Pa. Governor’s Redistricting Commission Calls for Mapmaking Makeover

August 30, 2019by Jonathan Lai

PHILADELPHIA — Exposing anew the deep divides over how Pennsylvania’s political maps are drawn, a state commission formed by Gov. Tom Wolf released a report Thursday calling for overhauling the mapmaking process — and was immediately met with pushback from Republican lawmakers.

The recommendations by the Redistricting Reform Commission included forming an 11-member bipartisan commission that would submit three maps to lawmakers to choose from; setting specific nonpartisan criteria for how the lines should be drawn; and requiring all data be made public. The members were appointed by Wolf last year after the state Supreme Court overturned Pennsylvania’s congressional map and sparked a bitter political and legal fight.

“Now is the time for a fundamental reexamination of Pennsylvania’s process for drawing political maps,” the report reads.

Michael Li, a redistricting expert at the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University, called it “a solid proposal” but warned that the devil is in the details. There are tweaks he would make to the system, he said, but overall the report lays out a series of good principles.

“They hit all the right points. … If they came up with something that was within this framework, I think Pennsylvania would be much better off than the system they have right now,” he said. “If what you try to guard against is aggressive gerrymandering, this goes a long way toward that.”

But recent attempts at reforming the state’s redistricting processes have died in polarized Harrisburg. And Republican lawmakers, who control both chambers of the state legislature, refused to participate as soon as the commission was announced, rejecting it as a Democratic governor’s attempt to take their power to draw political maps as they see fit.

Republicans on Thursday continued to show no interest in the commission.

“The power to draw district lines for state House and Senate seats is strictly delegated to the legislature in our state constitution,” Mike Straub, spokesperson for the House Republicans, said in a statement. “We will take into consideration proposals to modernize the current process, but an 11-member panel will never be as representative of the Commonwealth as 253 legislators and the Governor is, nor will an 11-member panel allow for as much transparency and opportunity for input as the amendment process currently provides.”

Senate Republicans issued a statement criticizing Wolf’s commission as aimed at generating media coverage instead of working with the legislature.

“The governor’s media-driven effort has only served as a distraction to the previous work and ongoing efforts by the legislature to examine the redistricting process in Pennsylvania,” Jennifer Kocher, spokesperson for the Senate Republicans, said in the statement.

The political reality of a state as divided as Pennsylvania was an important consideration in the report’s conclusions, said David Thornburgh, the head of Philadelphia-based good-government group of Committee of Seventy and chair of the commission.

“(W)e felt the Commission’s recommendations should be tempered by the realities of Pennsylvania’s structure of governance and political process,” the report reads, noting that Pennsylvania has no citizen initiative process, so any changes must first go through the General Assembly and then the governor.

Wolf Spokesperson J.J. Abbott said the governor “continues to support transitioning redistricting to a citizens commission and he appreciates the suggestions from the commission’s report.”

The commission proposes an entire model because the changes are meant to fit together for wholesale reform.

Republican and Democratic leaders would each appoint five voting members, with neither side allowed to point more than two members of the same party.

That’s meant to force Republicans to nominate Democrats and vice versa, along with third-party or independent members. That alone might help bring moderation, Thornburgh said — “the red team will look for the faintest blue and the blue team will look for the faintest red” — though rules such as these can be gamed.

Members would have to be registered with the same political party for five years, preventing party-switching to cheat the system, and anyone who has held public office, worked on an elected official’s staff, or been registered as a lobbyist would be ineligible to serve on the redistricting commission.

The governor’s appointee would not be a voting member.

After holding public meetings, the commission would select from public submissions and also draw its own maps that would aim for compactness. Where possible, political districts should follow town and county lines, keeping communities together.

It also floated the idea of a state standard that would go beyond federal protections for the voting power of communities of racial minorities, however it did not make a specific proposal.

The commission would be forbidden from considering individuals’ addresses, registered voters’ political affiliation, and previous election results (except if required by federal law).

All data used or considered by the mapmakers would be made public before being used, and each map would include a short explanation of its values or goals and quantitative measures of its compactness, contiguity, and town and county splits.

The 10 voting members would first pick five maps, then narrow the list to three. Seven votes would be required to approve each map, requiring some degree of bipartisan consensus. Those three maps would be sent to lawmakers to pick from.

At this point, the lawmakers could be the entire General Assembly, a subset of it, or some other group appointed by legislators. If the entire legislature is picking the map, a super majority vote would be required.

Lawmakers would only be allowed to pick a map, not alter it. In the event of a stalemate, the power returns to the 11-member commission to pick from among the three maps.


©2019 The Philadelphia Inquirer

Visit The Philadelphia Inquirer at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

In The News




Despite Business Warnings, GOP Moves Ahead With Voting Bills
In The States
Despite Business Warnings, GOP Moves Ahead With Voting Bills

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — Republican lawmakers around the country are pressing ahead with efforts to tighten voting laws, despite growing warnings from business leaders that the measures could harm democracy and the economic climate. More than 50 companies and business organizations, including some in Texas, released... Read More

Texas 6th District House Special Election Headed to Runoff
Texas 6th District House Special Election Headed to Runoff
April 30, 2021
by Dan McCue

 Susan Wright, who is seeking the seat held since 2019 by her late husband, Republican Rep. Ron Wright, secured one of two slots in an as yet unscheduled runoff election. She was one of 23 candidates vying to replace her husband, who died in February after a... Read More

Appeals Court Upholds 2014 FEC Decision
Appeals Court Upholds 2014 FEC Decision
April 21, 2021
by TWN Staff

WASHINGTON - The Federal Election Commission cannot be second-guessed on a 2014 decision on an administrative complaint because it relied in part on "prosecutorial discretion" in rendering that decision, a federal appeals court has ruled. The holding by the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the... Read More

GOP White House Hopefuls Move Forward as Trump Considers Run
Political News
GOP White House Hopefuls Move Forward as Trump Considers Run

WASHINGTON (AP) — Less than three months after former President Donald Trump left the White House, the race to succeed him atop the Republican Party is already beginning. Trump's former secretary of state, Mike Pompeo, has launched an aggressive schedule, visiting states that will play a... Read More

Warren Buffett Joins Effort by Corporate America to Condemn Voting Restrictions
Political News
Warren Buffett Joins Effort by Corporate America to Condemn Voting Restrictions
April 18, 2021
by Dan McCue

Billionaire investor Warren Buffett joined hundreds of other capitalists and corporate titans in signing an open letter condeming “discrimnatory” legislation designed to curtail voting rights. The letter, which appeared under the headline “We Stand for Democracy,” appeared as a double-page, centerfold advertisement in Thursday’s editions of... Read More

'Hillbilly' to Capitol Hill? Author Eyes Senate Bid in Ohio
Political News
'Hillbilly' to Capitol Hill? Author Eyes Senate Bid in Ohio

MIDDLETOWN, Ohio (AP) — Rodney Muterspaw figures J.D. Vance has already shown he's got what it takes to be a U.S. senator.  Vance, the "Hillbilly Elegy" author and a fellow Middletown native, broke out of poverty and family chaos and never forgot his Appalachian roots on... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top