheriff

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Emotions were high and security tight Monday as the Florida Senate convened a three-day special session to decide whether or not to uphold Gov. Ron DeSantis’ suspension of Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel. At an early morning press conference, the parents of the... Read More

California Independents Can Cast Ballots for Democrats — But Not Trump — In March Primary 2020 Elections
California Independents Can Cast Ballots for Democrats — But Not Trump — In March Primary

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — California voters who are unaffiliated with a political party will be able to participate in the Democratic presidential primary next year, but they will be prohibited from casting ballots for President Donald Trump or any possible Republican challenger, according to information released Monday... Read More

Trump Trails Top Democrats in New Minnesota Poll 2020 Elections
Trump Trails Top Democrats in New Minnesota Poll

MINNEAPOLIS — President Donald Trump trails several leading Democratic candidates, as well as U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar, at this point in the presidential campaign in Minnesota, according to a new Star Tribune Minnesota Poll. The two current front-runners for the Democratic nomination, former Vice President Joe... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top