Renewable Energy Surpasses Coal As Source of US Energy, Researchers Say

May 16, 2019 by Dan McCue
Renewable Energy Surpasses Coal As Source of US Energy, Researchers Say

For the first time in history, renewable energy surpassed coal earlier this month as a source of electricity generation in the United States, the Brookings Institution reported Wednesday.

The paper underlying the report attributes this remarkable development to U.S. municipalities and businesses striving to fill the void created by President Donald Trump announcing the United States’ withdrawal from the Paris Climate Accord.

Authors Shanta Devarajan and Tito Cordella, senior director and adviser, respectively of development economics at The World Bank said an unanticipated consequence of the U.S. “leaving Paris” was how private firms and local governments would react.

“Major oil companies, including ExxonMobil, continue to invest in low-carbon technologies and some state governments have imposed stricter local environmental standards to countervail the weaker federal ones,” the authors write in a Brookings Institution blog on their findings.

As an example, they point to the efforts of then-California Governor Jerry Brown, who in September 2018 signed an executive order committing the state to be carbon-neutral by 2045.

“As Nathan Hultman and Paul Bodnar put it in another Brookings blog, ‘Trump tried to kill the Paris agreement, but the effect has been the opposite,'” the authors write.

While the unexpected developments may be due to the public-spirited behavior of firms and state governments, the authors suggest that firms’ investments in clean technologies and states’ adoption of stricter emission standards could also be the result of firms’ profit-maximizing behavior accompanied by successful lobbying efforts in the face of weaker environmental rules.

“The decision to relax emission standards may increase firms’ incentives to adopt clean technologies. The reason is simple: The increased output that these technologies permit may raise profits by more than what the dirty technologies allow,” they write.

Despite the headline-grabbing fact that renewable energy surpassed coal as a proportion of U.S. energy production, the share of renewable energy used in the United States is still low by international standards.

They note that in 2015, the most recent year from which reliable statistics were available as they compiled their report, renewable energy represented just 13 percent of the mix in the U.S. They compare this to nearly a third of Germany’s energy coming from renewables (29 percent), and three-quarters of Brazil’s energy (74 percent) coming from the same renewable sources, mainly wind, solar and hydropower.

Devarajan and Cordella also have concerns about the future.

Yes, businesses and local governments have made great strides in balancing the initial negative impacts of Trump administration policies, but they fear that in order to undo the long-term damages current White House polices are inflicting on the environment, a future, “greener” administration intent on meeting the nation’s original Paris commitments may be forced to impose “draconian” emission cuts.

These, they say, may negatively affect firms’ profitability and cause them to be less green-minded in the future.

In their view, “all firms would be better off if they were mandated to adapt today to the standards that they will likely face in the future.”

To illustrate their point, the the authors turn to the issue of traffic congestion.

“While we would all be better off if we were forced to use public transportation instead of contributing to traffic jams, it is in no individual’s interest to leave their car home just to make others’ commute easier,” they write. “An efficient way to solve this tragedy of the commons, is to force all firms to abide by a stricter regulation.

“Of course, this is easier said than done when federal regulation is at the root of the problem. And it is unlikely that all states will agree on a common stricter regulation because, again, it will be in the interest of small states to free ride on the regulation enacted in the other states,” they write.

For larger states, the story is a different one. The authors say some states may have enough critical mass that their regulations have such a positive impact on the national level that they’d be willing to pay the price of stricter regulation, regardless of what other states do.

Devarajan and Cordella call this the “California effect,” which they explain as a very large state being willing to pay for the price of policies that affect the rest of the U.S. states because they are also significantly affected by them.

“In terms of the traffic example, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (and certainly the federal government) are big enough in Washington, D.C. that they could make their employees better off by banning their use of private transportation … [and] the remaining lawyers and lobbyists could (literally and figuratively) get free ride,” they write.

A+
a-
  • coal
  • Paris Accord
  • renewable energy
  • United States
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Climate

    March 20, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    White House Unveils Sweeping Rules to Speed Switch to Cleaner Cars

    WASHINGTON — The Biden-Harris administration on Wednesday rolled out an ambitious new regulatory regime aimed at bolstering the standards of... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Biden-Harris administration on Wednesday rolled out an ambitious new regulatory regime aimed at bolstering the standards of electric and hybrid vehicles by placing new restrictions on tailpipe emissions. According to administration officials, who briefed reporters on the new rules during a conference call... Read More

    March 15, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    Senate Told Growing Wildfire Threat Needs New Strategies

    WASHINGTON — The number of wildfires driven by climate change has grown but the U.S. effort to control them has... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The number of wildfires driven by climate change has grown but the U.S. effort to control them has not, according to emergency response officials at a Senate hearing Thursday. At least not fast enough to prevent disasters like the fire that ravaged Maui in... Read More

    Storm Carrying Massive 'Gorilla Hail' Hits Parts of Kansas and Missouri

    ST. LOUIS (AP) — Massive chunks of hail pelted parts of Kansas and Missouri on Wednesday night, bringing traffic to... Read More

    ST. LOUIS (AP) — Massive chunks of hail pelted parts of Kansas and Missouri on Wednesday night, bringing traffic to a standstill along Interstate 70, as storms unleashed possible tornadoes and meteorologists urged residents to stay indoors. There were three unconfirmed reports of tornadoes in Wabaunsee... Read More

    Climate, a Major Separator for Biden and Trump, Is a Dividing Line in Many Other Races

    RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — The race for the White House isn’t the only one with big stakes for climate policy.... Read More

    RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — The race for the White House isn’t the only one with big stakes for climate policy. In campaigns for Congress and for governor around the country, candidates are talking about how green the grid should be, too. Voters are increasingly feeling the impacts... Read More

    The First-Ever European Climate Risk Assessment Finds a Continent Unprepared for Growing Extremes

    Europe is facing growing climate risks and is unprepared for them, the European Environment Agency said in its first-ever risk... Read More

    Europe is facing growing climate risks and is unprepared for them, the European Environment Agency said in its first-ever risk assessment for the bloc Monday. The agency said Europe is prone to more frequent and more punishing weather extremes — including increasing wildfires, drought, more unusual... Read More

    Fewer Fish and More Algae? Scientists Seek to Understand Impacts of Historic Lack of Great Lakes Ice

    RACINE, Wis. (AP) — Michigan Tech University biologists have been observing a remote Lake Superior island's fragile wolf population every... Read More

    RACINE, Wis. (AP) — Michigan Tech University biologists have been observing a remote Lake Superior island's fragile wolf population every winter since 1958, but they had to cut this season's planned seven-week survey short after just two weeks. The ski plane they study the wolves from... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top