Run-It-Hot Wins Argument Over How to Get Americans Back to Work

Run-It-Hot Wins Argument Over How to Get Americans Back to Work
Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden and vice presidential nominee Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) address the nation at the Chase Center in Wilmington, Delaware, on Friday, Nov. 6, 2020. The winner of the 2020 presidential election has yet to be declared, as vote counting continues in the key states of Pennsylvania, Georgia, Nevada, Arizona, and North Carolina. (Drew Angerer/Getty Images/TNS)

Behind President-elect Joe Biden’s plans to drive the U.S. back to full employment after the coronavirus slump lies a long-lost idea: The unemployed need jobs, not skills. That “run it hot” recipe for recovery is back in favor among policymakers — including, crucially, at the Federal Reserve. The argument is that the government should juice the economy by any means necessary so demand is strong enough to pull people into work.

It contrasts with the “skills gap” thesis that prevailed after recent recessions. The view then was that large numbers of Americans who’d been thrown out of work wouldn’t be reemployable unless they took it upon themselves to develop new skills.

How far Biden can push the approach, which implies more government spending on top of this year’s $3 trillion pandemic rescue, may hinge on January’s runoff elections in Georgia. They’ll determine whether his Democratic Party wins control of the Senate or faces a Republican majority that can veto his plans, from further virus measures to investments in clean energy and child care. Those measures are crucial to the incoming administration’s roadmap for closing the jobs gap. About 10 million fewer Americans are employed now than at the start of the year.

“If we don’t have enough jobs for workers, it doesn’t matter how many skills they have. They are going to be underemployed,” said Jared Bernstein, a Biden adviser who previously served as his chief economist.

“Historically, skill arguments have been used to avoid invoking government or Federal Reserve interventions,” Bernstein said in an October interview. “Basically: ‘It’s not the economy’s fault, it’s their fault.’ And time and again, that’s been proved to be wrong.”

This time around, the Fed under Chair Jerome Powell is promising to let unemployment fall much further than in the past before starting to raise interest rates, effectively acknowledging that it got the issue wrong after the 2008 crash.

That episode spurred a debate over whether the jobless would be able to find work again without retraining. The fear was that long spells of unemployment owing to the depth of the downturn would erode skills, or that industries of the future would require a different set of them.

Economists often call that “structural unemployment.” Fed officials concluded that it had risen, which meant inflation could become a risk even while jobless rates were relatively high. That’s one reason they began raising borrowing costs in 2015, before employment had returned to pre-recession levels.

By framing the problem of unemployment in terms of skills, the U.S. central bank was reprising a familiar role.

In 1961, in the wake of a recession that had pushed unemployment to 7%, newly elected President John F. Kennedy’s advisers were pushing for a tax cut to boost the economy. But the Fed chairman, William McChesney Martin Jr., was worried about pressure on the U.S. dollar, which he attributed to low interest rates and budget deficits.

Martin warned Congress that rising unemployment was a “structural” phenomenon, and that running a deficit to push it down could “create serious new problems of inflationary character.” He pointed to workers who’d lost their jobs in the past two recessions, from coal miners in West Virginia to steelworkers in the Midwest, arguing that what they needed instead were things such as “more training and retraining to develop skills needed in expanding industries.”

That idea has anchored debates about how to balance unemployment and inflation ever since. It stakes out a minimal role for government spending in keeping the workforce fully employed, and puts the onus on individuals to tailor themselves to the private sector’s needs.

But over the last five years since the Fed began raising rates, the skills gap argument has largely fallen flat. The pool of jobless workers kept shrinking, as more and more people — even the long-term unemployed who had joined the disability rolls — began returning to work. Inflation remained low.

“Firms really started thinking creatively about how to break down whatever barriers there were to get the talent they needed,” Philadelphia Fed President Patrick Harker said in an October interview.

That experience had a big impact at the Fed. In August it announced a new strategy: instead of preemptive rate hikes based on estimates of what constitutes full employment, it will wait until inflation rises.

Fed officials are “trying to do what we can to create the conditions for the economy to get back to that tight labor market that was causing firms to start to think differently,” Harker said.

