Iowa Caucus Results Delayed After Struggle With New Reporting Process

February 4, 2020by Bill Ruthhart and Rick Pearson, Chicago Tribune (TNS)
Caucus participant Jarad Bernstein, who was supporting former Vice President Joe Biden, stands behind a track and field hurdle bearing Biden's name, as participant supporters for Sen. Bernie Sanders, background, wait to be counted during a satellite caucus at the Drake University field house Monday, Feb. 3, 2020, in Des Moines. A satellite caucus is held for registered voters who cannot attend their precinct's caucus site. Biden did not meet the viability threshold at this site, so Bernstein placed his support for Pete Buttigieg during realignment. (John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune/TNS)

DES MOINES, Iowa — Democrats crowded into local caucuses Monday night as Iowa embarked on its first-in-the-nation tradition of picking presidential candidates, with clear divisions along the lines of ideology and age affecting their choices.

Early entrance polls conducted for the national news networks showed Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren with support of caucusgoers who described themselves as “very liberal” as well as those age 29 and younger. Each of those groups represented about a quarter of attendees.

Among those 65 and older — about a third of those attending — caucusgoers showed a preference for former Vice President Joe Biden and former South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg, early results from the Edison Research survey showed. Buttigieg, 38, billed himself as an agent for generational change and showed some strength among younger voters as well.

Electability proved to be a major motivator for caucusgoers, with two-thirds preferring a candidate who could defeat President Donald Trump rather than just a contender with whom they agree.

Those themes emerged as thousands of Democrats turned out at nearly 1,700 precinct sites across Iowa’s 99 counties, drawn by anger at Trump as well as having a huge Democratic field from which to choose. The size of the field, along with new rules designed to ensure transparency and accuracy, were causing delays in the reporting of results by the Iowa Democratic Party.

Iowans also became the first to take sides on the future direction for a Democratic Party that finds itself plagued by a burgeoning ideological split between its progressive and more moderate wings.

Moderates contend the progressive wing represents an unrealistic overcorrection to counter Trump in November. Progressives decry the moderates as political relics in an age that requires bold structural changes and expanded social programs to counter income inequality.

In the Iowa campaign’s closing days, much of the attention on the race focused on Sanders and Warren, both progressives, and Biden and Buttigieg, who come from the party’s more moderate side. Sen. Amy Klobuchar of neighbor-to-the-north Minnesota also was looking to finish well as a more moderate candidate.

Four years ago, Hillary Clinton narrowly defeated Sanders by three-tenths of a percentage point in Iowa. Sanders looked for a chance to avenge that loss but still faces direct progressive competition from Warren.

Already, a record field of 24 contenders has been winnowed down to 11. Only seven of them actively competed in Iowa: Sanders, Warren, Biden, Buttigieg and Klobuchar, along with businessmen Andrew Yang and Tom Steyer. Billionaire Michael Bloomberg is looking at later contests, as is former Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick, Hawaii Rep. Tulsi Gabbard and Sen. Michael Bennet of Colorado.

In each of the Democrats’ last four contested nominating contests, the winner of Iowa has gone on to claim the nomination — Al Gore in 2000, John Kerry in 2004, Barack Obama in 2008 and Clinton in 2016. No Democrat has ever finished outside of the top three in Iowa and gone on to win the nomination.

On Monday, Iowa launched the grueling and expensive primary and caucus competition leading to the choice of a Democratic nominee at the party’s national convention in Milwaukee in July.

The nation’s first primary is in New Hampshire, a week from Tuesday. That’s followed by the Nevada caucuses on Feb. 22 and the South Carolina primary on Feb. 29. Super Tuesday is March 3, as 16 states and regions, including delegate-rich California and Texas, cast their votes. The Illinois primary is March 17, and by the end of next month, more than half of the convention delegates will be selected.

The large size of the Iowa field and what polls had showed to be a large number of undecided caucusgoers meant that second choices for a preference for the nomination could become very important.

Under caucus rules, a candidate must have at least 15% support from everyone in the precinct caucus to become viable. Those candidates lacking that threshold of support are deemed nonviable.

That’s when the process of realignment, or second choices, occurs.

Supporters of a nonviable candidate can join with another candidate who already is viable, join with others to try to make a nonviable candidate viable or leave the caucus site. Unlike past years, there only will be one realignment session, and people in a viable group in the first round cannot move to another candidate.

In addition, there’s a new wrinkle in how the results will be reported.

Traditionally, the winner of the caucuses was determined by a percentage of what’s known as state delegate equivalents — the apportionment of delegates to Iowa’s Democratic state convention, where its 41 delegates to the national convention are allocated.

This time around, Iowa Democrats will be releasing hard counts of attendees. There’ll be a first-round hard count — measuring how many people came out for each candidate, regardless of whether the contender was deemed viable in each precinct.

Then they’ll release a second body count, post-realignment. That will represent the totals used to determine the state delegate equivalents.

That leaves open the possibility that a candidate could win the first-round turnout tally but another contender could win the delegate percentage count —muddling who is considered the winner.

