Judges Toss Ohio’s Congressional Map, Declaring It Unconstitutional
A three-judge panel of federal judges tossed Ohio’s congressional map Friday, holding that it was a partisan gerrymander favoring Republicans and ordering that the districts be redrawn for the 2020 elections.
The unanimous decision said that as drawn the map violates voters’ rights to democratically select the representative of their choice. It also prohibits the state from holding any other election relying on the current map and gives the state until June 20 to propose an alternative map.
“We are convinced by the evidence that this partisan gerrymander was intentional and effective and that no legitimate justification accounts for its extremity,” the judges said. “The 2012 map dilutes the votes of Democratic voters by packing and cracking them into districts that are so skewed toward one party that the electoral outcome is predetermined.”
In the underlying lawsuit that led to the ruling, Democratic voters, the A. Philip Randolph Institute and other voters’ rights groups claimed the redrawing of the map after the 2010 Census resulted in a permanent 12-4 Republican advantage in the Ohio delegation.
During a recent hearing of the case, a representative of the institute testified that Democratic voters were unfairly placed in some districts and split between others during the map-making process, diluting the party’s political power.
In response, the Republican lawmaker defendants said the map had bipartisan support and that the case is irrelevant because a new map will be drawn immediately after the upcoming 2020 Census.
Attorneys for Republicans said the map resulted from compromise with Democrats and noted that each party lost one seat after reapportionment reduced Ohio’s U.S. House delegation because of population shifts in the 2010 Census.
The delegation went from 13-5 Republican to 12-4, they said.
Ohio Democrat and presidential candidate, Representative Tim Ryan,called Friday’s ruling “a huge victory for the State of Ohio and our democracy.”
“Partisan gerrymandering has become the unfortunate status quo in the United States, and it’s about time we end this undemocratic practice,” Ryan said. “These unfair maps perpetuate a cycle where districts are drawn to benefit the people in power. Ohio voters should choose their representatives, not the other way around. We must still remain vigilant and ensure that state elected officials draw a truly bipartisan, fair map. Fair maps mean fair elections.”
The U.S. Supreme Court is already considering challenges to congressional maps in North Carolina, drawn by Republicans, and Maryland, drawn by Democrats, that plaintiffs claim were partisan gerrymanders.
The Justices are expected to rule on those cases next month.
Earlier this month, a three-judge panel in Michigan ruled that state’s congressional and legislative maps are unconstitutionally gerrymandered, and ordered the state legislature to redraw some districts for 2020.
The judges in that case wrote that GOP mapmakers in 2011 drew maps with the goal of ensuring “durable majorities” for Republicans.
Appeals of both the Ohio and the Michigan ruling are expected.
In The News
Republicans will gather at 39 sites around Virginia Saturday to choose a slate of statewide candidates, with no choice, of course, being more important than that of governor. In a year in which the battle for the future of the GOP has mostly been waged in... Read More
In 2020, election officials tried to make voting easier and safer amid a global pandemic. Next time, they might get fined or face criminal charges. Republicans are creating a new slate of punishments for the county officials who run elections, arguing they overstepped their authority when... Read More
AUSTIN, Texas — Following hours of debate over amendments proposed by Democratic lawmakers, the Texas House of Representatives approved new restrictions to state election rules early Friday morning. After Democrats proposed more than 130 amendments to the legislation, the lawmakers eventually agreed to revise the bill... Read More
Florida was hit with multiple civil rights lawsuits Thursday minutes after Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a bill to limit mail-in voting and to require more complete voter identification. The NAACP, the League of Women Voters and others said in their lawsuits in federal court that the... Read More
WASHINGTON - The FEC has formally dropped a case looking into whether former President Donald Trump violated election law when he directed his personal lawyer to pay women, including a pornographic film actress, to buy their silence about alleged affairs with candidate, shortly before the 2016... Read More
PHOENIX (AP) — The U.S. Department of Justice expressed concern Wednesday about ballot security and potential voter intimidation arising from the Republican-controlled Arizona Senate's unprecedented private recount of the 2020 presidential election results in Maricopa County. In a letter to GOP Senate President Karen Fann, the... Read More