DC Circuit Rejects Trump Policy of Blocking Abortions for Undocumented Teens

June 14, 2019 by Dan McCue
DC Circuit Rejects Trump Policy of Blocking Abortions for Undocumented Teens
The E. Barrett Prettyman Federal Courthouse in Washington, D.C. It currently houses the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, and the United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON – The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the Trump administration’s policy of blocking abortions sought by undocumented pregnant teenagers in federal custody cannot “be squared with Supreme Court precedent.”

In 2017, the Trump administration adopted a policy that required Scott Lloyd, then-director of the Office of Refugee Resettlement, to sign off personally on every abortion requested by a minor in federal custody.

Lloyd, an anti-abortion crusader, rejected every one. But matters came to a head in the fall of 2017, when a 17-year-old girl identified only as Jane Doe demanded access to an abortion after being detained at the U.S. border in Texas.

Attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union, led by Brigitte Amiri, deputy director of the organization’s Reproductive Freedom Project, sued on her behalf in October 2017, asking the court to order the government to allow her to have the procedure, but the Trump administration continued to object.

During an expedited hearing, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan said she was astounded by arguments made by Justice Department attorneys, who claimed Doe did not have a constitutional right to an elective abortion while in federal custody.

Chutkan promptly issued a two-page order, holding the teen would “suffer irreparable injury in the form of, at a minimum, increased risk to her health, and perhaps the permanent inability to obtain a desired abortion to which she is legally entitled.”

In doing so, she also ordered the government to transport the teen “promptly and without delay” to the closest abortion provider.

After the court ordered the government to allow Doe to proceed with her abortion, the ACLU learned of several other young women in government custody who were being prevented from accessing abortion care.

The case was then certified as a class action and Judge Chutkan ordered the policy halted in March 2018.

In the meantime, Lloyd was removed from his post at the Office of Refugee Resettlement, after internal emails and depositions made public as part of the ACLU lawsuit suggested he was devoting much of his time to micromanaging the abortion requests of teenagers in his custody.

He was transferred to the Department of Health and Human Services’ Center for Faith and Opportunity Initiatives.

In its 2-1 decision on Friday, the D.C. District Court of Appeals held that the Trump administration should continue to be stayed while the ACLU case continues to proceed as a class action.

U.S. Circuit Judges Sri Srinivasan and Robert Wilkins, both Obama appointees, found that there is a likelihood that Jane Doe and the other young women who have joined the class action will succeed on their claim that the no-abortion policy “infringes on their protected right to choose to terminate their pregnancies.”

Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Laurence Silberman, a Reagan appointee, filed a dissenting opinion.

The ACLU’s Amiri responded to Friday’s ruling with harsh words for the White House.

“The Trump administration’s cruel policy of blocking young immigrant women in federal custody from accessing abortion was a blatant abuse of power,” she said.

“We are relieved that today’s ruling continues to prevent the policy from taking effect while the case proceeds, and allows the case to proceed as a class action as we continue this fight,” she added.

The ruling comes amid the passage of several state abortion bans intended to push the U.S. Supreme Court to reconsider its decision on Roe v. Wade, the case in which the court found women had a constitutional right to make their own reproductive choices.

“With today’s ruling, we are another step closer to ending this extreme policy once and for all, and securing justice for all of these young women,” Amiri said. “We will continue fighting to make sure that the Trump administration is permanently blocked from obstructing young immigrant minors’ access to crucial health care”

A+
a-
  • Abortion
  • ACLU
  • Department of Health and Human Services
  • Donald Trump
  • teenagers
  • undocumented aliens
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Civil Rights

    One of the Last Surviving Tuskegee Airmen Remembers Struggle for Recognition Amid Trump's DEI Purge

    AURORA, Colo. (AP) — With members of a trailblazing Black Air Force unit passing away at advanced ages, efforts to remain true... Read More

    AURORA, Colo. (AP) — With members of a trailblazing Black Air Force unit passing away at advanced ages, efforts to remain true to their memory carry on despite sometimes confusing orders from President Donald Trump as he purges federal diversity, equity and inclusion programs. Col. James H. Harvey III, 101, is among the last... Read More

    Drawing Huge Crowds, Bernie Sanders Steps Into Leadership of the Anti-Trump Resistance

    WARREN, Mich. (AP) — Bernie Sanders is standing alone on the back of a pickup truck shouting into a bullhorn.... Read More

    WARREN, Mich. (AP) — Bernie Sanders is standing alone on the back of a pickup truck shouting into a bullhorn. He's facing several hundred ecstatic voters huddled outside a suburban Detroit high school — the group that did not fit inside the high school's gym or... Read More

    February 28, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    AG Bondi Steps Up Effort to Force States to Comply With Trump Trans Policy

    WASHINGTON  — Attorney General Pam Bondi has sent letters to officials in three states warning them they must prevent transgender... Read More

    WASHINGTON  — Attorney General Pam Bondi has sent letters to officials in three states warning them they must prevent transgender students from participating in women’s and girls’ sports or risk legal action. “This Department of Justice will defend women and does not tolerate state officials who... Read More

    February 25, 2025
    by Dan McCue
    Log Cabin GOP: Trump Best President for LGBT Community ‘Ever’

    NATIONAL HARBOR, Md. — While MAGA was in full force and party mode this past week at CPAC 2025, smaller... Read More

    NATIONAL HARBOR, Md. — While MAGA was in full force and party mode this past week at CPAC 2025, smaller subsets of the conservative Republican establishment said they had their own reasons to celebrate. Among these were the Log Cabin Republicans, gay members of the GOP... Read More

    Anti-Vaxxer Explains Her Position, Thrilled With Kennedy Confirmation

    WASHINGTON — Rachel Bowes smiled from inside the Informed Consent Action Network’s booth in what might have been called the... Read More

    WASHINGTON — Rachel Bowes smiled from inside the Informed Consent Action Network’s booth in what might have been called the health and science wing of CPAC 2025’s exhibition hall. Immediately to her left was the “Make America Healthy Again” booth, which was piled high with colorful... Read More

    White House Will Celebrate Black History Month as Some Government Agencies Skip After Anti-DEI Order

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration will celebrate Black History Month at the White House on Thursday, preserving a tradition... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration will celebrate Black History Month at the White House on Thursday, preserving a tradition at the same time that President Donald Trump's executive order ending the federal government's diversity, equity and inclusion programs has disrupted its observance elsewhere. The ceremony comes as... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top