Loading...

DC Circuit Strikes Down GOP Challenge to Proxy Voting

July 20, 2021 by Dan McCue
DC Circuit Strikes Down GOP Challenge to Proxy Voting
Dusk falls over the Capitol, Monday, Dec. 21, 2020, in Washington. Congressional leaders have hashed out a massive, year-end catchall bill that combines $900 billion in COVID-19 aid with a $1.4 trillion spending bill and reams of other unfinished legislation on taxes, energy, education and health care. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)

WASHINGTON  – A Republican-led challenge to a House resolution allowing members to vote remotely during the COVID-19 pandemic ended abruptly Tuesday after the D.C. Circuit held it had no authority to review a “core” legislative act of Congress.

House Resolution 965 was adopted in May 2020 to allow voting by proxy for the duration of the coronavirus pandemic. It was initially meant to last a mere 45 days, but has been extended numerous times, with the most recent extension expiring Aug. 17.

A federal district court tossed the lawsuit last summer, but GOP members of Congress appealed, arguing House members must be physically present in order to reach a quorum and vote. 

To bolster their argument, the plaintiffs pointed to past examples where the House did not invoke proxy voting, like the 1918 influenza pandemic.

But in an opinion written by Chief Judge Sri Srinivasan and joined by U.S. Circuit Judges Justin Walker and Judith Rogers, the appellate panel agreed with the lower court that House officials are immune from the challenge under the U.S. Constitution’s speech and debate clause, which blocks legal challenges tied to legislative actions.

“Because we agree with the district court that the Clause bars consideration of the plaintiffs’ suit, we have no need to consider whether they have standing,” Srinivasan  wrote.

“The challenged Resolution enables members to cast votes by proxy, and the ‘act of voting’ is necessarily a legislative act,” he continued. “Indeed, we are hard-pressed to conceive of matters more integrally part of the legislative process than the rules governing how members can cast their votes on legislation and mark their presence for purposes of establishing a legislative quorum.”

Srinivasan also pointed to the circuit’s 1975 decision in Consumers Union of the United States. v. Periodical Correspondents’ Association, which challenged congressional rules requiring members of the press to apply to gain access to House and Senate press galleries. 

The circuit decided the challenge was similarly barred by the Constitution’s speech and debate clause.

“This case, if anything, more centrally involves legislative acts than did Consumers Union,” he wrote. “If the Speech or Debate Clause covers the administration of seating in the press galleries, in short, it must also cover the administration of voting by members.”

Among those applauding the ruling Tuesday afternoon was Rules Committee Chairman James P. McGovern, D-Mass., who said the decision upheld “what the Constitution and more than 100 years of legal precedent have made clear: that the House has the ability to set its own rules.

“Democrats and Republicans have utilized proxy voting during this pandemic to protect public health and keep this institution functioning,” he continued. “The fact that the minority leader is suing to prevent Congress from safely conducting the people’s business is unfortunate but emblematic of the way he approaches his role here. If Minority Leader [Kevin] McCarthy truly cares about this institution, he would drop this frivolous lawsuit and focus on what is actually threatening its integrity – those who spread dangerous conspiracy theories and downplay what happened on Jan. 6.”

In The News

Health

Voting

Congress

August 13, 2022
by Dan McCue
House Passes Inflation Reduction Act, Sends on to President

WASHINGTON — The House on Friday afternoon gave its approval to the Inflation Reduction Act, delivering a significant victory to... Read More

WASHINGTON — The House on Friday afternoon gave its approval to the Inflation Reduction Act, delivering a significant victory to President Joe Biden. The final vote was 220-207, along party lines. Four Republicans did not vote. In a tweet from Kiawah Island, South Carolina, where he... Read More

Dems Near Congressional Passage of Climate, Health Package

WASHINGTON (AP) — Democrats pushed their flagship climate change and health care bill toward House passage Friday, placing President Joe Biden on... Read More

WASHINGTON (AP) — Democrats pushed their flagship climate change and health care bill toward House passage Friday, placing President Joe Biden on the brink of a back-from-the-dead triumph on his leading domestic goals that could energize his party going into November’s elections. Democrats were poised to muscle the measure through the... Read More

August 9, 2022
by Dan McCue
Trump Can’t Keep Tax Returns From House Panel, DC Circuit Rules

WASHINGTON — Former President Donald Trump cannot block Congress from obtaining his tax returns as part of a House investigation... Read More

WASHINGTON — Former President Donald Trump cannot block Congress from obtaining his tax returns as part of a House investigation into audits of sitting presidents by the IRS, a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday. The decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of... Read More

August 8, 2022
by Dan McCue
With Senate Passage, Nation on Cusp of Having First Climate Law

WASHINGTON — “It wasn’t on the scoreboard one month ago,” Sen. Edward Markey, D-Mass., marveled when talking to reporters over... Read More

WASHINGTON — “It wasn’t on the scoreboard one month ago,” Sen. Edward Markey, D-Mass., marveled when talking to reporters over the weekend, but in just a matter of days a budget reconciliation bill long presumed dead was suddenly a “historic” achievement. And if the House follows... Read More

Democrats Say They've Reached Agreement on Economic Package

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Democrats have agreed to eleventh-hour changes to their marquee economic legislation, they announced late Thursday, clearing... Read More

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Democrats have agreed to eleventh-hour changes to their marquee economic legislation, they announced late Thursday, clearing the major impediment to pushing one of President Joe Biden’s paramount election-year priorities through the chamber in coming days. Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, D-Ariz., a centrist seen as the... Read More

August 4, 2022
by Alexa Hornbeck
Organ Transplant Network Is a ‘System in Need of Repair’ 

WASHINGTON — For 36 years, the United Network for Organ Sharing has provided a system for sick patients to get... Read More

WASHINGTON — For 36 years, the United Network for Organ Sharing has provided a system for sick patients to get donated vital organs but members from the Senate Committee on Finance are finding continued issues with the technology, and the government has little authority to change... Read More

News From The Well