Supreme Court Rejects Challenge to Limits on Church Services

June 2, 2020 by Dan McCue
Supreme Court Rejects Challenge to Limits on Church Services
Worshiping from home still being recommended as the coronavirus pandemic wanes in some communities. (Photo by Dan McCue)

WASHINGTON – A divided Supreme Court rejected an emergency appeal by a California church challenging state limits on attendance at worship services imposed to contain the spread of the coronavirus.

Chief Justice John Roberts joined the court’s four liberals late Friday night in turning away a request from the South Bay United Pentecostal Church in Chula Vista, California, in the San Diego area.

The church and Bishop Arthur Hodges III were represented by the Thomas More Society, a national not-for-profit law firm, which had initially objected to California Gov. Gavin Newsom deeming churches “nonessential” and requiring them to close during the coronavirus pandemic.

After the case was submitted to the high court, Newsom pulled back, changing his ban to what the plaintiffs said was an arbitrary cap on the number of people allowed to gather at a church.

Attorney Charles LiMandri, serving as special counsel to the Thomas More Society, argued in legal briefs that limits on how many people can attend their services violate constitutional guarantees of religious freedom and had been seeking an order in time for services this past Sunday.

But a majority of the justices were unconvinced.

Roberts wrote in brief opinion that the restriction allowing churches to reopen at 25% of their capacity, with no more than 100 worshipers at a time, “appears consistent” with the First Amendment.

The chief justice also noted that similar or more severe limits apply to concerts, movies and sporting events “where large groups of people gather in close proximity for extended periods of time.”

In a stinging dissent, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that the restriction upheld by the majority, “discriminates against places of worship and in favor of comparable secular businesses. Such discrimination violates the First Amendment.”

Kavanaugh went on to point to supermarkets, restaurants, hair salons, cannabis dispensaries and other businesses that are not subject to the same restrictions.

Lower courts in California had previously turned down the churches’ requests.

The court also rejected an appeal from two churches in the Chicago area that objected to Gov. Jay Pritzker’s limit of 10 worshipers at religious services.

However, Pritzker had already modified the restrictions to allow for up to 100 people at a time before the court acted.

“The disappointing ruling in the U.S. Supreme Court was a close 5-4 vote, based on the very high standards required for obtaining an emergency injunction on appeal,” LiMandri said after the ruling was handed down.

“This case is far from over,” the attorney continued. “Our next appellate brief is due in the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on June 5. If it is necessary to go back up to the U.S. Supreme Court after the Ninth Circuit rules again, we will benefit from a much more favorable standard. We are hopeful that fact would also lead to a better result for religious liberty.”

A+
a-
  • religion
  • Supreme Court
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    Religion

    January 29, 2024
    by Dan McCue
    HHS Civil Rights Office Issues Guidance on Religious Non-Discrimination

    WASHINGTON — The Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights has issued guidance to U.S. hospital and... Read More

    WASHINGTON — The Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights has issued guidance to U.S. hospital and long-term care facility administrators, reminding them of their facility’s obligation not to discriminate on the basis of religion. The warning comes at a tense time across... Read More

    Great Basin Tribes Want Bahsahwahbee Massacre Site in Nevada Named National Monument

    ELY, Nev. (AP) — White attackers turned a lush, high desert oasis in eastern Nevada, with its bubbling springs and... Read More

    ELY, Nev. (AP) — White attackers turned a lush, high desert oasis in eastern Nevada, with its bubbling springs and a rare stand of Rocky Mountain junipers, into killing fields. They massacred hundreds of Native people there in the 1800s — a horrific history once retold... Read More

    Native Hawaiian Salt Makers Combat Climate Change and Pollution to Protect a Sacred Tradition

    HANAPEPE, Hawaii (AP) — On a warm summer afternoon, Tina Taniguchi was on her hands and knees scraping dirt off... Read More

    HANAPEPE, Hawaii (AP) — On a warm summer afternoon, Tina Taniguchi was on her hands and knees scraping dirt off an oblong depression in the ground. Thick brown hair peeked out from her coconut leaf hat. Splotches of mud stuck to her T-shirt and speckled her... Read More

    November 14, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Supporters of Israel Caution Against Rising Antisemitism

    WASHINGTON — A backlash against the antisemitism that erupted since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel showed itself during... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A backlash against the antisemitism that erupted since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel showed itself during a congressional hearing and a demonstration in Washington, D.C., Tuesday. During a House Education and the Workforce subcommittee hearing, lawmakers and witnesses described college campuses as... Read More

    September 29, 2023
    by Tom Ramstack
    Maryland Law Against Sexual Abuse Threatens Trouble for Catholic Church

    A Maryland law that waives the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse takes effect next week, creating potential legal... Read More

    A Maryland law that waives the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse takes effect next week, creating potential legal liabilities for the Catholic Archdioceses of Washington and Baltimore. For the Washington archdiocese — which includes the Maryland suburbs — the risk results from revelations its... Read More

    Pope Says 'Backward' US Conservatives Have Replaced Faith With Ideology

    ROME (AP) — Pope Francis has blasted the “backwardness” of some conservatives in the U.S. Catholic Church, saying they have... Read More

    ROME (AP) — Pope Francis has blasted the “backwardness” of some conservatives in the U.S. Catholic Church, saying they have replaced faith with ideology and that a correct understanding of Catholic doctrine allows for change over time. Francis’ comments were an acknowledgment of the divisions in... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top