Budget Hawks Urge Lawmakers to Address COVID-19 Crisis, But Heed Its Lessons

March 25, 2020 by Dan McCue
The U.S. Capitol. Feb. 4, 2020. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON – Despite the fact the White House and Senate were able to reach a deal on a roughly $2 trillion stimulus bill early Wednesday, the U.S. economy is still facing a huge shock to its system, the president of the St. Louis Federal Reserve said.

Speaking on CNBC’s “Squawk Box” program, the St. Louis Fed’s James Bullard, who previously predicted the nation’s unemployment rate could rise to 30% during the pandemic, said while the near-term prognosis for the economy may be rough, it will bounce back.

“This number will be unparalleled, but don’t get discouraged,” Bullard said, tempering his earlier dire prediction.

“This is a special quarter, and once the virus goes away and if we play our cards right and keep everything intact, then everyone will go back to work and everything will be fine,” he said.

The Fed bank president went on to say he believes the $2 trillion stimulus deal worked out early Wednesday should offset the impact of shutting down much of the U.S. economy to allow the virus to run its course.

Of his earlier prediction of unemployment temporarily surpassing that of the Great Depression, Bullard stood by his assertion that there will be “this huge spike mostly centered in the second quarter,” but added that ” everyone knows exactly what that is, that’s pandemic relief that’s done on purpose.”

He went on to say that, “If we can get this to work right, everything will snap back to normal once this is over.”

The highest rate of U.S. unemployment during the Great Depression was 24.9% in 1933. On average the unemployment rate throughout that economic crisis remained above 14% for nine years.

In February, before the pandemic crisis took hold, the U.S. unemployment rate stood at 3.5%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

But while the rationale for what Larry Kudlow, the White House’s top economic adviser, has called this “the single largest Main Street assistance program in the history of the United States,” is easily understood, it has also justified the longstanding calls from budget hawks for elected officials to reduce deficits and address the country’s high and rising national debt.

In a letter to her members on Wednesday, Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, noted the organization has been pressing for greater fiscal responsibility in Washington for more than 40 years.

“One key reason we have continued to push for debt reduction in good times is so the country will have the fiscal space to engage in needed borrowing during recessions or national emergencies. The country is now facing both,” she said.

Sadly, she said, Washington entered the current crisis woefully unprepared for it.

 “Instead of spending the last five years addressing the nation’s long-term fiscal imbalance, policymakers enacted a series of tax cuts and spending increases that doubled our budget deficits,” she wrote. “We entered this crisis facing permanent trillion-dollar deficits and with the debt-to-GDP ratio already headed to record levels. As a result of this crisis, deficits could easily exceed $2 trillion this year and next.”

Despite her anger over poor fiscal management in the past, MacGuineas went on in her letter to acknowledge now is not the time to worry about near-term deficits.

“Combating this public health crisis and preventing the economy from falling into a depression will require a tremendous amount of resources – and if ever there were a time to borrow those resources from the future, it is now. Larger deficits are not only an inevitability, but are, unfortunately, a necessity,” she said.

At the same time, MacGuineas warned, this doesn’t mean lawmakers should decide resources are limitless nor that all ideas to spend more money or cut taxes are wise.

“Dollars should be injected into the economy quickly, but they should be spent as efficiently and effectively as possible. That means investing first and foremost in measures to address the public health crisis, targeting money toward those individuals and businesses most affected, it means testing where it doesn’t compromise timeliness, relying on loans and timing changes when it makes sense, and listening to the advice of economists on what policies will best support the economy,” she said.

MacGuineas added, “Now is not the time for politicians to push their pet projects.”

A similar message is being sounded by Michael A. Peterson, CEO of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation.

“The coronavirus outbreak is an unprecedented national emergency, and we need to respond aggressively to address both the public health crisis and the economic risk,” he said.

Like MacGuineas, Peterson called for lawmakers to take “highly targeted” steps to address the crisis and achieve the greatest impact.

“By acting quickly and strategically, we can improve the response and reduce suffering, especially among vulnerable populations,” he said.

But Peterson also went on to say “the country would be in a much better position right now if our debt and deficits weren’t already at such high levels, but our current fiscal outlook should not impede the response to this emergency.

“As we take these steps, we must acknowledge that the next generation should not have to continuously bear the burden of our urgent, current funding needs and lack of concern for the future. In the aftermath of this crisis, we will need to improve America’s strength and preparedness on many levels,” he said.

Federal Budget

Concord Coalition Weighs U.S. Deficit Against Pandemic’s Effect on Health Care Policy
Think Tanks
Concord Coalition Weighs U.S. Deficit Against Pandemic’s Effect on Health Care Policy
November 13, 2020
by Kate Michael

WASHINGTON - With over 10.5 million Americans so far infected with COVID-19, the U.S. health care system’s focus has understandably been on strategies for combating the virus. Yet when the nation is finally able to shift back to handling longer-term health care issues, The Concord Coalition... Read More

New Government Run Health Insurance Option Could Be More Expensive Than Initial Projections, Study Shows
Health
New Government Run Health Insurance Option Could Be More Expensive Than Initial Projections, Study Shows
November 5, 2020
by Sean Trambley

WASHINGTON -- With Congress considering significant health care reforms, including creating a government-run health insurance plan called the public option, a new study shows that it could be significantly more expensive than previously estimated. The study, released by Lanhee J. Chen, Ph.D., Tom Church, and Daniel... Read More

Committee for Responsible Federal Budget Estimates True Cost of Campaign Plans
Political News
Committee for Responsible Federal Budget Estimates True Cost of Campaign Plans
October 12, 2020
by Kate Michael

WASHINGTON -- The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, an independent non-profit organization, released its anticipated report on the estimated costs of both Trump’s and Biden’s campaign plans last week. Not surprisingly, they are very expensive plans.  Both candidates have ambitious proposals and policy priorities if... Read More

DRIVE LESS Act to Reduce Federal Spending on Government Vehicles Has Bipartisan Support
Federal Budget
DRIVE LESS Act to Reduce Federal Spending on Government Vehicles Has Bipartisan Support
October 9, 2020
by Sean Trambley

WASHINGTON. – U.S. Senators Jeanne Shaheen, D-N.H., James Lankford, R-Okla., and Angus King, I-Maine, reintroduced their bipartisan legislation to save taxpayer dollars by reducing the federal funding available for the acquisition and leasing of new federal vehicles. The Domestic Reduction In Vehicle Expenditure and Lowering Emissions... Read More

Senate Votes to Advance Stopgap Spending Bill
Congress
Senate Votes to Advance Stopgap Spending Bill
September 29, 2020
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - The Senate voted to advance a stopgap spending bill Tuesday night, the penultimate step to avoiding a government shutdown at midnight Wednesday. The vote to limit debate on the measure paves the way for a final vote in the chamber on Wednesday afternoon. The... Read More

CBO Long Term Outlook Report ‘Doesn’t Look Good’
Federal Budget
CBO Long Term Outlook Report ‘Doesn’t Look Good’
September 28, 2020
by Kate Michael

WASHINGTON — The Congressional Budget Office recently released two new outlook reports. These projections are an update of the U.S. deficit, debt, spending, and revenue over the next decade and beyond, given current laws in place. The pair of reports highlight the nation’s unsustainable budget trajectory. ... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top