The Philadelphia Fed chief is still worried about structural shifts in the economy rendering some jobs obsolete, and sees a need for retraining. His bank has partnered with Comcast Corp. — a large area employer — and the city’s workforce development board to help place workers in new positions that can make use of their experience.

But Fed officials have acknowledged that their own monetary tools are limited, and that fiscal policy has more power to boost the labor market. Unlike in 1961, they are urging lawmakers to keep spending, and unlike in the aftermath of 2008, they aren’t lowering the bar for what constitutes full employment.

The virus measures passed by Congress under President Donald Trump, including expanded unemployment benefits, have already achieved something novel: They’ve propped up household income even as millions lost their jobs.

That’s helped lay the groundwork for a swift rebound in employment on the other side of the pandemic, according to Cecilia Rouse, who served on President Barack Obama’s Council of Economic Advisers.

“We’re a largely consumption-based economy, so when I buy something, I’m creating a job for somebody else,” said Rouse, now dean of Princeton University’s School of Public and International Affairs. “I still think there’s a lot of room there for spending and economic assistance being part of the economic support and actually creating jobs.”

The question is: how much more of it will Congress permit? Most pandemic measures have already expired or are about to. Lawmakers have been deadlocked over renewing them. Biden’s longer-term ambitions, such as a $2 trillion clean-energy program, risk a similar fate in a skeptical Senate.

Bernstein said he was tasked by Biden with crunching some numbers on the energy plan, and was surprised to find it would create a wide range of different jobs across the labor-market spectrum: “blue collar, pink collar, you name it.”

“I very much hope that we have the opportunity to make those investments,” he said.

___

(c)2020 Bloomberg News

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC

A+
a-
  • Economics
  • Joe Biden
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Employment

    Making Healthy Snacks a Habit When Afternoon Energy Slumps Strike at Work

    NEW YORK (AP) — When Claire Paré was a classroom teacher, working in a setting where every minute, down to... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — When Claire Paré was a classroom teacher, working in a setting where every minute, down to the bathroom breaks, was scheduled, she brought granola bars, fruit and protein shakes to school so she’d be prepared when hunger hits. Then she transitioned to a job... Read More

    July 8, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Supreme Court Lifts Stay on Trump Effort to Slash Federal Workforce

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday lifted a lower court’s order that had prevented the Trump administration from moving... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday lifted a lower court’s order that had prevented the Trump administration from moving forward with planned mass layoffs and the dismantling of a number of federal agencies. In its unsigned ruling, the court said an executive order signed by... Read More

    US Employers Added 147,000 Jobs Last Month Despite Uncertainty Over Economic Policy

    (AP) — U.S. employers added 147,000 jobs in June as the American labor market continues to show surprising resilience despite... Read More

    (AP) — U.S. employers added 147,000 jobs in June as the American labor market continues to show surprising resilience despite uncertainty over President Donald Trump’s economic policies. The unemployment rate ticked down 4.1% from 4.2% in May, the Labor Department said Thursday. Hiring rose modestly from... Read More

    How to Manage ADHD at Work and Turn It Into a Strength

    NEW YORK (AP) — Jeremy Didier had taken her son to a psychologist for a possible ADHD evaluation when she spotted an... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — Jeremy Didier had taken her son to a psychologist for a possible ADHD evaluation when she spotted an article about women with the condition. As she read it in the waiting room, she thought to herself: They're describing me. “Lots of risk-taking, lots of... Read More

    Fewer Americans Sought Unemployment Benefits Last Week as Layoffs Remain Low

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The number of Americans applying for unemployment benefits fell last week, the Labor Department said Thursday, a sign... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The number of Americans applying for unemployment benefits fell last week, the Labor Department said Thursday, a sign that companies aren’t cutting many jobs. Jobless claims for the week ended June 21 dropped 10,000 to 236,000, a historically-low level. The four-week average of claims,... Read More

    Wall Street Gains Ground Following a Solid Jobs Report

    NEW YORK (AP) — Stocks rose on Wall Street Friday following a better-than-expected report on the U.S. job market. The... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — Stocks rose on Wall Street Friday following a better-than-expected report on the U.S. job market. The S&P 500 index rose 1.2% in morning trading. The benchmark index remains on track to notch a second consecutive winning week. The Dow Jones Industrial Average... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top