Federal Broadband Deployment Needs to Coordinate With Local Governments

October 29, 2021 by Victoria Turner
Federal Broadband Deployment Needs to Coordinate With Local Governments
Workers installing broadband cables. (Photo by Mika Baumeister via Unsplash)

PITTSBURGH — Despite the strides made towards increasing broadband access for all Americans through federal deployment and subsidy programs, 30 million households in the U.S. are still not subscribed to broadband services even when they are available, said Ross Lieberman, senior vice president of government affairs at ACA Connects, Thursday. 

Broadband infrastructure deployment goes “hand-in-hand” with tackling the broadband adoption issue, said Whitney Kimball Coe, director of national programs at the Center for Rural Strategies, during ACA Connects’ event entitled, “Building Successful Broadband Adoption Programs: Insights from the Field.”

The most common reason for nonsubscribers, Lieberman explained, was insufficient income. However, he said, even if the cost of “broadband is zero, other barriers remain, running from lack of connected devices to low digital literacy.” 

A recent survey on why people were not adopting the school-sponsored, no-cost programs found most people pointed to an “information trust barrier,” said Hannah Hill, principal at Boston Consulting Group. Households did not know they were eligible, she explained, or had difficulties going through the application and technical installation process. Some also did not know whether to trust there would be no unexpected charges, and that “can be really scary when you’re already struggling to meet basic needs” like food and rent. 

Nevertheless, addressing one side of the access and adoption problem will benefit the other, Kimball Coe said. An estimated 20 to 26 million Americans live in rural areas, “so addressing one piece of that will improve adoption on the other end of that.” 

The issue comes down to understanding the needs of the local communities, said Jonathan Bullock, executive vice president of corporate development and government at Hotwire Communications. 

In rural areas, the problem is a lack of infrastructure. Whereas on the urban side, Bullock said it’s a trust issue, so they began working with their “trusted community partners like housing authorities, charter schools, churches,” and the like. By partnering with the housing authority, for example, the tenants get ubiquitous Wi-Fi without even having to sign up. Through school partnerships, he added, subscribers talk to the school to sign up instead of calling the internet provider. 

“We make the signup something of a benefit, folks are willing to do it,” said Bullock, saying these local partnerships allow providers to extend their subsidy programs. 

“But again, that’s at a place where you have infrastructure…and you’re subsidizing an operating expense,” he said, which is low cost, but there isn’t a “private business model to build out to these areas.” 

Having a local government step in to help subsidize the infrastructure allows the private business model to meet the municipalities’ goal of addressing their community digital equity and access issues, Bullock explained, which “are unique to local governments.”

That particular private-public model, he added, solves both the infrastructure and the adoption issue.

According to Yosef Getachew, media and democracy program director at Common Cause, the $65 billion in broadband infrastructure the current bipartisan infrastructure framework includes is poised to address the three pillars needed to create the desired results: broadband deployment, adoption and digital equity. The Digital Equity Act includes $2.75 billion for grants to states for digital equity, inclusion and literacy programs like digital literacy training and broadband devices. 

But every state has its own laws and they don’t always coincide with each other nor federal objectives, as some “either support community networks or the expansion of infrastructure,” Kimball Coe said. 

And so far, Getachew added, there has not been a “sole entity at the federal level” that can “play the role of a digital equity coordinator” by collecting the success stories across communities to establish a national “digital equity plan framework.” 

“We have to put more energy, resources and effort into that coordination between the federal government and state and local [governments] to make sure that each community is getting its needs met,” she charged, as local ownership of the infrastructure will solve the access and adoptions issues.

Until the U.S. puts permanent broadband infrastructure in the ground or in the air by satellite, then the ongoing broadband investments will just keep building up future debt, Bullock warned. 

Victoria can re reached at [email protected].

A+
a-
  • ACA Connects
  • broadband
  • government partnerships
  • local government
  • Technology
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Broadband

    October 19, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    FCC Votes to Advance Bid to Restore Net Neutrality

    WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission voted on Thursday to proceed with a proposal to restore net neutrality and at... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Federal Communications Commission voted on Thursday to proceed with a proposal to restore net neutrality and at the same time, potentially, broaden the agency’s reach. The 3-2 party-line vote — with all Democratic commissioners voting in favor of the proposal — was the... Read More

    Biden Administration Announces More Funding for Rural Broadband Infrastructure

    The Biden administration on Monday continued its push toward internet-for-all by 2030, announcing about $667 million in new grants and... Read More

    The Biden administration on Monday continued its push toward internet-for-all by 2030, announcing about $667 million in new grants and loans to build more broadband infrastructure in the rural U.S. “With this investment, we’re getting funding to communities in every corner of the country because we... Read More

    April 27, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Hawaii to Net $115.5M for Broadband Projects

    WASHINGTON — As one of the most isolated populated places on Earth, Hawaii has long faced a litany of unique... Read More

    WASHINGTON — As one of the most isolated populated places on Earth, Hawaii has long faced a litany of unique communications challenges. But those days — and the island state’s heavy-duty reliance on submarine cables — are on the verge of being over. That’s because the... Read More

    March 2, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Treasury Has Dispensed Nearly $5B for Broadband Expansion

    WASHINGTON — The Treasury Department has awarded nearly $5 billion from the Capital Projects Fund to pay for broadband expansion... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Treasury Department has awarded nearly $5 billion from the Capital Projects Fund to pay for broadband expansion projects in 33 states, and expects to bestow the remaining $5 billion by the end of the year, the program’s director said on Wednesday. Speaking at... Read More

    Poor, Less White Areas Get Worst Internet Deals

    A couple of years into the pandemic, Shirley Neville had finally had enough of her shoddy internet service. “It was... Read More

    A couple of years into the pandemic, Shirley Neville had finally had enough of her shoddy internet service. “It was just a headache,” said Neville, who lives in a middle-class neighborhood in New Orleans whose residents are almost all Black or Latino. “When I was getting... Read More

    September 30, 2022
    by Madeline Hughes
    Broadband Grant Leaves Alaskan Village ‘Giddy’

    PORT LIONS, Alaska — The residents of the native village of Port Lions and surrounding Alaskan villages are “giddy” at... Read More

    PORT LIONS, Alaska — The residents of the native village of Port Lions and surrounding Alaskan villages are “giddy” at the thought of getting internet through the Department of Commerce’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration’s Tribal Broadband Connectivity Program, said Denise May, the tribal administer for... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top