Five States Sue Education Dept. Over CARES Act School Funding

July 13, 2020 by Tom Ramstack
Five States Sue Education Dept. Over CARES Act School Funding

Five states and the District of Columbia filed a lawsuit this week that accuses the U.S. Education Department of shorting schools in low-income areas on their fair share of coronavirus relief funds.

Instead, too much of the money is going to private and wealthy school districts that do not need the money, according to the lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.

Participating states are California, Maine, Michigan, New Mexico and Wisconsin.

They say the Trump administration is misinterpreting part of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) that sets standards for distributing relief funds to schools.

The relevant section of the law specifies how to distribute $30.75 billion for elementary schools, secondary schools, colleges and universities.

The Trump administration uses a formula that distributes the money equally based on the number of students in the schools.

The lawsuit says Congress intended the money to be distributed where the need is greatest, such as to low-income students and their schools.

“The [Education] Department’s interpretation will deprive low-income and at-risk students, their teachers and the public schools that serve them of critical resources to meet students’ educational and social-emotional needs during and after pandemic-related school closures,” the lawsuit says. 

It adds that “the states will also be harmed by the loss of these critical resources at a time of severe crisis.”

When Congress allocated the CARES Act funds in March, it said the money was supposed to be distributed by states to “local educational agencies.”

The states that are suing said that means the money should be considered part of Title I, Part A of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act. The Act provides financial assistance to local educational agencies and schools with high numbers of children from low-income families.

However, an interim final rule from the Education Department directs local educational agencies to “provide equitable services to students and teachers in non-public schools” as well as public schools.

Education Secretary Betsy DeVos gave further explanation of her agency’s intent in a June 25 announcement that said “CARES Act programs are not Title I programs,” which means they are not limited to schools that serve low-income students.

The states’ lawsuit says DeVos is out of step with Congress’ intent.

The Education Department “grafted its own allocation and eligibility rules on Congress’s directive,” the lawsuit says.

State attorneys general who filed the lawsuit directed their own harsh criticism at DeVos.

One of them was Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, who said in a statement, “At a time when Michigan schools are facing an unprecedented crisis, every single child deserves the chance to succeed. But, yet again, Secretary DeVos has decided to tip the scales in favor of private schools, leaving the state’s public school students behind.”

The lawsuit adds to the Education Department woes that put DeVos on the political hot seat this week when she initially threatened to withhold federal funding from schools that do not re-open in-person classes in the fall semester.

On Thursday, two days after making the threat during a Fox News interview, she pulled back amid harsh public criticism from educators, health officials and political leaders.

In a separate interview with Fox News’ Sandra Smith she said, “American investment in education is a promise to our students and families and if schools aren’t going to reopen, we’re not suggesting pulling funding from education, but instead allowing families to take that money and figure out where their kids can get educated if their schools are going to refuse to open.”

A+
a-
  • California
  • CARES Act
  • Education
  • lawsuit
  • Maine
  • Michigan
  • New Mexico
  • private schools
  • school funding
  • Wisconsin
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Education

    June 16, 2025
    by Cara Cervenka
    Education Advocates Urge Senators to Reject the ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’

    WASHINGTON — Advocates from several educational organizations gathered outside the Russell Senate Office Building last week to urge the Senate... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Advocates from several educational organizations gathered outside the Russell Senate Office Building last week to urge the Senate to reject the so-called "big, beautiful bill” they contend will gut public school funding. Standing in the shadow of the Capitol, educators and parents decried the... Read More

    Public Universities Remain America's Best Investment — and They’re More Affordable Than You Think

    “Colleges aren’t turning out the right kind of student[s].” That was the take offered by Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg in a recent... Read More

    “Colleges aren’t turning out the right kind of student[s].” That was the take offered by Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg in a recent podcast appearance, where one of the leading voices in the tech industry echoed an argument we're hearing far too often: college is no longer an investment... Read More

    May 29, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    US Government Plans to ‘Aggressively’ Revoke Visas of Chinese Students

    WASHINGTON – The U.S. government plans to “aggressively” revoke the visas of Chinese students at U.S. universities, Secretary of State... Read More

    WASHINGTON – The U.S. government plans to “aggressively” revoke the visas of Chinese students at U.S. universities, Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced Wednesday. He and U.S. intelligence officials recently told Congress that many Chinese graduate students are the equivalent of spies. Their consulates often assign... Read More

    Harvard Sues Trump Administration Over Ban on Enrolling Foreign Students

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Harvard University is challenging the Trump administration’s decision to bar the Ivy League school from enrolling foreign students,... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Harvard University is challenging the Trump administration’s decision to bar the Ivy League school from enrolling foreign students, calling it unconstitutional retaliation for defying the White House’s political demands. In a lawsuit filed Friday in federal court in Boston, Harvard said the government’s action... Read More

    May 22, 2025
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supreme Court Lets Decision Stand Banning State-Funded Charter School

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that taxpayer money cannot be used to subsidize a religious-oriented charter school in... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that taxpayer money cannot be used to subsidize a religious-oriented charter school in Oklahoma. The split decision allows a lower court ruling to stand that said tax money for religious schools violates the establishment clause of the First Amendment.... Read More

    Poor Guidance From Influential Math Educators Is Impairing Students

    Could it be that the nation’s large fraction of students lacking math proficiency is caused by significant numbers of students not having... Read More

    Could it be that the nation’s large fraction of students lacking math proficiency is caused by significant numbers of students not having their multiplication tables memorized? In a California K-12 district with 15% of students proficient in math, according to state testing, only about 25% of fourth graders were found to have... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top