Loading...

Unintended Consequencs of Sex Trafficking Laws

April 12, 2021 by Victoria Turner
Unintended Consequencs of Sex Trafficking Laws
Danielle Borrelli

The two federal laws governing sex trafficking online have disproportionately harmed more sex workers than saved victims of human trafficking, said Danielle Borrelli, operations coordinator at the California Cybersecurity Institute, today at a Lincoln Network event moderated by Alexiaa Jordan.  

Known and used collectively as SESTA-FOSTA, the Senate and House 2018 law combo has “normalized” speaking about sex work, but increased harm by exposing sex workers to a flurry of more misdemeanors, felonies and has actually put them at risk from harmful clients, Borrelli said. The law has made it harder for sex workers to vet their clientele, as forums and websites were being shut down due to the fear of being found liable. 

“It pushed them back into the more archaic on-the-streets situation…as a bill itself, it’s failed the people it’s trying to serve,” she said as she pointed out that this leads to more rapes, beatings and murder.

It was a sentiment that all three panelists agreed upon. 

They have also blurred the distinction between sex work – prostitution, adult entertainment – and sex trafficking, and this has led to a decrease of legal businesses and behaviors, said Emma  Llansó , director of the free expression project at the Center for Democracy and Technology. The laws have had “chilling effect” on sex workers by diminishing the online resources available to keep them safe.

The majority of cases brought against websites – like the infamous backpage.com that was taken down – were “struck down” under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, she explained, which shields platforms from being liable for third-party content published on their site. 

SESTA-FOSTA, she said, sought to change that, but the debate ignored that Section 230 already provides an exception to existing federal criminal law. She pointed out that this existing legal framework, not SESTA-FOSTA, was used to take backpage.com down. 

“SESTA-FOSTA was almost an answer to a problem that actually had a solution on the table,”  Llansó said. 

The new law also added a federal criminal liability exception to Section 230, said Alexandra Yelderman, visiting assistant professor of law at Notre Dame. If the host is operating the site with the intent to facilitate the criminal activity, she explained, then it is at fault. 

What a lot of these cases really come down to, explained Llanso, was advertisements that are published on the host site. It is almost impossible for these content hosts to go through every single advertisement to ensure they are legal and not promoting criminal behavior. Both Borrelli and Llanso noted that typical mitigation techniques employed by the host – like keyword searches and flagging videos – can only catch a certain amount before the culprits become savvy and change the terms they use themselves. 

In The News

Health

Voting

Cybersecurity

World Economic Forum Warns Cyber Risks Add to Climate Threat

LONDON (AP) — Cybersecurity and space are emerging risks to the global economy, adding to existing challenges posed by climate change and... Read More

LONDON (AP) — Cybersecurity and space are emerging risks to the global economy, adding to existing challenges posed by climate change and the coronavirus pandemic, the World Economic Forum said in a report Tuesday. The Global Risks Report is usually released ahead of the annual elite winter gathering of CEOs and... Read More

Major Outage at Amazon Disrupts Businesses Across the US

A major outage in Amazon's cloud computing network Tuesday severely disrupted services at a wide range of U.S. companies for... Read More

A major outage in Amazon's cloud computing network Tuesday severely disrupted services at a wide range of U.S. companies for more than five hours, the latest sign of just how concentrated the business of keeping the internet running has become. The incident at Amazon Web Services... Read More

November 22, 2021
by Kate Michael
Klobuchar Weighs in on CAP’s New Report on Tech Regulation

WASHINGTON — Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., has been on a crusade for swift and sweeping reform of Big Tech platforms,... Read More

WASHINGTON — Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., has been on a crusade for swift and sweeping reform of Big Tech platforms, introducing a number of bills and even publishing a book titled “Antitrust” that looks at the history of policy toward trusts and monopolies and details how... Read More

November 13, 2021
by Victoria Turner
US Cyber Attack Defenses Assessed at Forum

WASHINGTON — The U.S. is at risk of creating a two-silo cybersecurity strategy impeding its ability to adequately address ever-evolving... Read More

WASHINGTON — The U.S. is at risk of creating a two-silo cybersecurity strategy impeding its ability to adequately address ever-evolving cyber threats from bad actors overseas, a former assistant secretary of defense said Friday. Speaking at an American Enterprise Institute event, Paul Stockton, who is now... Read More

November 9, 2021
by Dan McCue
SolarWinds Sued By Shareholders Over Epic 2020 Data Breach

GEORGETOWN, Del. — Shareholders are suing software provider SolarWinds Corp. in the Delaware Court of Chancery claiming the company directors... Read More

GEORGETOWN, Del. — Shareholders are suing software provider SolarWinds Corp. in the Delaware Court of Chancery claiming the company directors should have known of, and yet did nothing to mitigate, the risk of the massive data breach that took place in 2020. The plaintiffs, led by... Read More

October 26, 2021
by Tom Ramstack
Bigger Government Role Expected to Protect Industry From Hackers

WASHINGTON — Large-scale cyberattacks continued this week in the United States and abroad as computer security experts told a congressional... Read More

WASHINGTON — Large-scale cyberattacks continued this week in the United States and abroad as computer security experts told a congressional panel Tuesday that more government intervention is needed. On Monday, Microsoft announced that Russia-backed hackers were trying to steal information technology to disrupt the global supply... Read More

News From The Well
Exit mobile version