Betsy DeVos Can’t Be Bothered

April 12, 2019 by Mary Sanchez
U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy Devos.

Say this for Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos: She’s consistently elitist.

She’s also consistently obtuse, which often is the demeanor of the entitled. DeVos simply can’t be bothered to consult studies that don’t comport with what she already believes or to consider input from members of Congress who have a duty to safeguard the public education system that serves their constituents.

DeVos is unwaveringly attached, at times to the point of staggering ignorance, to ideological postulates inimical to equality in education.

It’s no surprise that DeVos had the equivalent of a very bad day at school when she appeared Wednesday before a House committee. The five-hour hearing was her first before a House committee since Democrats became the majority, so she couldn’t count on the soft treatment typical of her early tenure.

DeVos prepped herself to answer tough questions the best she could while offering no real information, but in the end she might have had more luck had she just claimed that the dog ate her homework.

A pattern was quickly set. DeVos would deny, dodge, pivot, always delivering the vague replies with a smile.

Members of the House Education and Labor Committee grilled the secretary on many aspects of the administration’s proposed budget, which requests a 12.5 percent cut from previous funding levels.

Democrats tried to draw her out on the administration’s rollback of Obama-era guidance around transgender students, which they argued could undercut those children’s mental health, citing studies about levels of depression, bullying and suicide attempts.

Nope, DeVos wasn’t going to engage. She merely acknowledged that, yes, she knew of such studies.

She held steadfast to the view that the proposed Education Freedom Scholarships are an exciting opportunity for parents and children. It’s a first cousin to voucher programs.

The plan will allow for $5 billion in federal dollar-to-dollar tax credits that can be applied in a variety of ways, including toward private or religious education.

Nor would DeVos actually answer queries about why her department is stalling on deciding if loan forgiveness should be granted to nearly 160,000 people with claims of being defrauded by for-profit colleges.

To be fair to DeVos, it’s not that she doesn’t care about children, education or the future of the nation, despite what her harshest critics believe.

Her problem is that she thinks her views are more important than those of academic experts, of the courts, which have repeatedly ruled against the administration’s efforts, of teachers’ organizations, of parents and of the very children she claims to protect.

Points of view that contradict her own — which boil down to the attitude that the federal government controls too much in education — are quickly dismissed.

One exchange, in particular, illustrated this.

Rep. David Trone, a Maryland Democrat, pressed DeVos to commit to the goals of diversity despite the Trump administration’s rollback Obama-era guidelines on the use of race in admittance policies.

At first, she deferred by claiming that she had no real knowledge of the U.S. Supreme Court case on which the guidance was based.

Eventually, she acknowledged the benefit of diverse educational settings, which is a far cry from actually discussing the complexities of legally accomplishing them.

Trone also tried to pry a useful statement from DeVos by asking if she agreed that racial segregation “poses a threat to the educational opportunities for children of color.”

DeVos replied, “I am concerned with every student.”

Wow. Nobody saw that coming: a deft iteration of “all lives matter” cop-out. That’s the rhetorical ploy favored by people who would rather not discuss the fact that black and brown lives have a peculiar tendency to matter less in American society, in contexts as various as policing, education, employment and wealth. Rather than grapple with why and how structural inequality persists, these people simply chirp that “everyone” is important.

Extremely privileged people — and DeVos’ family wealth is estimated at about $5 billion — can be a bit sheltered from accepting that all they do might not be golden.

During her two years as a cabinet secretary, DeVos has had extraordinary access to resources that could help her see how complicated the world of education is, including the great successes and failures of both traditional public schools and of the charter schools that she champions.

We expect students to engage as life-long learners, to develop adaptive skills that best prepare them for life. And yet at the top of the federal education bureaucracy sits a woman who doesn’t seem to have learned a thing.

Readers can reach Mary Sanchez at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter @msanchezcolumn.

© 2019, MARY SANCHEZ DISTRIBUTED BY TRIBUNE CONTENT AGENCY, LLC

Opinions

Moving Forward Together in the Face of a Global Pandemic
Opinions
Moving Forward Together in the Face of a Global Pandemic

This global pandemic knows no borders and has no regard for politics. Like Americans who have come together to take steps to bend the curve, our elected officials have also come together swiftly and in a bipartisan manner to provide much-needed federal assistance to the millions... Read More

COVID-19 Is About to Make Our Affordable Housing Crisis Much Worse. Here’s One Way to Help Stem the Tide
Opinions
COVID-19 Is About to Make Our Affordable Housing Crisis Much Worse. Here’s One Way to Help Stem the Tide

Even before the COVID-19 pandemic created a global economic downturn, the U.S. faced a mounting affordable housing crisis. In March, the National Low Income Housing Coalition estimated that the U.S. needs at least 7 million more affordable units to sufficiently house extremely low-income Americans. With more than 30... Read More

Time for Congress to Fix Leave Protections for Forgotten Frontline Workers in Next Relief Bill
Opinions
Time for Congress to Fix Leave Protections for Forgotten Frontline Workers in Next Relief Bill

Every day, Joyce Barnes starts work at 7 am. She wraps up at 10 pm to go home. And she’s done this for more than three decades as a home health care worker. One of Joyce’s patients suffered a stroke earlier this year and cannot get... Read More

America’s Mariners Perform Essential Work During COVID-19 Crisis
Opinions
America’s Mariners Perform Essential Work During COVID-19 Crisis

Each week, tug boat operators cross the Bering Sea from Dutch Harbor, Alaska, to Akutan Island, towing a barge full of groceries, medicine and other life-sustaining provisions. After offloading the cargo, containers full of fish products are loaded onto the barge for the return trip –... Read More

Veterans Need Help to Quit Smoking. Smoking Alternatives Can Help.
Opinions
Veterans Need Help to Quit Smoking. Smoking Alternatives Can Help.

As a veteran advocacy organization, Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America (IAVA) focuses on non-partisan priority issues all Americans can support, like combating veteran suicide and access to post military education. These priorities are driven by veteran responses to IAVA’s annual member survey, the most recent... Read More

Congress Must Return to Session
Opinions
Congress Must Return to Session

There is no question that the United States is in crisis. A global pandemic and economic crisis have upended American life, costing lives and leaving millions of families without a way to make ends meet. In the face of this national emergency, those of us in... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top