4 Automakers Reach Emissions Deal With California, Bucking Rollback

July 26, 2019by Eric D. Lawrence

Ford, Volkswagen, BMW and Honda have reached a deal with California to increase gas mileage standards and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, setting a national standard, a longtime auto industry goal.

The deal between the four automakers and the California Air Resources Board appears to offer a way around the thorny standoff between the Trump Administration and California over the administration’s push to roll back the standards laid out during the Obama Administration. The fight, however, is expected to continue in the courts despite the deal as the administration works to rewrite the rules. A White House spokesman did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Notably, the deal “recognizes California’s authority” and would increase the average fuel economy of the automakers’ new vehicle fleets to almost 50 mpg by model year 2026. During a conference call Thursday with California Gov. Gavin Newsom and CARB Chair Mary Nichols, officials noted that the Trump Administration’s plan would bring that only to an average of 37 mpg by that time.

The deal would stretch out the timeline for the improvement on the standards by a year from the Obama-era rules and would only apply if the administration follows through on its rewrite, which Newsom indicated has no justification since automakers themselves are willing to abide by more stringent rules.

Newsom called the deal a game changer and said California is asserting itself while reserving its rights to litigate.

“Regardless about what the Trump Administration determines in the next few weeks, this is the direction we’re headed in,” he said.

Newsom praised the four companies’ “significant leadership” and said they deserve “enormous credit.” He said he anticipates additional companies signing on, and the release noted that the deal is available to others.

“Ensuring that America’s vehicles are efficient, safe and affordable is a priority for us all,” the statement said. “A 50-state solution has always been our preferred path forward and we understand that any deal involves compromise. These terms will provide our companies much-needed regulatory certainty by allowing us to meet both federal and state requirements with a single national fleet, avoiding a patchwork of regulations while continuing to ensure meaningful greenhouse gas emissions reductions.”

Honda issued its own statement as well:

“The framework provides regulatory stability, greater environmental benefits and reduced compliance costs. As a leader in producing efficient, low and zero-emission vehicles, Honda believes this is a win for our customers and for the environment.”

The deal follows recent action by automakers to push the administration to reach a deal with broad support from California and other states. Seventeen automakers, including Ford and General Motors, had sent a letter directly to President Donald Trump urging one national standard in hopes of avoiding an extended period of litigation and regulatory uncertainty.

A Fiat Chrysler Automobiles spokesman, however, said the automaker was not invited to participate in the current discussion.

In a statement, FCA said it is committed to improving the fuel economy of its fleet but noted a need to adjust the rules.

“We have been clear throughout the federal rulemaking process that the current standards need to be adjusted to reflect changing conditions in the marketplace, and today’s announcement acknowledges that is true. We look forward to reviewing the details of this agreement, as well as the federal rule later this year,” the FCA statement said.

Those changing conditions involve the relatively low price of gas and the apparent consumer shift away from SUVs and trucks.

Interestingly, the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, which represents three of the automakers in the California deal (Ford, BMW and VW), focused in its reaction on the difficulty of reaching the Obama-era standards.

“Today’s announcement of the framework of an agreement by California and certain automakers acknowledges that the MY2022-2025 standards developed by the Obama administration are not attainable and need to be adjusted. … Individual companies may have different perspectives on how best to achieve greater certainty. A final federal rule regarding future CAFE/GHG standards has yet to be released and automakers continue to seek an optimal pathway forward that meets the diverse needs of our customers while providing environmental improvements, preserving safety and auto jobs and keeping new vehicles affordable for more Americans,” according to the statement.

U.S. Rep. Debbie Dingell, D-Mich., weighed in on the news, calling it positive and saying the industry needs certainty.

“This industry is more fragile than many realize. If the United States is to be competitive, we have to stay at the forefront of innovation and technology, which will help us transition to the next generation of more fuel-efficient vehicles,” Dingell said. “This agreement is a step forward in that direction. I would urge this framework to be a catalyst for all stakeholders to go back to the table. It would be win-win for everyone.”

The anti-pollution advocacy group Moms Clean Air Force praised the deal but questioned why other automakers, Toyota in particular, had not already signed on.

“Moms are delighted that car companies are moving out of the rollback lane and getting America up to speed on mileage and fuel economy. We have one question though: where is Toyota USA? They should be part of this deal, showing leadership — as they know how to make fuel efficient cars — instead of hanging back,” according to Dominique Browning, co-founder and senior director of the organization.

