Lawmakers Contribute to Lawsuit To Block EPA’s Water Quality Rule
WASHINGTON — Members of Congress who handle environmental issues are adding their voices to a federal court case that threatens to roll back protections of the 1972 Clean Water Act.
They are siding with the plaintiffs in a lawsuit that opposes the Trump administration’s Navigable Waters Protection Rule, which they call the Dirty Water Rule.
It restricts clean water protections to a smaller area than previous interpretations of the Clean Water Act.
The Trump rule does not protect 60% of stream miles in the lower 48 states that flow less than year-round, according to members of Congress protesting the revised rule. The previous interpretation used by the Environmental Protection Agency protected more of the waterways that only flow for part of the year, also known as intermittent waterways.
The members of Congress filed an amicus brief in the case pending in Massachusetts. They say the Navigable Waters Protection Rule ignores science and undermines the ability of states to protect their own water quality.
“In 1972, Congress enacted the Clean Water Act, a landmark statute with the core objective of cleaning up the nation’s waters,” says the amicus brief signed by 74 members of Congress. “The (Navigable Waters Protection Rule) turns this statutory scheme on its head.”
Amicus briefs are legal filings in lawsuits by someone who is not a party to a case but who seeks to assist a court by offering information, expertise or insight that might be overlooked otherwise. The briefs can play important roles in the outcome of cases.
The amicus brief filed December 16 is in the case of Conservation Law Foundation v. Environmental Protection Agency, which is pending in U.S. District Court in Boston. The Conservation Law Foundation is an environmental advocacy organization.
The members of Congress said in their brief that by asserting a federal rule that overrides any local control, the Trump administration is nearly ensuring the result will be dirtier drinking water for about a third of Americans.
It would lead to “the destruction of rivers, streams, lakes and wetlands throughout the nation,” says a statement from the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee chairman, Peter DeFazio, D-Ore.
The Environmental Protection Agency announced the Navigable Waters Protection Rule in April as a means of clarifying its definition of “waters of the United States” under the Clean Water Act.
“For the first time, the agencies have streamlined the definition so that it includes four simple categories of jurisdictional waters, provides clear exclusions for many water features that traditionally have not been regulated and defines terms in the regulatory text that have never been defined before,” the EPA said in a statement in April.
Disputes continue over the Environmental Protection Agency’s exclusion of some “groundwater” and waterways with “ephemeral features” that flow only after rainfall.
Environmentalists say the new definitions exclude streams that are important tributaries to major rivers as well as wetlands that are breeding grounds for several bird species.
“Where Congress called for science-based decision-making, the (Navigable Waters Protection Rule) largely ignores the science of clean water,” the congressional amicus brief says. “And where Congress called for a collaborative, comprehensive, and mandatory federal and state cleanup of the nation’s waters, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps)—the agencies primarily responsible for implementing the Clean Water Act—have tried to decrease protections from water pollution, all based on fallacious notions about Clean Water Act federalism.”
A Supreme Court ruling this year on similar questions indicates the Conservation Law Foundation stands a good chance of winning its lawsuit.
The Supreme Court said in County of Maui v. Hawaii Wildlife Fund that the Clean Water Act can be used to stop polluters from dumping waste into streams, rivers, and coastal waters without a permit, even if the pollution reaches those waters through unregulated groundwater.
“The Trump Administration attempted to open a serious loophole in the Clean Water Act and was roundly rejected,” said Heather Govern, the Conservation Law Foundation’s director of clean air and water.
Other support for the Conservation Law Foundation’s position comes from President-elect Joe Biden, who announced his environmental team last week. They include Interior Department and Environmental Protection Agency leaders with strong records for environmental activism.
Biden said one of his first actions as president would be to rejoin the Paris Agreement on climate change that President Donald Trump decided to quit. He also pledged a more active water cleanup program.
In The News
This week, the Environmental Protection Agency released a new roadmap to accelerate efforts to protect Americans from per- and polyfluoroalkyl... Read More
This week, the Environmental Protection Agency released a new roadmap to accelerate efforts to protect Americans from per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, a class of toxic chemicals found in food packaging and other common commercial products that can cause severe health problems. "We are exploring ways for... Read More
LONDON (AP) — The world needs to cut by more than half its production of coal, oil and gas in... Read More
LONDON (AP) — The world needs to cut by more than half its production of coal, oil and gas in the coming decade to maintain a chance of keeping global warming from reaching dangerous levels, according to a U.N.-backed study released Wednesday. The report published by... Read More
Scott Breneman told a congressional subcommittee Monday about how his fishing business was upended by the Orange County oil spill... Read More
Scott Breneman told a congressional subcommittee Monday about how his fishing business was upended by the Orange County oil spill discovered off California’s coast on October 1. After a day of fishing 90 miles off the coast, “We were coming in the harbor and I detected... Read More
This article is by Prachi Patel and was originally published by Anthropocene magazine. The world was already drowning in plastic when the Covid-19... Read More
This article is by Prachi Patel and was originally published by Anthropocene magazine. The world was already drowning in plastic when the Covid-19 pandemic hit. The use of protective equipment and surge in takeout and home delivery more than doubled the world’s plastic waste in 2020 over the previous... Read More
HUNTINGTON BEACH, Calif. (AP) — A Southern California beach that was closed more than a week ago because of a... Read More
HUNTINGTON BEACH, Calif. (AP) — A Southern California beach that was closed more than a week ago because of a leak of crude oil from an undersea pipeline reopened on Monday, far sooner than many expected, Huntington Beach's city and state beaches reopened after officials said... Read More
WASHINGTON -- More than 20 federal agencies released their plans Thursday to adapt to climate change in response to an... Read More
WASHINGTON -- More than 20 federal agencies released their plans Thursday to adapt to climate change in response to an order from President Joe Biden. The plans explain how they will maintain the continuity of government service despite rising temperatures that will strain their personnel, buildings... Read More