Elon Musk Wins Suit Over Tesla Purchase of Rooftop Solar Company

April 28, 2022 by Dan McCue
Elon Musk Wins Suit Over Tesla Purchase of Rooftop Solar Company
(Photo via Wikimedia Commons)

WILMINGTON, Del. — In a week in which his planned purchase of Twitter is dominating headlines, Elon Musk scored a victory of another sort on Wednesday, prevailing in a shareholder lawsuit over electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla’s purchase of SolarCity, a rooftop solar company.

SolarCity, which was headquartered in Fremont, California, focused on door-to-door sales of leased systems, where customers would pay no upfront costs, but agreed to purchase the power generated by those panels from the company for 20 years. 

This business model helped make SolarCity the largest residential solar installer in the country, but also saddled it with $1.5 billion in debt by early 2016.

This is when Musk came in and said he wanted to buy the company, through Tesla, in an all-cash deal. The proposal immediately inspired skepticism among some of the automaker’s shareholders because SolarCity was founded by Peter and Lyndon Rive, Musk’s cousins, and Musk was the chairman of their board.

Musk, however, argued the companies already had a close operating relationship, pointing out that SolarCity offered free charging to Tesla Roadster owners at its charging stations, and that SolarCity became one of the first installers of the Tesla Powerwall home energy storage battery.

Still, Tesla’s stock plunged more than 10% on the day the proposed $2.6 billion purchase was announced, which led to the shareholder lawsuit in Delaware’s Chancery Court.

In the lawsuit, Tesla stockholders claimed they incurred $13 billion in damages as a result of the deal,  which they characterized as a bailout for SolarCity. They also alleged that in making the deal, Musk breached his fiduciary duty to the electric car company.

During the trial, Musk said the SolarCity deal was part of his “master plan,” which he had written in 2006 and was meant to accelerate the advent of sustainable energy.

Musk also denied that he placed any pressure on the Tesla board to go through with the transaction. 

Vice Chancellor Joseph Slights sided with Elon Musk, writing in his opinion that “Elon was more involved in the process than a conflicted fiduciary should be. And conflicts among other Tesla Board members were not completely neutralized.” 

“That said,” he continued, “the Tesla Board meaningfully vetted the acquisition, and Elon did not stand in its way.”

The case was what is known as a shareholder derivative action – a suit filed by investors on behalf of a corporation, rather than individuals or funds. 

If the plaintiffs had won, proceeds would have gone to Tesla and not to the shareholders who brought the suit.

Attorneys for the shareholders could not immediately be reached for comment. They still have the option of appealing the case to the Delaware Supreme Court.

Dan can be reached at [email protected] and at https://twitter.com/DanMcCue.


A+
a-
  • Elon Musk
  • lawsuit
  • SolarCity
  • stocks
  • Tesla
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Courts

    September 14, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Federal Court to Allow Limited Audio Access as COVID Rules End

    WASHINGTON — Federal courts will begin dialing back remote audio access later this month when an emergency policy implemented during... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Federal courts will begin dialing back remote audio access later this month when an emergency policy implemented during the pandemic expires, but judges will still have the discretion to allow live audio access to certain non-trial proceedings, the U.S. Judicial Conference said this week.... Read More

    September 8, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Appeals Court Revives Psychologists’ Lawsuit After They Were Accused of Helping in Torture

    WASHINGTON — The Washington, D.C., Court of Appeals on Thursday revived a defamation lawsuit by retired military psychologists who claimed... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Washington, D.C., Court of Appeals on Thursday revived a defamation lawsuit by retired military psychologists who claimed they were inaccurately accused of encouraging torture during the U.S. war on terrorism. The ruling also represents a setback for local laws found nationwide intended to... Read More

    Lawsuit Seeks to Bar Trump From Primary in Colorado, Citing Constitution's 14th Amendment

    DENVER (AP) — A liberal group on Wednesday filed a lawsuit to bar former President Donald Trump from the primary ballot in... Read More

    DENVER (AP) — A liberal group on Wednesday filed a lawsuit to bar former President Donald Trump from the primary ballot in Colorado, arguing he is ineligible to run for the White House again under a rarely used clause in the U.S. Constitution aimed at candidates who have... Read More

    Alex Murdaugh's Lawyers Want New Trial Claiming Court Clerk Told Jurors Not to Trust Him

    COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — Attorneys for convicted murder Alex Murdaugh want a new trial, accusing the court clerk of improperly... Read More

    COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — Attorneys for convicted murder Alex Murdaugh want a new trial, accusing the court clerk of improperly influencing the jury. They're accusing the court clerk at his double murder trial of telling jurors not to trust him when he testified in his own defense. They... Read More

    Judge Says Trump-Era Rule Change Allowing Logging of Old-Growth Forests Violates Laws

    PENDLETON, Ore. (AP) — A federal judge has found that a Trump-era rule change that allowed for the logging of... Read More

    PENDLETON, Ore. (AP) — A federal judge has found that a Trump-era rule change that allowed for the logging of old-growth forests in the Pacific Northwest violates several laws. U.S. Magistrate Judge Andrew Hallman on Thursday found that the U.S. Forest Service violated the National Environmental... Read More

    August 31, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    DC Grand Juror Pleads Guilty to Secretly Recording Witnesses

    WASHINGTON — A man who admitted to secretly recording grand jury proceedings in District of Columbia Superior Court pleaded guilty... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A man who admitted to secretly recording grand jury proceedings in District of Columbia Superior Court pleaded guilty Tuesday to criminal contempt and obstruction of justice charges. He posted the recordings from his cellphone on social media and sent them out in text messages.... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top