Appeals Court Halts Florida Felons from Registering to Vote, Pending Further Review

July 2, 2020by Lawrence Mower, Miami Herald/Times Tallahassee Bureau (TNS)
Desmond Meade registers to vote, his wife Sheena Meade beside him, at the Orange County, Fla., Supervisor of Elections office on Jan. 8, 2018. Meade, a University of Florida political science professor, testified during a lawsuit against a law requiring ex-felons to pay all outstanding debts before restoring their right to vote. (Sarah Espedido/Orlando Sentinel/TNS)

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A federal appellate court has temporarily stopped a judge’s order that granted hundreds of thousands of felons the right to vote, the latest turn in Florida’s battle over felon voting rights.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit ruled in favor of state officials and Gov. Ron DeSantis, who asked the court to stop a ruling in May by U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle. Hinkle ruled that DeSantis and Florida elections officials can’t keep felons from voting if they can’t afford to pay all court fees, fines and restitution, finding that the requirement is unconstitutional.

The court’s order also states that the entire panel of 11th Circuit judges will hear the case, a rare decision that was requested by DeSantis. The panel, which is known as one of the more conservative appellate courts in the nation, includes two judges that DeSantis had first appointed to Florida’s Supreme Court.

The decision is a setback for the hundreds of thousands of felons who were granted the ability to vote under Hinkle’s order. A spokesman for Florida Secretary of State Laurel Lee, who oversees the state’s Division of Elections, did not respond to questions about the ruling.

Hinkle’s ruling in May over Amendment 4, passed by Florida voters in 2018, was sweeping. DeSantis and state lawmakers last year limited the historic amendment by requiring felons to pay all court-ordered financial obligations before being allowed to vote.

Hinkle struck that down. He ruled that court fees, which are tacked on to a felon’s sentence and subsidize the criminal justice system, amounted to a poll tax. He also ruled that if a felon can’t afford to pay court fines, such as Florida’s $50,000 fine for drug trafficking, or restitution to victims, it can’t stop them from registering to vote.

“This order holds that the State can condition voting on payment of fines and restitution that a person is able to pay but cannot condition voting on payment of amounts a person is unable to pay,” Hinkle wrote.

His decision opened up a path for potentially hundreds of thousands of felons to register to vote, six months before the presidential election. He ruled that any felon poor enough to have been given a court-appointed attorney should be allowed to vote. And any felon who had their financial obligations converted to civil liens — which nearly always happens — must be allowed to vote as well, he ruled.

Hinkle also required the state to allow felons to fill out a form attesting that they can’t afford to pay. State officials were abiding by that requirement, but that, too, was struck down with the appellate court’s order. It’s unclear how felons are supposed to register.

A spokeswoman for Hillsborough County Elections Supervisor Craig Latimer, who is also president of the Florida Supervisors of Elections, deferred comment to state officials about how the order will play out.

“The Division of Elections should be able to provide you with an answer regarding process,” spokeswoman Gerri Kramer wrote in an email. “As the litigation is ongoing, we cannot provide comment but will, of course, respect and abide by the final decision of the courts regarding this issue.”

Mark Gaber, director of litigation at Campaign Legal Center, which is representing several felons in their case against the state, said he expects the 11th Circuit appellate judges to hear the case and rule on it before November’s election.

“It would be quite remarkable to slow-roll it,” Gaber said. “I imagine the court will move quickly.”

Earlier this year, a smaller panel of 11th Circuit appellate judges sided with Hinkle in a separate decision on the case. Gaber said he was confident the larger panel would uphold Hinkle’s ruling.

“This is like a bedrock principle of constitutional law that you can’t hinge someone’s rights on whether they have money in their pocketbook, so I think at the end of the day, the court will see that,” he said.


©2020 Miami Herald

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

State News

Spanberger Secures $1.2 Million for Virginia Health Workforce Development
Spanberger Secures $1.2 Million for Virginia Health Workforce Development
August 10, 2020
by Reece Nations

Rep. Abigail Spanberger, D-Va., announced Monday the acquisition of $1.2 million in federal grant funds for the Virginia Health Workforce Development Authority’s recruitment efforts, continuing education and health care workforce development. The VHWDA grant will be issued to the organization’s network of Area Health Education Centers,... Read More

States Wary of Trump’s Move for Them to Kick in on Federal Aid
States Wary of Trump’s Move for Them to Kick in on Federal Aid

A day after President Donald Trump took executive action to offer $400 per week in supplemental unemployment benefits, including 25% he said should be kicked in from state coffers, governors are pushing back. The leaders of states including New York and Michigan said Trump’s plan ignores... Read More

City of Albany Sponsors Socially Distant Street Fairs All Summer
City of Albany Sponsors Socially Distant Street Fairs All Summer
August 7, 2020
by Sara Wilkerson

ALBANY, N.Y. – The city of Albany has initiated a traveling street fair for residents to socialize at a distance and to learn about local resources. The street fair, called Playstreets, was started last month and its next fair will take place on August 14.  Among... Read More

New York AG Sues to Dissolve National Rifle Association
State News
New York AG Sues to Dissolve National Rifle Association
August 6, 2020
by Gracie Kreth

ALBANY, N.Y. - New York Attorney General Letitia James filed a lawsuit against the National Rifle Association Thursday. The lawsuit calls to dissolve the country’s largest pro-gun organization alleging years of corruption and leadership’s personal use of millions of dollars in donations to the organization. “The... Read More

Inslee Advances in Washington Gubernatorial Primary
Political News
Inslee Advances in Washington Gubernatorial Primary

OLYMPIA, Wash. (AP) — Democratic Gov. Jay Inslee advanced Tuesday in Washington's primary election as he seeks to become the first incumbent elected to a third term in the state in more than 40 years. Inslee was leading decisively in early returns. He’ll face a small-town... Read More

Districts Go Round and Round on School Bus Reopening Plans
Districts Go Round and Round on School Bus Reopening Plans

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — School districts nationwide puzzling over how to safely educate children during a pandemic have a more immediate challenge — getting 26 million bus-riding students there in the first place. Few challenges are proving to be more daunting than figuring out how to... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top