Republicans in Iowa also caucused, but Trump faced only minor opposition and The Associated Press quickly declared him the winner.

To move through Iowa and the initial states, a Democrat has to have a strong fundraising operation along with a comprehensive long national ground game.

Latest reports filed with the Federal Election Commission show that among the top-tier contenders in Iowa, Sanders was the most prolific fundraiser. Through the end of last year, Sanders took in $109 million, spent $96 million and had $18 million in the bank.

Warren raised $82 million and spent $68 million with nearly $14 million available, Buttigieg received $77 million and spent $62 million with $14.5 million, while Biden raised $61 million and spent $52 million, leaving him with $9 million in cash on hand while Klobuchar got $29 million and spent $24 million and had $5 million available, the FEC reports showed.

The seven Democrats competing in Iowa combined to spend nearly $55 million in TV ads, according to a New York Times tabulation of Advertising Analytics data.

Steyer led the way, spending $14.27 million of his fortune on TV spots, followed by Sanders with $10.1 million, Buttigieg with $9.99 million, Yang with $6.52 million, Warren with $6.14 million, Biden with $4.09 million and Klobuchar with $3.74 million. Biden’s total does not include an additional $2 million spent by a super PAC supporting his candidacy.

One topic that has received national TV attention got little notice in Iowa: Trump’s impeachment trial in Washington. His acquittal is viewed as a foregone conclusion in the GOP-led Senate, but it has served to sideline the senators competing for the nomination in recent weeks.

Those senators campaigned over the weekend but left Iowa on Sunday night for closing arguments in Trump’s Senate trial on Monday.

2020 election voter guide: Get the latest election news, analysis and opinion

Ultimately, the Democratic choice comes down to voter confidence in the electability of their candidates while looking to attract the independents and Republicans in critical states that helped Trump win election in 2016.

“One thing that’s different this time is the electability issue. It’s always been floating around but it’s really pronounced this time,” said David Yepsen, a former veteran political reporter for the Des Moines Register. “Democrats are so mad, they might like a candidate, but they’re going to go with who they think can win.”

Winning was the final sales pitch for all of the top contenders.

In a crowded bar Sunday afternoon on the west side of Des Moines, Sanders made a final plea to supporters to bring their friends, “distant cousins and those people you haven’t talked to in years” to the caucuses.

“This is the political reality: If the turnout is low, we’re gonna lose. If the turnout is high, we’re gonna win,” Sanders said. “So, our job together is to create the highest turnout in the history of the Iowa caucus.”

The caucuses represent “the beginning of the end for Donald Trump,” Sanders said to raucous applause and raised beers. “It is the beginning of a moment when we tell the billionaire class and the 1% that this country belongs to all of us, not just the few.”

Warren’s pitch in the closing days of the campaign marked a continuation of her call for “big, structural change” to the federal government. But she also pivoted to presenting herself as the best candidate to unify the progressive and more moderate wings in the party.

Wearing a hooded sweatshirt and carrying a six-pack of beer, Warren offered her final thoughts on the race at a Super Bowl party at a downtown Des Moines convention center.

“I started this a year ago, right here in Iowa, to run for president. I knew why I’d be running. I knew who I’d be running for. This is a fight I’ve been in all my life for hardworking families,” Warren said, noting she had held “a zillion” town halls, fielded hundreds of questions and taken thousands of selfies. “Iowa, you’re tough. You ask hard questions … I’m grateful for those hard questions, because you, Iowa, have made me a better candidate and you will make me a better president of the United States.”

Biden, at his final rally at a Des Moines middle school, emphasized his experience and reiterated his message that 2020 is not a time to elect a president who isn’t ready for the job. It’s an approach aimed at drawing a contrast with Buttigieg, his top competition among moderates.

“To state the obvious, the next president is going to inherit a country divided and a world in disarray,” Biden said. “There will be no time for on-the-job training. We need a president who is going to be able to lead on Day 1, who can command the world stage, lead our armed forces and repair our relationships with our allies, which are being crushed right now.”

Biden repeatedly has pointed to efforts by Trump and his surrogates to launch attacks aimed at hampering his campaign in Iowa as a sign of strength that he’s the candidate most feared by Republicans.

“There’s got to be some reason why they are so intent on me not being the nominee,” Biden said. “Folks, I promise if you stand with me, we’ll end Trump’s reign of hatred and division and unite this country.”

Buttigieg ended his Iowa campaign with an enthusiastic rally under the cavernous dome of Bowen Roundhouse Arena at Lincoln High School on the south side of Des Moines. More than 2,000 supporters frequently interrupted the former South Bend mayor with applause as he once again invoked the imagery of the sun rising over America the first day Trump is no longer president and contended his moderate approach and the generational change he represents would best unify a divided nation.

“I know how much you are weighing, even now, the importance of that influence, that thumb on the scale that you’ve got in deciding the future of the nomination and the presidency, and therefore, the country,” Buttigieg told the crowd. “And I’m here one more time, to look you in the eye, to ask you for your support so we can begin to turn the page and bring about a better day in this country.”