The entire process might be a case of “be careful what you wish for.”

Industry analyst Jeremy Acevedo of Edmunds told the Free Press last month that automakers may have “bit off more than they could chew” when they asked Trump to reconsider Obama-era CAFE standards.

“While automakers may not want to meet these aggressive targets, at least it’s something they can plan for, as opposed to years of uncertainty waiting out a lengthy court battle,” he said.

Here are the terms of the deal, according to the release:

  • Revised greenhouse gas standards: GHG standards, beginning in the 2022 model year (MY) and extending through the 2026 MY, with increasing stringency at a nationwide average annual rate of 3.7% (year-over-year). Of the 3.7% annual stringency, 1% can be achieved using the advanced technology multiplier credits, below.
  • Appropriate flexibilities to promote zero emission technology: Continue current advanced technology multipliers that now expire after MY 2021, extending them through MY 2024 at the current 2.0x for Battery Electric and Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles (BEV/FCEV), and 1.6x for Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEV), tapering off at the current MY 2020 and MY 2021 levels in MY 2025 and MY 2026, respectively.
  • Simplify accounting: Remove the requirement to account for upstream emissions of fuels, as these can be addressed by other programs.
  • Increase innovation: Raise the current cap on off-cycle menu credits, which account for actions taken outside the formal test cycle framework, from 10 grams per mile to 15 grams per mile starting in MY 2020.
  • Streamlining and process improvements: Improve the off-cycle credit program to facilitate timely review and decision-making regarding the approval of new off-cycle technologies.
  • Recognize California’s authority: Participating companies are choosing to pursue a voluntary agreement in which California accepts these terms as compliance with its program, given its authority, rather than challenge California’s GHG and ZEV programs.


©2019 Detroit Free Press

Visit the Detroit Free Press at www.freep.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

In The News

‘Do Something’: Active Shooter Trainings Teach How to Fight Back Against a Gunman In The News
‘Do Something’: Active Shooter Trainings Teach How to Fight Back Against a Gunman

GOLDEN, Colo. — The gunman paced the hallways of the charter school, passing framed paintings of George Washington and Thomas Jefferson before stopping outside classroom 138. There, he took a deep breath, yanked open the door and began firing. GOLDEN-CO-AUGUST 28, 2019: School resource officer for... Read More

Americans’ Struggles With Medical Bills Are a Foreign Concept in Other Countries Health
Americans’ Struggles With Medical Bills Are a Foreign Concept in Other Countries

GORINCHEM, Netherlands — In France, a visit to the doctor typically costs the equivalent of $1.12. A night in a German hospital costs a patient roughly $11. And in the Netherlands — one of the few wealthy nations other than the U.S. where patients face a... Read More

To Rein in Cities, Texas Tries to Ban Their Lobbying Lobbying
To Rein in Cities, Texas Tries to Ban Their Lobbying

AUSTIN, Texas — The five lobbyists at Focused Advocacy represent more than 20 Texas cities before the legislature. The firm tracked 3,300 municipal-related bills during this year’s 140-day session, and the walls of its downtown Austin offices are decorated with the framed logos of Austin, El... Read More

Health Care: Still Potent, But More Complicated in 2020 Election Health
Health Care: Still Potent, But More Complicated in 2020 Election

ATLANTA — On a recent sweltering August morning, Congresswoman Lucy McBath headlined a rally extolling the Affordable Care Act’s protections for patients. But the freshman Democrat, who represents a fast-changing swath of Atlanta’s northern suburbs, took care not to mention the 9-year-old law’s name from the... Read More

Classes Without Textbooks? More Colleges Are Giving It a Try Education
Classes Without Textbooks? More Colleges Are Giving It a Try

PHILADELPHIA — When Natalie Flynn surveyed students in her Temple University intro to physical geology classes, she found half weren’t buying the textbook she used. Many couldn’t afford it. “We were developing a very, very uneven playing field in the classroom,” she said. Temple University physical... Read More

Emily Clyburn, Activist and Wife of Rep. Jim Clyburn, Dies at 80 Uncategorized
Emily Clyburn, Activist and Wife of Rep. Jim Clyburn, Dies at 80

WASHINGTON — To those unversed in South Carolina politics and civic life, she was the wife of 58 years to Democrat Jim Clyburn, the highest-ranking African American in Congress. To everyone else, she was known, with great reverence, as Ms. Emily — a driving force behind... Read More

Straight From The Well
scroll top