Congress Tries to Protect Employers From Lawsuits Tied to Coronavirus
WASHINGTON – Industry and legal experts told the U.S. Senate Tuesday that the coronavirus pandemic is creating liabilities that are not adequately addressed by existing laws and regulations.
As a result, business owners are running up against hundreds of lawsuits that are slowing the nation’s economic recovery.
Sen. Dick Durbin, an Illinois Democrat, called the nearly 1,000 court claims filed so far this year “a tidal wave of lawsuits” during the hearing of the Senate Judiciary Committee.
The Senate is considering proposals for national standards to protect businesses from lawsuits by employees and customers during the pandemic.
Many business owners want to reopen but risk getting sued if their employees or customers are exposed to increased risk of infection and illness. Others say some of the lawsuits are attempts to get settlement money despite no proof of damages.
Meanwhile, unemployment has risen to the highest levels since the Great Depression of the 1930s and the nation’s economy is nosediving from widespread economic loss.
“We shouldn’t be punished for fulfilling our duty to stay open,” said Kevin Smartt, chief executive officer of Texas-based Kwik Chek Convenience Stores.
He agreed the health of employees and customers is important but added, “None of us could protect against every risk of infection.”
One proposal in Congress would exempt businesses from nearly all liability related to coronavirus.
A second more popular proposal would protect them from getting sued only if they meet standards of new workplace health and safety guidelines.
Democrats and Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee agreed some kind of legal protection is needed to fully reopen the U.S. economy.
They recommended that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration jointly establish national coronavirus guidelines.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein, a California Democrat, said the guidelines need to be “specific COVID-related standards.”
Sen. Lindsey Graham, the South Carolina Republican who chairs the Judiciary Committee, said the alternative to liability protection is likely to be further business failures.
“What I want to do is make sure we don’t have to go into bankruptcy any more than we have to,” Graham said.
However, a labor leader cautioned that extending the protection too far could create an incentive for employers to inadequately protect workers.
“We believe that would exacerbate some of the outlaw employers we have in this country,” said Marc Perrone, International President of the United Food and Commercial Workers International Union.
He added, “We must not provide a blanket of immunity that guarantees some of these workers would be taken advantage of.”
David Vladeck, a professor at Georgetown University Law Center in Washington, D.C., said Congress needed to avoid enacting an immunity from liability for employers that conflicts with state laws on the same issue.
“Legislation that simply displaces state liability laws is not only unprecedented it is probably unconstitutional,” Vladeck said.
In The News
WASHINGTON - The House passed legislation that would decriminalize cannabis at the federal level -- the first time either chamber of Congress has voted on such a measure. And significantly, the measure received bipartisan support. When the figurative smoke cleared, the Marijuana Opportunity Reinvestment & Expungement... Read More
WASHINGTON - House Democrats made history on Thursday when the caucus voted to make Reps. Gregory Meeks, of New York, and David Scott, of Georgia, the first African-Americans to chair, respectively, the chamber's Foreign Affairs and Agriculture Committees. Meeks, who was the third-ranking member of the... Read More
WASHINGTON -- Drug policy analysts told a congressional committee Thursday that the U.S. government has largely failed to stop illegal drug smuggling because of an unfocused strategy against the cartels. Instead, they recommended flexibility that seeks solutions based on local conditions. In one example analysts mentioned... Read More
WASHINGTON — Texas Sen. John Cornyn, a senior Republican and adviser to the majority leader, said flatly Thursday that President Donald Trump has no realistic path to overturning the election. After weeks of court defeats, he noted, Trump's legal team has yet to show evidence of fraud and ballot tampering despite claims... Read More
WASHINGTON — Pressure is building on Congress to pass another economic aid package before the end of the year, and Democratic and Republican leaders said Thursday they're hopeful a deal is possible. But with only a few days left on the legislative calendar, it's far from certain that optimism... Read More
WASHINGTON (AP) — President-elect Joe Biden is adjusting the scope of his agenda to meet the challenges of governing with a narrowly divided Congress and the complications of legislating during a raging pandemic. Rather than immediately pursue ambitious legislation to combat climate change, the incoming administration may try to... Read More