Beginning the race as virtually unknown to the Iowa electorate, Buttigieg reviewed the journey of his campaign, from drawing a few dozen people at a coffee shop, where his campaign manager mopped the floor afterward, to rising to the top tier of the field with a chance to win the caucuses. As he often has in the final days of his campaign, Buttigieg drew comparisons to Obama’s improbable 2008 victory in Iowa, which propelled him on a run that ended in the White House.

“Iowa, you have a beautiful, beautiful tradition of vindicating people’s hope. You have a beautiful tradition of expanding what people think is possible in our political life,” Buttigieg said in his final remarks on the trail. “The first time I ever stepped foot in this state was as a campaign volunteer, knocking on doors for a senator from Illinois, and I was here when you changed what America thought was possible.”

Like Warren and Sanders, Trump’s impeachment trial had Klobuchar off the trail for many of the race’s final days. At a Super Bowl party in a Johnston barbecue joint, Klobuchar referenced that absence in appealing to her campaign staff and volunteers to escalate their efforts in the contest’s final hours as she once again returned to Washington for closing arguments in the trial.

“I have a strong feeling that the people of Iowa understand that when I couldn’t be here all last week, that I had a job to do,” she said. “And that they get, because I wasn’t here, that you just have to double down on your work.”

Throughout the campaign there were the quadrennial concerns over whether Iowa should continue in its influential role of being the first in the nation to weigh in on the presidency, with its lack of diversity and large rural population seemingly in contrast to Democratic Party goals.

At a recent rally for Biden in Fort Madison, a city of 11,000 people tucked in the southeastern corner of the state, Mike White said people need to put the results of Monday night’s caucuses in the proper perspective.

The 71-year-old Vietnam veteran and retired factory worker said he planned to caucus for Biden, who enjoys substantial support from African Americans nationally, though their numbers are not a significant factor in Iowa.

The state’s 90% white population and its tendency to be more moderate shouldn’t have an outsized influence as a whole on the Democrats’ selection of a presidential candidate, White said.

“I tell people, ‘You need to get out of Iowa and clear your head,’” said White, who was one of just two African Americans in a crowd of about 150 people at Biden’s rally. “We’ve got to get away from this camouflage of Iowa. Look around, how many people in this room do you see that look like me? Not many. Iowa isn’t the end all be all.”


©2020 Chicago Tribune

Visit the Chicago Tribune at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

2020 Elections

Rep. Neal Eyes Massive Coronavirus Relief, Climate and Infrastructure Package
Rep. Neal Eyes Massive Coronavirus Relief, Climate and Infrastructure Package

WASHINGTON — House Ways and Means Chairman Richard E. Neal's attitude toward legislating under a Democratic-led White House might aptly be described as "never let a crisis go to waste." The Massachusetts Democrat wants to take a page from his party's 2009 playbook, when the Obama administration took office amid the wreckage of... Read More

Opening of 117th Congress Will be Different Due to Pandemic
Opening of 117th Congress Will be Different Due to Pandemic

WASHINGTON — When the 117th Congress convenes in January, COVID-19 precautions will prevent the 435 House members from gathering in the chamber together, so opening day festivities of swearing in members and electing the speaker will look a little different. House leaders have begun discussing how to carry out... Read More

Mnuchin to Put $455 Billion in Funds Out of Yellen's Easy Reach
Mnuchin to Put $455 Billion in Funds Out of Yellen's Easy Reach

WASHINGTON — Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin will put $455 billion in unspent Cares Act funding into an account that his presumed successor, former Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen, will need authorization from Congress to use. Mnuchin plans to place the money into the agency's General Fund, a Treasury Department spokesperson said Tuesday. That fund... Read More

Lawmakers a Step Closer to Averting Dec. 11 Government Shutdown
Lawmakers a Step Closer to Averting Dec. 11 Government Shutdown

WASHINGTON — Top appropriators reached bipartisan agreement Tuesday on a framework for an omnibus spending package that would avoid a partial government shutdown next month. The compromise forged between the leaders of the House and Senate Appropriations committees sets spending allocations for the dozen bills that fund federal agencies... Read More

Trump Gives Biden Access to Daily Intelligence Briefings
White House
Trump Gives Biden Access to Daily Intelligence Briefings

WASHINGTON — President-elect Joe Biden will begin to get the nation's most classified intelligence after the White House signed off Tuesday on providing him the Presidential Daily Briefing as the transition moves forward. The incoming president getting access to the top-secret briefing is the most high-profile part of the transition and... Read More

Stabenow Says Smaller Coronavirus Relief Bill Better Than Nothing
Stabenow Says Smaller Coronavirus Relief Bill Better Than Nothing

WASHINGTON — A top Senate Democrat said Tuesday that she's engaged in bipartisan discussions on COVID-19 aid and urged quick action even if that means "a short-term package for the next few months." "We need to act," said Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D- Mich., the fourth-ranking Democrat in that chamber... Read More

News From The Well
scroll top