Senate Wants More Oversight of Dangerous Biological Research

August 4, 2022 by Tom Ramstack
Senate Wants More Oversight of Dangerous Biological Research
Wuhan Institute of Virology. (Wikimedia Commons)

WASHINGTON — Scientists revived suspicions Wednesday that COVID-19 escaped from a Chinese lab during a Senate hearing where lawmakers discussed methods for preventing additional pandemics.

Their main concern was “gain-of-function” methods that biochemists discovered about 20 years ago. Gain-of-function refers to medical research that alters the genetic structure of organisms to enhance their biological activity.

The scientists who testified at the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee hearing described it as inexpensive and potentially more lethal than any nuclear bomb.

“It’s just hard to think why you would ever want to do this when you consider the misuse potential,” said Kevin M. Esvelt, a Massachusetts Institute of Technology assistant professor of media arts and sciences.

Much of the skepticism about Chinese assertions COVID-19 originated from human contact with sick bats focuses on genetic mutations in the virus that some scientists say could not be explained as a natural phenomenon.

“As soon as you make a change that does not occur in nature, then it becomes dangerous,” Esvelt said.

The Wuhan Institute of Virology is one of the world’s leading organizations for gain-of-function research. COVID-19 is known to have started in Wuhan, China.

“These are asymmetric tools of mass death,” Esvelt said about gain-of-function techniques.

Other gain-of-function research has been performed at American universities under National Institutes of Health grants, usually with a goal of disease prevention and cures. Typically, the researchers study strains of influenza and severe acute respiratory syndrome.

A committee within the NIH holds primary responsibility for determining whether the projects are worthwhile and safe.

Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., who chaired the Homeland Security Committee hearing Wednesday, said more than a million American deaths from COVID-19 show better oversight of gain-of-function is needed.

“I think it was from a lab leak,” Paul said about the virus.

He recommended that Congress develop legislation that would set up a more robust method for reviewing any projects authorized for gain-of-function research. The current system lacks transparency and is administered by the same people participating in the research, Paul said.

“We want better oversight of this,” he said.

Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis., asked about a chain of events leading to the COVID-19 pandemic that some scientists said cast doubt on Chinese assertions the virus escaped from an open-air market in November or December 2019 where bats were sold for meat.

The events included the fact the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s database for its gain-of-function research was taken offline at 2 a.m. on Sept. 12, 2019. In addition, genetic material that mimicked the kinds of genes found in COVID-19 was being used in research at the lab but some scientific investigators said they were denied complete access to the evidence.

“Obviously, mum’s the word,” Johnson said.

He also questioned the integrity of scientists who do gain-of-function research for the easy access to grants and publications it offers.

“I just find that sick,” Johnson said.

Tom can be reached at [email protected] and @TomRamstack

A+
a-
  • biological research
  • oversight
  • Senate
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Science

    What's Pi Day All About? Math, Science, Pies and More

    Math enthusiasts around the world, from college kids to rocket scientists, celebrate Pi Day on Thursday, which is March 14... Read More

    Math enthusiasts around the world, from college kids to rocket scientists, celebrate Pi Day on Thursday, which is March 14 or 3/14 — the first three digits of an infinite number with many practical uses. Around the world many people will mark the day with a... Read More

    Plan for $400M Monkey-Breeding Facility in SW Georgia Draws Protest

    BAINBRIDGE, Ga. (AP) — Some local residents and an animal-rights group are protesting plans for a monkey-breeding facility in southwest... Read More

    BAINBRIDGE, Ga. (AP) — Some local residents and an animal-rights group are protesting plans for a monkey-breeding facility in southwest Georgia. Opponents on Tuesday urged the Bainbridge City Council to block plans by a company called Safer Human Medicine to build a $396 million complex that... Read More

    First US Lunar Lander in Over 50 Years Launched but Problem Develops on Way to Moon

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) — The first U.S. lunar lander in more than 50 years rocketed to space Monday, launching... Read More

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) — The first U.S. lunar lander in more than 50 years rocketed to space Monday, launching a race for private companies to deliver experiments and other items to the moon. But about seven hours after liftoff, Astrobotic Technology reported the solar panel... Read More

    France's Macron Says Melting Glaciers 'Unprecedented Challenge for Humanity'

    PARIS (AP) — Melting glaciers are an “unprecedented challenge for humanity,” French President Emmanuel Macron said on Friday, as he launched a... Read More

    PARIS (AP) — Melting glaciers are an “unprecedented challenge for humanity,” French President Emmanuel Macron said on Friday, as he launched a call for nations to work together on slashing planet-warming emissions, protecting the environment and collaborating on scientific research into the Earth's icy ecosystems. Such a united... Read More

    AI Raises Fears About Risks to Humanity. Are Tech and Political Leaders Doing Enough?

    LONDON (AP) — Chatbots like ChatGPT wowed the world with their ability to write speeches, plan vacations or hold a conversation as good... Read More

    LONDON (AP) — Chatbots like ChatGPT wowed the world with their ability to write speeches, plan vacations or hold a conversation as good as or arguably even better than humans do, thanks to cutting-edge artificial intelligence systems. Now, frontier AI has become the latest buzzword as concerns grow that... Read More

    October 23, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    AI Seen as Key to Planning Climate Change-Related Hazard Mitigation

    PASADENA, Calif. — As demand for more detailed assessment of climate risks grows, a team of scientists from around the... Read More

    PASADENA, Calif. — As demand for more detailed assessment of climate risks grows, a team of scientists from around the globe argue for utilizing artificial intelligence to greatly improve the climate simulations that form the basis of hazard mitigation plans. Although we’re all prone to complain... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top