Alito Talks of Abortion Opinion Leak as Decision to Overturn Roe Stays at Forefront for Many Voters

October 26, 2022 by Tom Ramstack
Alito Talks of Abortion Opinion Leak as Decision to Overturn Roe Stays at Forefront for Many Voters
Handmaids protest abortion restrictions at a recent rally. (AP Photo/John O'Connor File)

WASHINGTON — Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito said Tuesday the leak in May of a draft opinion he wrote that removed a constitutional right to abortion endangered the lives of the nine justices.

He called the leak a “betrayal of trust” during a presentation in Washington, D.C., at the conservative Heritage Foundation for public policy.

Alito spoke about the abortion decision at a time it is taking on prominence in debates among political candidates in the days leading to the midterm elections. In California, abortion rights are on the ballot as a constitutional amendment.

“The leak also made those of us who were thought to be in the majority in support of overruling Roe and Casey targets for assassination, because it gave people a rational reason to think they could prevent that from happening by killing one of us,” Alito said.

He was referring to the 1973 Roe v. Wade Supreme Court ruling that established a woman’s right to abortion as a Fourth Amendment constitutional right.

The related 1992 decision in Planned Parenthood v. Casey limited the authority of states to restrict access to abortion.

The Supreme Court overturned both of the rulings in June in its landmark Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision.

A month earlier, someone inside the Supreme Court leaked a draft copy of the Dobbs decision to the news organization Politico, setting off a firestorm of protest from abortion-rights supporters.

When the ruling was released, 13 states responded by immediately banning most abortions. Others are considering similar bans.

Democrats in Congress and President Joe Biden vowed to introduce a federal law that would prevent states from outlawing abortions. They are continuing the pledge, along with conflicts it creates with Republicans, in their campaigns leading to the Nov. 8 midterm elections.

“The U.S. Supreme Court eliminated a national edict which essentially allowed abortion up to the moment of birth, and correctly decided that abortion law should be determined by elected representatives,” Carol Tobias, president of the National Right to Life Committee, told The Well News.

“Naturally, abortion has taken on a larger role in this year’s election because of it. But pro-life people have always been a major force in elections and will be again this year,” she said.

The latest sparring match was Tuesday evening, when Pennsylvania senatorial candidates Mehmet Oz and John Fetterman showed sharp differences of opinion on abortion during a televised debate.

Oz, a celebrity doctor and Republican candidate, said, “I want women, doctors, local political leaders, letting the democracy that’s always allowed our nation to thrive, to put the best ideas forward so states can decide for themselves.” 

In a statement that supported the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, Oz said that “there should not be involvement from the federal government.”

Fetterman, Pennsylvania’s lieutenant governor and the Democratic candidate, said he would “fight to reestablish” the constitutional right to abortion found in the Roe v. Wade decision. 

In California, where voters strongly favor abortion rights, the only remaining issue for the Nov. 8 ballot is how much support they will give a woman’s right to choose.

Popular opinion polls show voters are likely to enshrine abortion rights as a state constitutional amendment under Proposition 1. It would amend California’s constitution “to expressly include an individual’s fundamental right to reproductive freedom, which includes the fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and the fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives.”

In Texas, which was one of the first states to enact a nearly total ban on abortions in June, some political candidates want to allow rape and incest exceptions. State law now allows up to life in prison for abortion providers.

Support for the partial rollback on the abortion ban is even drawing support from a few Texas Republicans. Gov. Greg Abbott has declined to say whether he supports the idea.

New Mexico still allows abortions under state law but at least two towns are taking a different course by trying to get rid of them.

In a move that sets up a potential conflict with state law, local officials in Clovis and Hobbs are considering banning abortion clinics from their towns. Both towns are located near the Texas border, which worries Clovis and Hobbs officials that Texans might cross the border seeking abortions in their communities.

The Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision says, “The inescapable conclusion is that a right to abortion is not deeply rooted in the nation’s history and traditions. On the contrary, an unbroken tradition of prohibiting abortion on pain of criminal punishment persisted from the earliest days of the common law until 1973.”

Tom can be reached at [email protected] and @TomRamstack

A+
a-
  • midterm elections
  • Samuel Alito Jr.
  • Supreme Court
  • In The News

    Health

    Voting

    2022 Elections

    April 4, 2023
    by Dan McCue
    Report: Failure to Embrace Center Led to Santos Victory

    WASHINGTON — A new analysis of the 2022 electoral race that elevated admitted Republican fabricator George Santos to Congress suggests... Read More

    WASHINGTON — A new analysis of the 2022 electoral race that elevated admitted Republican fabricator George Santos to Congress suggests local Democratic leaders made a series of critical blunders heading into the contest, not the least of which was not running a more centrist candidate against... Read More

    Democrat Katie Hobbs Takes Office as Arizona Governor

    PHOENIX (AP) — Katie Hobbs took the oath of office Monday to become Arizona’s 24th governor and the first Democrat... Read More

    PHOENIX (AP) — Katie Hobbs took the oath of office Monday to become Arizona’s 24th governor and the first Democrat to hold the office since 2009. Hobbs was sworn in during a private ceremony at the state Capitol as she formally took over from Republican Doug... Read More

    Democrat Wins Arizona Attorney General Race After Recount

    PHOENIX (AP) — A recount of votes has confirmed Democrat Kris Mayes narrowly defeated Republican Abraham Hamadeh in the Arizona... Read More

    PHOENIX (AP) — A recount of votes has confirmed Democrat Kris Mayes narrowly defeated Republican Abraham Hamadeh in the Arizona attorney general’s race, one of the closest elections in state history. The highly anticipated results announced Thursday in Maricopa County Superior Court are among the last... Read More

    December 22, 2022
    by Dan McCue
    McClellan Wins Democratic Nomination in Virginia’s 4th CD

    RICHMOND, Va. — Virginia state Sen. Jennifer McClellan overwhelmingly won the Democratic nomination to succeed the late A. Donald McEachin... Read More

    RICHMOND, Va. — Virginia state Sen. Jennifer McClellan overwhelmingly won the Democratic nomination to succeed the late A. Donald McEachin in Congress, garnering 84.81% of the vote, party officials announced early Thursday morning. McClellan far outdistanced her chief rival for the party’s nod, Joseph Morrissey, receiving... Read More

    December 21, 2022
    by Dan McCue
    It’s All Over but the Vote Counting in ‘Firehouse’ Primary in Va.

    RICHMOND, Va. — More than 26,400 people turned out to vote in a “firehouse” Democratic primary held in Virginia's 4th... Read More

    RICHMOND, Va. — More than 26,400 people turned out to vote in a “firehouse” Democratic primary held in Virginia's 4th Congressional District on Tuesday — so many that the party had to reportedly print as many as 10,000 additional ballots to keep up with demand. "The... Read More

    Democratic Sen. Warnock Wins Georgia Runoff Against Walker

    ATLANTA (AP) — Democratic Sen. Raphael Warnock defeated Republican challenger Herschel Walker in a Georgia runoff election Tuesday, ensuring Democrats... Read More

    ATLANTA (AP) — Democratic Sen. Raphael Warnock defeated Republican challenger Herschel Walker in a Georgia runoff election Tuesday, ensuring Democrats an outright majority in the Senate for the rest of President Joe Biden's current term and capping an underwhelming midterm cycle for the GOP in the... Read More

    News From The Well
    scroll top