Analysis: Mostly Smoke, and Little Fire, From Republicans to Democrats on Impeachment

October 8, 2019by Nathan L. Gonzales
US President Donald Trump speaks to the press as he departs the White House in Washington, DC, for his annual visit to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, on October 4, 2019. (Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/Getty Images/TNS)

WASHINGTON — Republicans are publicly celebrating impeachment as a political boon and trying to hold House Democrats’ feet to the fire with television ads and protests. But without credible challengers, it’s little more than expensive hot air.

Last week, President Donald Trump’s campaign manager bragged about turning up the heat on a freshman Democrat who supports an impeachment inquiry, and the Republican National Committee is on television targeting a dozen Democratic members for supporting one. But in most instances, there’s a lot of smoke and little fire, considering Republicans are still searching for credible candidates in many of the districts.

“Trump supporters out big league to tell Representative @RepHaleyStevens that she made a big mistake. Her re-election chances just went down the drain,” tweeted Trump manager Brad Parscale about the Democratic congresswoman from Michigan’s 11th District.

Between protesters and the RNC’s ad buy in a district Trump carried in 2016, that sounds like quite a threat. But it’s terrible political analysis from the person in charge of getting the president reelected. Through June 30, Republicans did not have a challenger who raised any money while Stevens had $1.1 million. So it’s hard to see how the congresswoman is in danger of losing next November.

Third quarter Federal Election Commission reports are due Oct. 15, so it’s possible that we will soon learn about a challenger that has raised big money in July, August and September. But that’s unlikely.

Obviously the lack of a candidate didn’t stop the RNC from rolling out slight variations of the same TV ad in 13 districts.

“Elaine Luria promised she’d tackle problems facing our country,” the narrator says in the ad aired in the Norfolk, Va., media market, according to Kantar/CMAG. “Luria broke her promise. Instead of fixing health care and lowering drug prices, Luria votes with the radicals for endless investigations of President Trump — wasting tax dollars.

“Instead of working to create more jobs, Luria wants more hearings. Tell Elaine Luria, put petty politics aside and start getting things done,” concludes the ad, which is similar across the districts, just with a different member and a couple different grainy pictures.

But Republicans lack a credible candidate in eight of the 13 targeted districts, including those represented by Stevens and Luria, as well as Minnesota’s 2nd (represented by Angie Craig), Michigan’s 8th (Elissa Slotkin), New York’s 19th (Antonio Delgado), New Hampshire’s 1st (Chris Pappas), Pennsylvania’s 8th (Matt Cartwright), Nevada’s 3rd (Susie Lee) and Illinois’ 17th (Cheri Bustos, who is also chairwoman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.)

The fundraising discrepancies are sharp. For example, Craig had $701,000 in the bank at the end of June while former Michigan state Rep. Rick Olson had nothing. Slotkin had more than $1 million at the end of June (and self-reported that she had $1.65 million at the end of September) while Republicans wait for former Rep. Mike Bishop to decide whether he’ll run. And Bustos had $2.3 million cash on June 30 as none of her GOP challengers had any money at the same time.

There was also another curious choice among the initial RNC targets: Iowa Democrat Dave Loebsack. He announced in April that he will not seek reelection, so he would seem to be immune from attacks on his voting record.

Since the filing deadlines have not passed, there’s still time for candidates to enter these races, raise money and mount serious challenges. But the ads and district level protests would have been a lot more effective if there were already well-financed challengers breathing down the necks of these incumbents.


©2019 CQ-Roll Call, Inc., All Rights Reserved

Visit CQ Roll Call at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


Democrats’ Hope for Quick Impeachment is Looking a Bit More Complicated Impeachment
Democrats’ Hope for Quick Impeachment is Looking a Bit More Complicated

WASHINGTON — House Democrats’ hopes for a short and focused impeachment inquiry against President Donald Trump are being put to the test by a string of new leads that could lengthen their investigation, as well as by some moderate Democrats who remain skeptical about whether the... Read More

Mulvaney Says Trump Held Aid to Prod Ukraine Impeachment
Mulvaney Says Trump Held Aid to Prod Ukraine

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump withheld roughly $400 million in aid to Ukraine earlier this year in part to pressure its new government to investigate Democrats, acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney said Thursday, a stunning confirmation that hits directly at the center of... Read More

Pelosi Considers, Then Rejects Holding House Vote on Impeachment Inquiry In The News
Pelosi Considers, Then Rejects Holding House Vote on Impeachment Inquiry

WASHINGTON — Amid growing political pressure from Republicans, House leaders on Tuesday began seriously gauging support among Democrats for holding a vote to formally establish the impeachment investigation of President Donald Trump — even through the inquiry is already underway. But by the end of the... Read More

Schiff Says Secret Testimony Aimed at Keeping Trump in The Dark Impeachment
Schiff Says Secret Testimony Aimed at Keeping Trump in The Dark

WASHINGTON — House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff defended holding testimony behind closed doors in the impeachment inquiry he’s heading up against President Donald Trump, likening this phase of the investigation to a “grand jury.” “We want to make sure that we meet the needs of... Read More

Two Giuliani Associates Subpoenaed in House Impeachment Inquiry Impeachment
Two Giuliani Associates Subpoenaed in House Impeachment Inquiry
October 10, 2019
by Dan McCue

WASHINGTON - Two Russian-born associates of President Donald Trump's personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, were subpoenaed in the House impeachment inquiry just hours after their arrests on campaign finance charges. Lev Parnas and Igor Fruman have been tied to efforts by Giuliani to get Ukraine to investigate... Read More

Italy’s Spy Chief Met Twice With Barr to Aid Inquiry: Repubblica Foreign Affairs
Italy’s Spy Chief Met Twice With Barr to Aid Inquiry: Repubblica

ROME — Italy’s spy chief Gennaro Vecchione met twice in August with U.S. Attorney General William Barr and prosecutor John Durham to help an investigation into the scandal involving President Donald Trump’s possible ties to Russia, one of Italy’s leading newspapers reported. The first meeting took... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top