Employers Grapple with Religious Exemptions Claims for Vaccine Mandates

September 22, 2021 by Alexa Hornbeck
Employers Grapple with Religious Exemptions Claims for Vaccine Mandates
In this Jan. 6, 2021, photo, His Eminence Archbishop Elpidophoros, Primate of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America throws a cross into Spring Bayou during the 115th year of the annual Epiphany celebration in Tarpon Springs, Fla. Leaders of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America said this week “there is no exemption in the Orthodox Church for Her faithful from any vaccination for religious reasons.” Greek Orthodox Archbishop Elpidophoros added: “No clergy are to issue such religious exemption letters,” and any such letter “is not valid.” (Douglas R. Clifford/Tampa Bay Times via AP)

The Biden administration announced vaccine mandates that will affect employers with over 100 employees, and now religious exemption requests are pouring in from those who claim that a sincerely held belief keeps them from receiving a vaccine. 

“The minute after the president announced the new mandate, many governors announced they were going to court. I think there will be substantial litigation based on claims of religious liberty. We haven’t seen the exact language of the regulation, and we don’t exactly know what it will say, but it will allow for testing in lieu of vaccinations,” said Wendy Parmet, professor of Law and professor of Public Policy and Urban Affairs at Northeastern University in Boston, Massachusetts.

Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act gives workers the right to seek an exception to a vaccination mandate based on their religious beliefs. 

The administration’s vaccine mandate offers employers the option to allow employees who request a medical or religious exemption to take routine COVID-19 testing instead of receiving a vaccine.

However, employers do not necessarily have to provide a religious exemption. A Supreme Court decision from 1977, known as TWA v. Hardison, gives an employer the ability to deny a religious exemption if it imposes a large burden on daily operations. 

There is no standard or universal definition for religious exemptions, and they have typically been applied to vaccines required for school or daycare entry, and not workplace requirements.

“Most established religions have no objections to vaccinations in general, particularly the COVID-19 vaccine,” said Parmet.

In fact, many religions have clear positions supporting vaccination, including Catholicism, Jehovah’s Witness, Judaism, Buddhism, and Hinduism.

The only known religion to technically oppose vaccinations is the Church of Christian Scientists, who believe in spiritual healing and frequently deny some or all medical help for disease.

“Someone can have a sincere religious objection to vaccines even if it’s not consistent with an established religious doctrine. The test is a sincerity test, not about orthodoxy,” said Parmet.

“If the employer applies the test too strictly, they can get into constitutional or statutory trouble, as they could be denying someone who has a right to the exemption. But if anyone can get the exemption, then they have a loophole. Therein lies the problem,” said Parmet.

Employers review the religious exemption requests to identify whether the claim is sincere, which may depend on the rules for each state. 

All states except California, Maine, Mississippi, New York, and West Virginia offer non-medical exemptions for religious and philosophical reasons.

In Maine, nine employees are suing the state to demand a religious exemption as it is not currently allowed in the state.

In New York, seventeen health professionals are suing the state because the mandate does not include the option of religious exemption. 

Last week, a federal judge issued a restraining order to block the New York State Department of Health from interfering with employers granting religious exemptions to its vaccine mandate. 

The ruling is one of many legal actions that will set the stage for how employers should handle faith-based claims for vaccine exemption and government mandates. 

“Courts have consistently upheld the decision by states such as California or New York to get rid of religious exemptions. What is different now is, on one hand, we have a new Supreme Court that is very supportive of religious liberty, and the second is we can’t forget that everything relating to COVID-19 has become so politicized and controversial, and I see that playing out in all the litigation being brought up right now,” said Parmet.

United Airlines also recently sent an internal memo to employees that those who work in customer-facing jobs need to be vaccinated or they will be terminated. 

Even in cases where religious exemption is approved, the United employee would still be put on a temporary, unpaid personal leave without a testing option.

While an employer not providing a COVID-19 testing accommodation might seem to violate the Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s temporary standards for vaccine mandates, United Airlines may have a legal defense under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act from 2014.

The law allowed Hobby Lobby to deny contraception health care coverage based on religious objections from the employers.

“An employer could say that the mandate violates the religious freedom act and that the regulation, depending upon what it says, provides no accommodation for their religious objections,” said Parmet.

A+
a-
  • COVID-19
  • religious exemptions
  • vaccines
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Religion

    January 29, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    HHS Civil Rights Office Issues Guidance on Religious Non-Discrimination

    WASHINGTON — The Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights has issued guidance to U.S. hospital and... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights has issued guidance to U.S. hospital and long-term care facility administrators, reminding them of their facility’s obligation not to discriminate on the basis of religion. The warning comes at a tense time across... Read More

    Great Basin Tribes Want Bahsahwahbee Massacre Site in Nevada Named National Monument

    ELY, Nev. (AP) — White attackers turned a lush, high desert oasis in eastern Nevada, with its bubbling springs and... Read More

    ELY, Nev. (AP) — White attackers turned a lush, high desert oasis in eastern Nevada, with its bubbling springs and a rare stand of Rocky Mountain junipers, into killing fields. They massacred hundreds of Native people there in the 1800s — a horrific history once retold... Read More

    Native Hawaiian Salt Makers Combat Climate Change and Pollution to Protect a Sacred Tradition

    HANAPEPE, Hawaii (AP) — On a warm summer afternoon, Tina Taniguchi was on her hands and knees scraping dirt off... Read More

    HANAPEPE, Hawaii (AP) — On a warm summer afternoon, Tina Taniguchi was on her hands and knees scraping dirt off an oblong depression in the ground. Thick brown hair peeked out from her coconut leaf hat. Splotches of mud stuck to her T-shirt and speckled her... Read More

    November 14, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supporters of Israel Caution Against Rising Antisemitism

    WASHINGTON — A backlash against the antisemitism that erupted since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel showed itself during... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A backlash against the antisemitism that erupted since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel showed itself during a congressional hearing and a demonstration in Washington, D.C., Tuesday. During a House Education and the Workforce subcommittee hearing, lawmakers and witnesses described college campuses as... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Maryland Law Against Sexual Abuse Threatens Trouble for Catholic Church

    A Maryland law that waives the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse takes effect next week, creating potential legal... Read More

    A Maryland law that waives the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse takes effect next week, creating potential legal liabilities for the Catholic Archdioceses of Washington and Baltimore. For the Washington archdiocese — which includes the Maryland suburbs — the risk results from revelations its... Read More

    Pope Says 'Backward' US Conservatives Have Replaced Faith With Ideology

    ROME (AP) — Pope Francis has blasted the “backwardness” of some conservatives in the U.S. Catholic Church, saying they have... Read More

    ROME (AP) — Pope Francis has blasted the “backwardness” of some conservatives in the U.S. Catholic Church, saying they have replaced faith with ideology and that a correct understanding of Catholic doctrine allows for change over time. Francis’ comments were an acknowledgment of the divisions in... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top