House Seeks More Job Protections for Nursing Mothers and Older Applicants

September 28, 2021 by Tom Ramstack
House Seeks More Job Protections for Nursing Mothers and Older Applicants
House Rules Committee Chairman Jim McGovern, D-Mass., right, leads a partially-virtual hearing. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)

WASHINGTON — A congressional panel on Monday considered whether changes are needed to two proposals for expanding workplace rights of nursing mothers and older job applicants before submitting them to final votes by lawmakers.

The holdup on the bills is confusion about whether they would protect workers or shut them out of jobs they would otherwise be able to fill.

In both cases, nursing mothers and older workers would get greater rights to sue employers who discriminate against them.

Some Republicans asked whether anyone would hire them if the employers knew there was a bigger risk of getting hauled into court or fined for job discrimination.


“There’s a lot of bipartisan agreement on these bills,” said Rep. James McGovern, D-Mass., chairman of the House Rules Committee.

However, Rep. Tom Cole, R-Okla., disagreed, saying the Protect Older Job Applicants Act seeks to resolve a problem that isn’t much of a problem at all.  

“While this sounds worthwhile, it is ultimately misguided and unnecessary,” Cole said.

The bill would allow older job applicants to sue employers that engage in a pattern of hiring practices that has a “disparate impact” on them.

Disparate impact is sometimes called “unintentional discrimination.” It results from policies, practices or rules that appear to be neutral but disproportionately impact a protected group.

In the case of the Protect Older Job Applicants Act, the bill would prevent practices such as being passed over for training or promotions offered to younger workers likely to stay in their jobs longer.


The bill would amend the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, which protects employees at least 40 years old from age-related discrimination in hiring, promotion, discharge, compensation or conditions of employment.

If the bill passes in Congress, it would represent a big change for court decisions on “disparate impact” age discrimination. 

In the 2015 case of Villareal v R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. and the 2018 case of Kleber v. CareFusion Corp., older job applicants argued they were subjected to disparate impact discrimination because of their ages. Both cases were appealed to U.S. Courts of Appeals, where the plaintiffs lost their lawsuits.

Cole and other Republicans also raised objections about the PUMP for Nursing Mothers Act.

It would require employers to provide employees who are nursing mothers with a reasonable break time each day to either nurse their children or pump breast milk. Employers also would need to offer the women private places, other than bathrooms, to nurse their children or pump breast milk.

“It would impose the greatest cost on small businesses, those least able to afford them,” Cole said.

He also called it unrealistic for many kinds of jobs, such as flight attendants who could not bring their children on board aircraft and could not be given a private place to pump breast milk.

Rep. Tim Walberg, R-Mich., said the greatest beneficiaries of the bills would be trial lawyers who are hired by job applicants or employees with complaints.

“The bill provides a breeding ground for trial lawyers to claim discrimination,” Walberg said.


Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., said Republicans are overlooking how many workers could benefit from the PUMP for Nursing Mothers Act.

He said it would expand protections for about nine million workers. He also said it would help them balance work against their own and their children’s health.

A+
a-
  • Employment
  • House
  • House Rules Committee
  • James McGovern
  • job protections
  • nursing mothers
  • older applicants
  • Tom Cole
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Employment

    Federal Government's $1 Billion Effort to Recruit Next Generation of Doctors at Risk

    SALISBURY, Md. (AP) — Thousands of women living in rural, eastern Maryland have few options when they're looking for someone... Read More

    SALISBURY, Md. (AP) — Thousands of women living in rural, eastern Maryland have few options when they're looking for someone to deliver their babies. The local hospital doesn't have an obstetrics doctor on staff so most women in this region, flanked by sprawling farm fields and... Read More

    Hollywood Writers, Slamming 'Gig Economy,' to Go on Strike

    NEW YORK (AP) — Television and movie writers declared late Monday they will launch a strike for the first time... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — Television and movie writers declared late Monday they will launch a strike for the first time in 15 years, as Hollywood girded for a walkout with potentially widespread ramifications in a fight over fair pay in the streaming era. The Writers Guild... Read More

    April 25, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Most Still Skittish About Discussing Mental Health at Work

    AUSTIN, Texas — Despite the fact over half of all Americans have taken a “mental health day” off from work,... Read More

    AUSTIN, Texas — Despite the fact over half of all Americans have taken a “mental health day” off from work, most say they don’t admit it and are concerned their employers don’t do enough to support their mental well-being, according to a new survey from JobSage.... Read More

    Fox News Ousts Tucker Carlson, Its Most Popular Host

    NEW YORK (AP) — Fox News on Monday ousted prime-time host Tucker Carlson, whose stew of grievances and political theories about Russia... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — Fox News on Monday ousted prime-time host Tucker Carlson, whose stew of grievances and political theories about Russia and the Jan. 6 insurrection had grown to define the network in recent years and make him an influential force in GOP politics. Fox said that the network... Read More

    March 28, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Child Labor Violations Receive Heightened Scrutiny

    WASHINGTON — With exploitation on the rise and Republican lawmakers in some states rolling back protections, the Biden administration is... Read More

    WASHINGTON — With exploitation on the rise and Republican lawmakers in some states rolling back protections, the Biden administration is stepping up its efforts to combat child labor violations. Labor Department officials say there has been a dramatic increase in the number of children employed in... Read More

    Lawsuit: Slurs, Coercion at BBQ Chain With Racist History

    COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A South Carolina barbecue chain known for its pro-segregation stance in a landmark 1960s case and... Read More

    COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A South Carolina barbecue chain known for its pro-segregation stance in a landmark 1960s case and its embrace of the Confederate flag in 2000 is facing allegations of racism and sexual harassment by the fired general manager of one of its restaurants.... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top