Third Way Says Congress Must Ensure Higher Ed Meets Need of Hard-Working Students

March 30, 2019 by Dan McCue
Princeton University. (Photo by Dan McCue)

The public policy think tank Third Way has thrown its support behind the PROTECT Students Act, a bill introduced this week by Senators Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., and Dick Durbin, D-Ill., that seeks to hold colleges, for-profit schools, and other institutions accountable when they engage in deceptive and fraudulent practices.

Hassan, a member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee, and Durbin, the Democratic Whip, introduced the legislation on March 26.

In doing so they explained they are greatly concerned about dishonest actors in higher education who are enriching themselves with federal taxpayer dollars while leaving tens of thousands of their students with credits or degrees of little value, few job prospects and huge amounts of debt.

At the same time, the senators said, they are greatly concerned with steps Education Secretary Betsy Devos has taken to roll back Obama-era reforms intended to prevent such predatory practices in the first place, and to respond to the repercussions when those practices are uncovered.

They cite the demises of Corinthian Colleges and ITT-Tech, two of the nation’s largest for-profit education chains, which both collapsed after federal regulators alleged they’d engaged in widespread fraud, deceptive marketing and lying to the government.

Despite these profile examples, the senators say DeVos has “consistently putting the interests of fraudulent, for-profit colleges ahead of students.”

According to Senator Durbin, “For-profit colleges enroll just 9 percent of all postsecondary students but account for 34 percent of all federal student loan defaults. Add to that widespread predatory practices and a unique propensity within higher education for massive precipitous collapses, and the for-profit college industry continues to represent a disproportionate risk to students and taxpayers.”

Senator Hassan agreed.

“For our students and veterans to receive the quality education that they deserve, we must ensure that they are protected from predatory practices that too often occur at for-profit colleges and other higher education institutions,” She said.

Among other things, their bill would improve coordination of federal oversight of for-profit colleges among multiple federal agencies and close a loophole in the Higher Education Act that some for-profit colleges have used to exploit Department of Defense and Department of Veterans Affairs’ tuition programs and collect taxpayer dollars they would not otherwise be entitled to.

In endorsing the legislation, Lanae Erickson, senior vice president for Social Policy and Politics for Third Way, a Washington-based public policy think tank, said her organization believes students and taxpayers “deserve a return on their investment in higher education.”

“Too many students who enroll in college never get the degree they seek, leaving them with debt but no degree to show for it,” Erickson said. “And predatory institutions rake in millions in federal student aid dollars and leave students worse off than they were when they enrolled.”

The PROTECT Students Act, she said, “would solidify protections for students and taxpayers, taking a big step in the right direction towards holding institutions and programs accountable for delivering on what they advertise.”

Third Way knows how challenging it can be to earn a college degree. After an exhaustive analysis of federal data published earlier this year, the think tank found that just 57 percent of students who start two- and four-year colleges graduate.

At the same time, Third Way said, students who take out loans to attend college but never finish are three times as likely to default, earn lower incomes throughout their lives, and have higher rates of unemployment.

As a result of these findings, the organization has called for a national effort to raise the college graduation rate to 84 percent, noting similar efforts have increased the high school graduation rates by 15 percent.

Among the key findings of the Third Way study was that in the graduation rate of just one class of students entering two- and four-year schools in the United States was raised to 84 percent, it would result in an increase of over 730,000 two-year degree holders and over 520,000 four-year degree holders.

The ripple effects of that would be an increase in annual wages for 730,000 additional two-year degree holders by an average of $4,849; an increase in annual wages for 520,000 additional four-year degree holders by an average of $19,034; reduce the number of people in poverty by 48,000; and over the course of those students’  lifetimes increase the amount of local, state, and federal tax revenue by more than $90 billion.

With these statistics in mind, Erickson said The PROTECT Students Act “would put in place some sorely needed guardrails to ensure that students aren’t defrauded and taxpayers aren’t left footing the bill when an institution fails to do its job.”

Education

Biden Directs DoED to Pause Federal Student Loan Payments Until September
Education
Biden Directs DoED to Pause Federal Student Loan Payments Until September
January 21, 2021
by Sara Wilkerson

President Joe Biden has directed the Department of Education to extend its pause on federal student loan payments and collections until September 30, 2021.  The directive was part of a series of executive orders that the newly sworn in president signed during his first few days... Read More

Virginia Modifies Guidance for K-12 Reopenings Amid Pandemic
State News
Virginia Modifies Guidance for K-12 Reopenings Amid Pandemic
January 20, 2021
by Sara Wilkerson

Recently, Virginia officials released an updated revision of the state’s interim guidelines for reopening K-12 schools in a letter sent to Virginia educators and public health officials. The move comes one day after the Centers for Disease Control published a new study indicating that K-12 schools... Read More

Senators Collins and Hassan Protect Funding for Nearly 200 Rural, Low-Income School Districts
Education
Senators Collins and Hassan Protect Funding for Nearly 200 Rural, Low-Income School Districts
January 4, 2021
by Sean Trambley

WASHINGTON — Last week, U.S. Sens. Susan Collins, R-Maine, and Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., announced they successfully reversed a Department of Education decision that jeopardized funding for nearly 200 rural, low-income school districts.  A provision they negotiated was included in the year-end government funding bill and signed... Read More

With Education Pick, Biden Adds Public Schools Proponent
Education
With Education Pick, Biden Adds Public Schools Proponent

WASHINGTON — Joe Biden is poised to nominate Miguel Cardona as secretary of the Department of Education. The schools chief in Connecticut pushed to reopen campuses during the coronavirus pandemic and emerged as a consensus choice for the federal post with the backing of teachers unions... Read More

Supreme Court to Decide Whether NCAA Can Refuse Pay for Football and Basketball Stars
Sports
Supreme Court to Decide Whether NCAA Can Refuse Pay for Football and Basketball Stars

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court agreed Wednesday to decide whether major colleges and universities are violating federal antitrust laws by refusing to pay the football and basketball players who bring in hundreds of millions of dollars to their campuses. The National Collegiate Athletic Association and several... Read More

Departing Trump Administration Wants to Weaken Nutrition Rules for School Meals
Political News
Departing Trump Administration Wants to Weaken Nutrition Rules for School Meals

PHILADELPHIA — In their last days in office, Trump administration officials are trying to reduce nutrition requirements for school meals, seeking to undo changes initiated by the Obama administration a decade ago. The U.S. Department of Agriculture says it wants to allow school districts to be... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top