Filing a Complaint With FEC Commission the Start of A Long and Winding Process

August 7, 2020 by Dan McCue
Filing a Complaint With FEC Commission the Start of A Long and Winding Process
Federal Election Commission building, in Washington, D.C.

WASHINGTON – Every month an email from the Federal Election Commission arrives in the inbox with a certain insouciant inevitability.

“Pending advisory opinion requests,” it says.

“That’s right,” you say to yourself. “They’re back to not having a quorum on the commission board.”

It’s never a long list, and in no way is it a commentary on how hard staff and staff attorneys at the FEC continue to work day in and day out.

Nevertheless, the email always has a whiff of the slow-grinding gears of government about it.

“Contribution limit, primary date, and salary eligibility for independent presidential candidates,” one entry says. “Received July 15, 2020.”

Below that line the entry reads, “Extension of time granted on July 21, 2020 for 20 days following the date that the commission holds its first open meeting at which a quorum of at least four commissioners is present.”

Leaving aside the obvious bureacrat-ese of the language, it gives one pause.

“Wasn’t there a story this week about a complaint filed with FEC against the Trump re-election campaign?”

“What will the lack of a quorum on the board mean to the case being resolved before the November election?”

Curious, we first reached out to the FEC, which confirmed via email that “without a working quorum of at least four commissioners, the agency is unable to move forward on newly filed complaints.”

We then turned to the plaintiff, the nonpartisan Campaign Legal Center, which has alleged the Trump re-election campaign unlawfully laundered roughly $170 million dollars through a straw vendor.

The campaign has denied the accusation.

“AMMC is a campaign vendor responsible for arranging and executing media buys and related services at fair market value,” said Tim Murtaugh, Trump 2020 communications director.

“AMMC does not earn any commissions or fees. It builds efficiencies and saves the campaign money by providing these in-house services that otherwise would be done by outside vendors. The campaign reports all payments to AMMC as required by the FEC. The campaign complies with all campaign finance laws and FEC regulations,” Murtaugh said.

“But what about the day of reckoning before the FEC board?” we asked once we had Brendan Fischer, CLC’s director of federal reform, on the phone.

“How do you feel about your complaint likely not getting anywhere until after the election?”

“I don’t know that it’s particularly significant,” Fischer said. “Even if the FEC had a full set of commissioners, we would not expect this to get resolved for probably two or three years.”

“That’s fairly common with these more complex complaints,” he said. “That said, the initial stages of the complaint process are going to move forward, regardless of whether the board has a quorum.”

In the case of a complaint like the one filed against the Trump campaign, staff attorneys will begin to review the accusations, and share the complaint with the campaign so that its lawyers can issue a written response.

Once the FEC attorneys complete their preliminary review and investigation — a process that typically takes anywhere from six to eight months — they’ll draft a report making a recommendation to the full commission on whether they believe the relevant election law has been violated.

“It’s at that point that we need the commission to have a quorum,” Fischer said. “Then the commission can vote on the recommendation and authorize a decision — and that’s effectively the beginning of the process to achieve a negotiated settlement.”

Fischer said while no one can predict when the commission quorum will be restored, “it’s fairly possible it will be restored sometime in 2021.”

Assuming all this occurs in the timeline described, what could the repercussions for the Trump campaign be in 2023?

“Well, the first thing, if the staff attorneys and the commission agree a violation has occurred, in the imposition of civil penalties, most commonly a fine,” Fischer said.

“Along with that there would likely be an agreement stipulated that the campaign not engage in similar activity in the future,” he added.

The question then was, “Does filing a complaint under the current circumstances pay?”

If Trump were to win a second term, he’d be on the verge of leaving office before the campaign faced the possibility of a sanction.

If he’s not re-elected, the 2020 campaign will be a distant memory.

“This filing — and many filings — are really about preventing a campaign from setting the precedent that some behavior they’ve engaged in is permissible,” Fischer said.

“That’s because very often what happens in this realm is that one candidate or political committee will pioneer a particular activity that pushes the legal envelope of what’s permissible in an election,” he said. “Once that happens, and if it goes unchallenged, other candidates and committees will begin to replicate that same activity.”

“Along with that, of course, and particularly in regard to this complaint, we believe it’s the public’s right to know how campaign money is being spent,” Fischer concluded.

A+
a-
  • Campaign Legal Center
  • Federal Elections Commission
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Elections

    Despite the Hype, Campaign Cash Doesn’t Buy Elections

    This misconception has stubbornly dominated American political thinking for decades. Recent electoral contests have delivered the latest in a series... Read More

    This misconception has stubbornly dominated American political thinking for decades. Recent electoral contests have delivered the latest in a series of stunning repudiations of this assumption. From April’s Florida legislative races to a high-profile Wisconsin Supreme Court contest and even the 2024 presidential election, we saw... Read More

    Federal Judge Will Hear Arguments as Groups Try to Block Trump's EO on Elections

    NEW YORK (AP) — A federal judge on Thursday will hear arguments in three cases from national Democrats and voting rights... Read More

    NEW YORK (AP) — A federal judge on Thursday will hear arguments in three cases from national Democrats and voting rights groups that are challenging President Donald Trump’s recent executive order on elections, which, among other changes, would require proof of citizenship to register to vote in federal elections. The... Read More

    Biden's Top Health Official, Xavier Becerra, Enters Race to Succeed California Gov. Gavin Newsom

    LOS ANGELES (AP) — Former Biden administration Health Secretary Xavier Becerra on Wednesday became the latest Democrat to join the crowded field... Read More

    LOS ANGELES (AP) — Former Biden administration Health Secretary Xavier Becerra on Wednesday became the latest Democrat to join the crowded field seeking to become California’s next governor, a contest that could be dramatically reshaped if former Vice President Kamala Harris becomes a candidate. The Stanford Law School... Read More

    Wisconsin and Florida Elections Provide Early Warning Signs to Trump and Republicans

    A trio of elections on Tuesday provided early warning signs to Republicans and President Donald Trump at the beginning of an ambitious term,... Read More

    A trio of elections on Tuesday provided early warning signs to Republicans and President Donald Trump at the beginning of an ambitious term, as Democrats rallied against his efforts to slash the federal government and the outsize role being played by billionaire Elon Musk. In the marquee race for... Read More

    Democratic Base's Anger Puts Some Party Leaders on Shaky Ground

    PHOENIX (AP) — The Democratic base is angry. Not just at President Donald Trump, Elon Musk and the “Make America Great Again” movement.... Read More

    PHOENIX (AP) — The Democratic base is angry. Not just at President Donald Trump, Elon Musk and the “Make America Great Again” movement. Rank-and-file Democrats are mad at their own leaders and increasingly agitating to replace them. Arizona Democrats pushed out their party chair, and Georgia Democrats are on... Read More

    AP Decision Notes: What to Expect in Pennsylvania's State Legislative Special Elections

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Tuesday’s special elections will fill two vacancies in Pennsylvania’s General Assembly. Democrats are defending a state House seat on... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Tuesday’s special elections will fill two vacancies in Pennsylvania’s General Assembly. Democrats are defending a state House seat on friendly turf with control of the deadlocked chamber on the line, while Republicans look to maintain their comfortable advantage in the state Senate in a reliably... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top