The FCC Still Looking at Exclusivity Arrangements in MTE Broadband Market

September 7, 2021 by Victoria Turner
The FCC Still Looking at Exclusivity Arrangements in MTE Broadband Market
A Consolidated Communications technician works on a line used to provide broadband internet service in a rural area on Wednesday, July 29, 2020, in Stowe, Vt. (AP Photo/Wilson Ring)

WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission announced today it is seeking another round of comments regarding exclusivity arrangements between multi-tenant buildings and broadband providers. 

The filings preceding the announcement show the tug-of-war remains between those who think the competitive landscape for the broadband market in these multiple tenant environments is working and those, particularly smaller carriers and consumer advocates, who do not. What it comes down to is a debate between those who want to regulate the MTE broadband market and those who don’t. 

Since 2000, the agency has been updating rules regarding the service agreements between the carriers and the MTE owners – particularly prohibiting exclusivity agreements making a carrier the sole service provider for the building, preventing others from competing for the same MTE and lessening consumer choices. 

Another issue under review is the wiring agreements MTE owners enter to give access to the service providers for their wiring to be installed, regardless of the options their tenants – the end-users – actually desire. 

In their release today, the agency is reinvigorating their 2019 rulemaking efforts by seeking comments on revenue sharing agreements as well as exclusive wiring and marketing arrangements between MTE owners and carriers.

At the end of last year, the FCC’s docket began picking up momentum again with a back-and-forth between smaller service providers like Sonic Communications and trade association INCOMPAS versus advocate groups – like the National Multifamily Housing Council and the National Apartment Association – representing MTE owners as “Building Owner Advocates.” 

Both sides painted very different pictures of the state of competition in the market. 

The Building Owner Advocates stated that 88% of all Americans have at least two broadband providers they can choose from, but Sonic countered that this only reflected national data – not the actual residents of MTEs – which the Houston-based telecommunications company alleged was a much smaller number. 

Sparking this latest round of debate was INCOMPAS, a trade association made up of large and small communications and technology companies that advocate for policy changes in their arena. In an August 2020 ex parte filing, INCOMPAS wrote about a call between its Government Relations Director Andrew Micheff, a couple of FCC officials and Stephen Bradley, Sonic’s director of sales and marketing. 

“Incumbent communications providers and landlords have used graduated revenue sharing and access fees as well as wiring and rooftop exclusivity arrangements to circumvent the Commission’s access rules and exclude competitive providers from MTEs,” the letter alleged, adding that exclusive marketing agreements only add to reducing the likelihood of competitors getting to those MTEs. 

“[O]bstacles such as revenue sharing requests from building owners, access fees, and exclusivity provisions in the contract with the building’s current service provider has precluded the company and others from provisioning broadband services to these buildings,” the letter said that Bradley noted during the call. In other words, only the big market players can afford them while simultaneously absorbing the cost of extending their network to them.

But on the flip side, the response pointed to INCOMPAS’s filings as an example that the regulations restricting revenue sharing agreements as well as the exclusive wiring and marketing arrangements are unnecessary. Despite traffic increasing 20% to 40% throughout the pandemic, the advocates said the networks performed optimally throughout the broadband market and attributed this success to the former FCC administration’s light regulatory touch that “gave network operators the flexibility they needed to meet changes in demand.” 

“Different providers, including small, independent broadband providers, using different technologies and following different business plans are serving different sectors of the market on mutually agreeable terms,” the advocates stated, and that was due to the free market “not by government dictate.”

But it seems the FCC is not yet convinced either way. As the agency seeks to “refresh the record,” the debate is not over. 

“It’s time to take a fresh look at how exclusive agreements between carriers and building owners could lock out broadband competition and consumer choice,” FCC Acting Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel said in a statement.

A+
a-
  • broadband
  • FCC
  • MTE Broadband market
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Broadband

    October 19, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    FCC Votes to Advance Bid to Restore Net Neutrality

    WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission voted on Thursday to proceed with a proposal to restore net neutrality and at... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission voted on Thursday to proceed with a proposal to restore net neutrality and at the same time, potentially, broaden the agency’s reach. The 3-2 party-line vote — with all Democratic commissioners voting in favor of the proposal — was the... Read More

    Biden Administration Announces More Funding for Rural Broadband Infrastructure

    The Biden administration on Monday continued its push toward internet-for-all by 2030, announcing about $667 million in new grants and... Read More

    The Biden administration on Monday continued its push toward internet-for-all by 2030, announcing about $667 million in new grants and loans to build more broadband infrastructure in the rural U.S. “With this investment, we’re getting funding to communities in every corner of the country because we... Read More

    April 27, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Hawaii to Net $115.5M for Broadband Projects

    WASHINGTON — As one of the most isolated populated places on Earth, Hawaii has long faced a litany of unique... Read More

    WASHINGTON — As one of the most isolated populated places on Earth, Hawaii has long faced a litany of unique communications challenges. But those days — and the island state’s heavy-duty reliance on submarine cables — are on the verge of being over. That’s because the... Read More

    March 2, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Treasury Has Dispensed Nearly $5B for Broadband Expansion

    WASHINGTON — The Treasury Department has awarded nearly $5 billion from the Capital Projects Fund to pay for broadband expansion... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Treasury Department has awarded nearly $5 billion from the Capital Projects Fund to pay for broadband expansion projects in 33 states, and expects to bestow the remaining $5 billion by the end of the year, the program’s director said on Wednesday. Speaking at... Read More

    Poor, Less White Areas Get Worst Internet Deals

    A couple of years into the pandemic, Shirley Neville had finally had enough of her shoddy internet service. “It was... Read More

    A couple of years into the pandemic, Shirley Neville had finally had enough of her shoddy internet service. “It was just a headache,” said Neville, who lives in a middle-class neighborhood in New Orleans whose residents are almost all Black or Latino. “When I was getting... Read More

    September 30, 2022
    by Madeline Hughes
    Broadband Grant Leaves Alaskan Village ‘Giddy’

    PORT LIONS, Alaska — The residents of the native village of Port Lions and surrounding Alaskan villages are “giddy” at... Read More

    PORT LIONS, Alaska — The residents of the native village of Port Lions and surrounding Alaskan villages are “giddy” at the thought of getting internet through the Department of Commerce’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration’s Tribal Broadband Connectivity Program, said Denise May, the tribal administer for... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top