Baltimore Sues To Force Second Jewel Of Triple Crown To Stay Put

March 20, 2019 by Dan McCue

Baltimore Mayor Catherine Pugh sued the owners of Pimlico Race Course on Tuesday in a bid to block them from moving one of the city’s signature sporting events, the Preakness Stakes, to another thoroughbred racing track in Maryland.

Pugh, a Democrat, filed the lawsuit in Baltimore Circuit Court, on behalf of her office, the city council and three local residents.

She is asking the court to prevent the owners of the track and race, the Stronach Group, from using state funds to fund improvements at the other track, Laurel Park in Anne Arundel County, which is about 30 miles south of the Baltimore facility.

Instead, she’s asking the court to grant ownership of Pimlico and the Preakness to the city through condemnation.

The Stronach Group took control of Laurel and Pimlico, where the Preakness was first run in 1873, when it bought the Maryland Jockey Club, eight years ago.

Since then, the lawsuit claims, the Stronach Group has “systematically underinvested in Pimlico and invested instead in the Laurel Racetrack.”

A Maryland law passed in 1987 explicitly states the Preakness, the second jewel in racing’s Triple Crown, can be moved from Pimlico “only as a result of a disaster or emergency.”

The other two “jewels” are the Kentucky Derby and the Belmont Stakes.

Stronach has spent the majority of the state aid it receives for track improvements on Laurel Park for the past several years.

Pugh maintains the Stronach Group is “openly planning to violate Maryland law by moving the Preakness to a different racetrack despite the absence of any disaster or emergency, except for the disaster that they are in the process of creating.”

“Through the systemic divestment of Pimlico, Defendants could indeed manufacture an ‘emergency or disaster’ to justify transfer of the Preakness to Laurel, as undermaintained infrastructure begins to fail and crowds attending Pimlico races and the horses racing there are endangered,” the lawsuit claims.

The mayor also states that moving the race, which is held in mid-May, would harm the Park Heights and Pimlico neighborhoods around the track, which are poorer than the neighborhoods surrounding Laurel Park.

“Divesting from Pimlico in order to invest in Laurel and Bowie creates further imbalances in Maryland’s economy,” the lawsuit states.

The Stronach Group has promised to keep the Preakness at Pimlico through the 2020 horse racing season.

At the same time, it has been investing heavily in Laurel Park in the hopes of attracting the multi-million dollar Breeders’ Cup and other lucrative stakes races to the region.

To help bring its plan to fruition, the group has backed legislation in the Maryland General Assembly that would allow the Maryland Economic Development Corp. to issue $80 million in bonds to pay for improvements at Laurel and another $40 million in bonds for enhancements at a nearby training center.

With less than three weeks remaining in the current General Assembly sessions, the fate of the legislation is uncertain. States lawmakers representing Baltimore and its surrounding communities have been vocal in their opposition to it.

One of them, State Sen. Bill Ferguson, a Democrat, has proposed amending the bill to require Stronach to file a redevelopment plan for Pimlico before any bonds could be spent on Laurel.

In the meantime, Pugh says if the court allows the city to take ownership of Pimlico and the race, the “properties will be used to continue their historic role in the cultural traditions of Baltimore City, to foster employment and economic development in Baltimore, and in particular in the Park Heights Urban Renewal jurisdiction, as well as to protect the health and safety of the people attending the Preakness and other Pimlico events.”

In a statement provided to The Well News, Baltimore City Solicitor Andre Davis said though the city moved forward with the filing of the lawsuit, “we remain willing and hopeful to continue discussions with the defendants and all stakeholders to reach an agreeable resolution of our claims.  

“There is no “Triple Crown” without the Preakness Stakes and the Preakness Stakes belongs in Baltimore City at Pimlico,” Davis continued.  “And that is true by virtue of its long history and tradition as well as by state law. So we are hopeful that all concerned will see the wisdom in pursuing the path of restoration of the Park Heights facility to continue our great tradition as the venue for the second leg of the Triple Crown. ”

In a statement of its own the Stronach Group said, “These actions are premature and unfounded.”

Litigation

NC Gerrymandering Trial Begins, Could Have Major Implications For 2020 And Beyond State News
NC Gerrymandering Trial Begins, Could Have Major Implications For 2020 And Beyond

RALEIGH, N.C. — The lines used to elect members of the North Carolina General Assembly are unconstitutional and should be redrawn before the 2020 elections, an attorney for activists and politicians argued in court Monday. In 2018, Democratic candidates won more than 50% of the votes... Read More

Fourth Circuit Dismisses Emoluments Lawsuit Over Trump's D.C. Hotel In The News
Fourth Circuit Dismisses Emoluments Lawsuit Over Trump's D.C. Hotel
July 10, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals handed a legal victory to President Trump Wednesday, dismissing a lawsuit claiming he's been illegally profiting from foreign and state government officials who stay at his luxury hotel on Pennsylvania Avenue. "Word just out that I won... Read More

House Democrats Sue Treasury Department Over Trump Tax Returns Litigation
House Democrats Sue Treasury Department Over Trump Tax Returns
July 2, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON -  House Democrats sued the Trump administration in federal court Tuesday for access to President Donald Trump's tax returns, setting up a legal showdown over the records. In a complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, the House Ways and... Read More

Holder Vows to Shift Partisan Gerrymandering Fight to the States In The News
Holder Vows to Shift Partisan Gerrymandering Fight to the States
June 28, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - The U.S. Supreme Court's ruling Thursday that federal judges have no role in settling disputes over partisan gerrymandering appears likely only to intensify efforts in the states to end the practice that allows both political parties to put a stranglehold on electoral majorities. "My... Read More

Courts Must Continue to Defer to Agency's Interpretation of Regulations Supreme Court
Courts Must Continue to Defer to Agency's Interpretation of Regulations
June 26, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - A sharply divided U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld a series of legal precedents instructing courts to defer to an agency's interpretation of its own regulations. The ruling, written by Justice Elena Kagan, is a significant development in administrative law, and came to pass... Read More

Federal Employees’ Lawsuit Reinstated for Data Breach of Personal Information Litigation
Federal Employees’ Lawsuit Reinstated for Data Breach of Personal Information
June 25, 2019
by Tom Ramstack

WASHINGTON - Federal employees will get their day in court after the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled last week that their lawsuit over an Office of Personnel Management data breach can be reinstated. A trial court dismissed the lawsuit accusing OPM of negligence for allowing... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top