Facebook Notifications Are Not Akin to Robocalls

April 1, 2021 by Dan McCue
Facebook Notifications Are Not Akin to Robocalls

WASHINGTON – A unanimous Supreme Court sided with Facebook on Thursday, ruling that a notification system the social media giant employs to alert users to suspicious logins does not run afoul of a federal law aimed at curbing robocalls and automated text messages.

The case revolved around the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, which restricts calls by “an automatic telephone dialing system.”

The respondent in the case, Noah Dugui began receiving alerts on his telephone telling him his account was compromised, despite the fact he’d never created a Facebook account.

After he tried without success to stop the unwanted messages, he filed a class action against the social media giant, alleging it violated the TCPA by maintaining a database that stored phone numbers and programming its equipment to send automated text messages.

Facebook countered by arguing the TCPA does not apply because the technology it used to text Duguid did not use a “random or sequential number generator,” one of the technologies the Act was specifically created to address.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed, holding the Act applies to notification systems like those employed at Facebook because its technology has the capacity to dial automatically stored numbers.

Writing for the court, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said to  qualify as an “automatic telephone dialing system” under the TCPA, a device must have the capacity either to store a telephone number using a random or sequential number generator, or to produce a telephone number using a random or sequential number generator. 

“The statutory context confirms that the TCPA’s autodialer definition excludes equipment that does not use a random or sequential number generator,” she continued, adding “Facebook’s interpretation of [the statute] better matches the scope of the TCPA to these concerns.”

Sotomayor went on to say that none of Duguid’s counterarguments overcame the ”clear commands” of the statute’s text and broaden context.”

“It would make little sense however, to classify as autodialers all equipment with the capacity to store and dial telephone numbers, including virtually all modern cell phones,” she wrote.

Further, she said, Duguid over-broadly construed the TCPA’s privacy-protection goals.

“Despite Congress’ general concern about intrusive telemarketing practices, Congress ultimately chose a precise autodialer definition,” the justice noted.

“Finally, Duguid argues that a random or sequential number generator is a ‘senescent technology,’ i.e., one likely to become outdated quickly,” Sotomayor said. “That may or may not be the case, but either way, this Court cannot rewrite the TCPA to update it for modern technology. Congress’ chosen definition of an autodialer requires that the equipment in question must use a random or sequential number generator. That definition excludes equipment like Facebook’s login notification system, which does not use such technology.”

In a concurring opinion, Justice Samuel Alito Jr. spends most of his time talking about words and how they are interpreted.

“Appellate judges spend virtually every working hour speaking, listening to, reading, or writing English prose,” he writes. “Statutes are written in English prose, and interpretation is

not a technical exercise to be carried out by mechanically applying a set of arcane rules.

“Canons of interpretation can help in figuring out the meaning of troublesome statutory

language, but if they are treated like rigid rules, they can lead us astray. When this Court describes canons as rules or quotes canons while omitting their caveats and limitations, we only encourage the lower courts to relegate statutory interpretation to a series of if-then computations. No reasonable reader interprets texts that way,” Alito said.

A+
a-
  • Facebook
  • Noah Dugui
  • robocalls
  • Supreme Court
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Social Media

    A Supreme Court Ruling in a Social Media Case Could Set Standards for Free Speech in the Digital Age

    WASHINGTON (AP) — In a busy term that could set standards for free speech in the digital age, the Supreme... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — In a busy term that could set standards for free speech in the digital age, the Supreme Court on Monday is taking up a dispute between Republican-led states and the Biden administration over how far the federal government can go to combat controversial social... Read More

    House Passes Bill That Would Lead to TikTok Ban if Chinese Owner Doesn't Sell. Senate Path Unclear

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The House on Wednesday passed a bill that would lead to a nationwide ban of the popular video app... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — The House on Wednesday passed a bill that would lead to a nationwide ban of the popular video app TikTok if its China-based owner doesn't sell, as lawmakers acted on concerns that the company's current ownership structure is a national security threat. The bill, passed by... Read More

    Fake Images Made to Show Trump With Black Supporters Highlight Concerns Around AI and Elections

    WASHINGTON (AP) — At first glance, images circulating online showing former President Donald Trump surrounded by groups of Black people... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — At first glance, images circulating online showing former President Donald Trump surrounded by groups of Black people smiling and laughing seem nothing out of the ordinary, but a look closer is telling. Odd lighting and too-perfect details provide clues to the fact they... Read More

    Florida Lawmakers Prepare for Gov. DeSantis to Veto Social Media Ban on Children Under 16

    TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) — Florida lawmakers were bracing for Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis to veto a bill banning social media... Read More

    TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) — Florida lawmakers were bracing for Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis to veto a bill banning social media for children under 16 on Friday and finding a way to make him more comfortable with its language before their session ends next week. DeSantis supports... Read More

    Russian Disinformation Is About Immigration. The Real Aim Is to Undercut Ukraine Aid

    WASHINGTON (AP) — For Vladimir Putin, victory in Ukraine may run through Texas' Rio Grande Valley. In recent weeks, Russian... Read More

    WASHINGTON (AP) — For Vladimir Putin, victory in Ukraine may run through Texas' Rio Grande Valley. In recent weeks, Russian state media and online accounts tied to the Kremlin have spread and amplified misleading and incendiary content about U.S. immigration and border security. The campaign seems... Read More

    February 26, 2024
    by Tom Ramstack
    States Try to Convince Supreme Court to Keep Laws Regulating Social Media

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed skeptical Monday of two state laws that could redraw social media companies’ right to... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed skeptical Monday of two state laws that could redraw social media companies’ right to decide what sort of content is displayed on their platforms. The tech companies say the Florida and Texas laws that seek to limit which content they... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top