The Most Comprehensive Study Ever Reveals Which are the Greenest ‘Blue Foods’
The lowest-impact label went to farmed bivalves and seaweeds; but there were also some surprises—e.g., wild and farmed salmon have the same footprint

October 13, 2021 by Anthropocene
The Most Comprehensive Study Ever Reveals Which are the Greenest ‘Blue Foods’

This article is by Emma Bryce and was originally published by Anthropocene magazine.


What is the role of fish in a sustainable food future? Compared to other food groups, we have limited knowledge about the environmental impact of blue foods when it comes to greenhouse gas emissions and ecosystem impact. So a team of researchers set out to fill the gap.  They gathered data from almost 7,000 fish farms and 1,000 fishery records about 23 species groups of fish, bivalves, seaweeds, and crustaceans. From this they built life cycle analyses that considered modes of production, land, water, nitrogen and phosphorus use, and emissions impact. The species they looked at collectively accounted for 70% of global blue food production, giving them a useful overall picture of the fishing and aquaculture industry’s environmental impact.  A few key patterns emerged. First, the major source of emissions in aquaculture is the production of feed for the farmed fish. In fact this accounted for a striking 70% of emissions for most farmed fish, most notably flatfish and crustaceans, the researchers found. The footprint is attributable to the land conversion and fertilizers that are needed to produce the feed, which are typically soybeans. This land-based food production also gives farmed fish a relatively high footprint where water use is concerned.  In wild-caught fisheries meanwhile, the primary emissions culprit is fuel-use for boats, especially true for high-seas industrial fleets that may travel long distances to capture fish.  This assessment also revealed which are the ‘greenest’ blue foods to consume. The researchers found that across all fish – farmed and wild-caught—the lowest-impact were farmed bivalves and seaweeds, mainly because they don’t need to be fed. In fact, their self-sufficiency gives them an ecosystem benefit, because shellfish and seaweed can remove nitrogen and phosphorus pollution—usually originating from terrestrial agriculture—from the water. What’s more, bivalves especially have some of the highest nutritional value of all available blue foods, presenting a clear win on all fronts.  The analysis also turned up a few surprising results, such as the fact that farmed shrimp were found to be less impactful than wild-caught. Also, consumers looking to make a difference by eating wild-caught salmon rather than farmed may be squandering their efforts: like trout, this fish had the same footprint whether farmed, or wild-caught.  By highlighting the several weak points in blue food production, the researchers also make it clearer where the opportunities are to make this increasingly influential source of dietary protein more sustainable.  As is often the case with food, the biggest opportunity lies in dietary change—in this instance, increasing our appetite for lower-impact bivalves and seaweeds. But while appetites adapt, there are also many changes to be made to the way we farm and catch fish, too.  The clearest opportunity there lies in feed. Crucially, finding ways to increase the feed conversion ratio (using less feed, more efficiently, to produce more fish) would bring substantial benefits. The researchers estimate that reducing the amount of feed applied in aquaculture by 10% could reduce all the associated environmental stressors of feeding fish—land use, water use, emissions—by between 1 and 24%.  If fish farms also switched to feed sourced from deforestation-free farms, emissions associated with feeding fish would drop by up to 50%. Beyond that, alternative feed sources like insect meals and algae, also hold a lot of potential to bring impacts down.  For open-ocean fisheries, where fuel use is the major concern, switching to more efficient gears (like trawl nets) that results in less fuel use, could lead to emissions reductions of up to 61%—and potentially limit ecosystem damage as well. Getting vessels to use low-emission fuels is another route, though that solution is still on a relatively distant horizon, the researchers say. Ultimately, these changes will require time, policy interventions, and ideally subsidies to support more sustainable forms of blue food production. But unlike terrestrial agriculture, whose damage is so far-gone that we need to unpick it, with blue foods the good news is that we have the chance to intervene now and curb the damage before it reaches its peak—especially in aquaculture, because it’s still a developing industry. 

“The global community now faces a unique window of opportunity to steer expansion towards sustainability,” the researchers say.


Anthropocene magazine, published by Future Earth,  gathers the worlds’ best minds to explore how we might create a Human Age that we actually want to live in. 

Emma Bryce is a journalist based in London. As well as Anthropocene, her work has appeared in The Guardian, Wired Magazine UK, Audubon Magazine, The New York Times, Ensia, and Yale e360.


Source: Gephart et. al. “Environmental performance of blue foods.” Nature. 2021.

A+
a-

In The News

Health

Voting

Food

March 19, 2024
by Jesse Zucker
Spring Has Sprung! Time to Try These Seasonal Foods

WASHINGTON — March 19 marks the first day of spring. We have more hours of daylight, slowly rising temperatures and... Read More

WASHINGTON — March 19 marks the first day of spring. We have more hours of daylight, slowly rising temperatures and flowers beginning to bloom. With the winter frost (hopefully) behind us, certain fruits and vegetables are at their peak.  Eating seasonally can be a fun and... Read More

Fewer Fish and More Algae? Scientists Seek to Understand Impacts of Historic Lack of Great Lakes Ice

RACINE, Wis. (AP) — Michigan Tech University biologists have been observing a remote Lake Superior island's fragile wolf population every... Read More

RACINE, Wis. (AP) — Michigan Tech University biologists have been observing a remote Lake Superior island's fragile wolf population every winter since 1958, but they had to cut this season's planned seven-week survey short after just two weeks. The ski plane they study the wolves from... Read More

Candy Companies Pitch Gum as Stress Reliever and Concentration Aid to Revive Stale Sales

Candy companies want to know: What will make Americans start chewing gum again? Gum’s bubble burst during the COVID-19 pandemic, when masks... Read More

Candy companies want to know: What will make Americans start chewing gum again? Gum’s bubble burst during the COVID-19 pandemic, when masks and social distancing made bad breath less of a worry and fewer people spent on impulse buys. The number of packages of gum sold dropped by nearly a... Read More

January 22, 2024
by Jesse Zucker
Do You Need to Cut Carbs to Be Healthy?

WASHINGTON — Over the years, diet trends have come and gone. Every few decades, a new macronutrient becomes a villain.... Read More

WASHINGTON — Over the years, diet trends have come and gone. Every few decades, a new macronutrient becomes a villain. Low-fat and fat-free products were once all the rage. Next, we moved into Atkin’s, keto, and paleo diets — all with one thing in common: cutting... Read More

CDC Expands Warning About Charcuterie Meat Trays as Salmonella Cases Double

AP — Federal health officials are expanding a warning about salmonella poisoning tied to charcuterie meat snack trays sold at Sam's... Read More

AP — Federal health officials are expanding a warning about salmonella poisoning tied to charcuterie meat snack trays sold at Sam's Club and Costco stores. At least 47 people in 22 states have been sickened and 10 people have been hospitalized after eating Busseto brand and Fratelli... Read More

Advocacy Groups Are Petitioning for the End of SNAP Interview Requirements

NEW YORK (AP) — Student and legal advocacy groups are petitioning the U.S. Department of Agriculture to lift the interview... Read More

NEW YORK (AP) — Student and legal advocacy groups are petitioning the U.S. Department of Agriculture to lift the interview requirement for Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) applicants to receive food aid. The groups argue the interview requirement is burdensome and prevents those who qualify for food aid from receiving... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top